Adam The God

We lost 2%+ with those late concessions. Pity.

Yep, I rather hope Max is fit.

I'm much more worried about Freo next week, because not only are their rucks better, but their midfield is better. Agree on Fullarton though. The nuffy on SEN comparing Petty to Weideman. Fullarton is a lot more reminiscent of the Weid. People just like to complain though.

Just watched the replay. Outside of a 5 minute period in the third where he failed to bring the ball to ground and Essendon mopped up 2 v 1 a couple fo times, Petty was fine. People just have a bias. JVR was really solid in the ruck and Turner probably played his best game. Super excited about a Disco/JVR tandem for the foreseeable future. I also think ultimately, Petty will go back and hopefully Jefferson can cement a spot forward.

In the centre square, he was ordinary as a ruck, particularly in the first half... as I acknowledged in my first post. I'm watching the replay now and his follow up work around the ground is fine.

His name was Rob. I heard him too. King of the nuffies. Not many supporter groups would call up and whinge about a player after a great win. Probably one of those MCC supporters that yells kick it every seconds. No feel for the game at all. That's not to say I'm not excited about Jefferson and I think he'll play this year.

Post some more please. We could do with less mindless negativity on here.

Who won? 12+ in clearances. Off you pop.

I think if we see it for 4 of the next 6 weeks, we'll play finals. I'm not sure we will, but let's see.

We didn't hold our own in clearances, we spanked them. Otherwise, I agree mate.

Go you redlegs! Goody coached the pants off Brad Scott, who is no slouch himself. Smashed them in clearances - 12+. The ruck role is seriously the most overrated role in the game. Anyway, beautiful around the ground stoppage set ups, massive props to McQualter too. We consistently set everyone up on the back of the contest knowing we could either hit the contest hard from there or stop their chaining out in the opposite direction. Such good coaching. Windsor and McVee are going to be elite players. JT is a genius. Both are so clean at ground ball. And if you can do that in the driving rain, you can always do it. Serious talents. Kolt showed some really good signs. Kozzy so dangerous around stoppage and his forward pressure was sublime. Rivers' early disposal was pretty iffy, but he knows how to win the contest and knows where to go to win the ball. I think with more time in there, his disposal under heat will get better. That's 5 guys 22 or under who are starting to majorly impact games every week. Add JVR to that conversation too, and Bowser and AMW are playing their roles too. The decision to play Petty was vindicated and when Petty struggled in the centre bounces early, Disco hitting the scoreboard meant we could afford JVR in the ruck more. I was more confident about tonight than next week, but we've put ourselves back in with a chance of not only playing finals, but ridiculously, top 4. Let's see how we go.

Ace.

Great post mate. IMO, it's no coincidence that the week Melksham comes back in, JVR gets the 2nd and 3rd best defender and gets a look at 8 shots on goal. If Melksham can play his role, it frees up either JVR or Fritta and we become much more dangerous in the forward half.

That's fine. Let's just win.

I'd love to know, it's become incredible this stat to me. I keep expecting them to [censored] the bed, but they still haven't yet.

Yep, @Gator is an excellent poster.

Turner has rucked in at least 2 or 3 games now. He did some rucking last week for example. I agree I'd prefer JVR forward, but he does go through patches of the game where the ball doesn't go near him. In those circumstances, I'd prefer to get him involved around the footy. So a bit of a case by case basis.

I think it'll more likely be 50/50 Petty and Turner tbh. Goody signalled in his presser that we have to balance JVRs dominance as a forward vs rucking him.

His track record. Or ridiculous claims like this when recently out of the game - https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/former-richmond-assistant-coach-david-king-declares-the-tigers-a-certainty-for-afl-top-eight-in-2011/news-story/eda5d63e30819aa35bf90014d0650476 He's a click chaser. That's his job.

Was exactly my thinking. Great post mate. King hasn't played at the elite level for 20 years and hasn't coached for close to 15 years. He's knowledgeable based on his access to Champion Data stats, but his analysis is very iffy.

Jetts for me. Absolute star. Loved Wheels' toughness too, don't recall him having much more speed than Jetts (who had little).

Exactly how I would have gone and how I thought we'd go. Petty, JVR and Disco 10 minutes each per quarter. Happy with this and excited to see how we go with it.

I figured the Murray connection with Dazzle.

I wonder if someone like Shai Bolton could be prized out of Richmond, given his age (25) and their impending predicament. He'd compliment our midfield beautifully and partner our smalls and talls forward of centre. He's signed til 2028, but you never know. Richmond are going to be in for some pain and need to maximise the next 2 drafts before Tassie come in.

If we set up any deeper, we won't be on the field at all. Our defensive zone for most of the year has been deep because we've been trying to slingshot into the space created the other way. I'd actually like us to go the other way and play a more aggressive, in your face style against Essendon. I'd rather us play the more explosive, combative style that we played against Brisbane. The old Richmond style, take territory with the ball, and push up at the ball carrier when not in possession. The difficult thing to predict is what sort of effect does not having Max have on our contest game. Does it make it easier to play the combative game or harder? I'd say harder because we don't have the ascendancy in the ruck, so to play the percentages, we may well sit our zone deep and look to intercept and go the other way. The wet weather won't help those attempts though.