Jump to content

beelzebub

Life Member
  • Posts

    39,587
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    83

Everything posted by beelzebub

  1. The wannabe revisionists are still at work. Gil is still the Dill and Madigan is a .... ( insert word of choice )...mine's irrelevant FYI. It's almost funny
  2. Yes, I'm not sure who snuck the footy in here
  3. THIS ^^^^ In a nutshell we are a 2nd Back, a 2nd Fwd and about 2-3 mids short of a highly competitive team. Some we already possibly have on our list but arent developed yet. Others will be hunted down at seasons end ( well ...hunted now...got late ..lol )
  4. Really Laughable. He's far from perfect
  5. I know very well WHAT it's asks. I strangely enough can fathom that. You chose to get clever and pedantic and fell on your derriere my friend. All of DL is opinion. But the question was framed. You want to box clever.... Fine. I have no problems with opinions. I have one myself. I suggest decision on players by clubs ought to be disparate, no emotional aspect. I.e what is best for club. As this game goes on players will move around more and more. I'm about Melbourne. Not fussed ( other than Druggies) who plays. It's about the jumper.
  6. I know its only humour.. but the notion of Jab suing the Awful as result of losing the Brownlow... Wouldnt happen.
  7. The question of the poll does not say ...in your opinion. It's asks is he tradable. Your opinion will lead to an answer but if you're going to argue as a pedant. Get it right Id suggest.
  8. And that always explains why he can kick a ball out of bounds when looking to pass upfield... or straight to an opponent. Or getting pinged through a lack of awareness. He does some absolute shockers at times which bely otherwise good sense. Again , he seems more than capable of these movements at training. The problems with a stats especially one like 80% efficiency is firstly..its krap as the criteria is as dodgy as all hell. But even going with it that 20% that isnt often comes flying back as scoreboard punishment. TMac will undoubtedly be persevered with. That wasnt the actual question of the OP. Im sure other clubs may feel him out. The club should at least hear them out.
  9. It's little steps...but progress
  10. Does poor offensive work become very much more a matter when combined with resultant opposition scoring ? Im not alone in observing that in training and 'easier' games he seems more on the mark (sts) Step up the pressure and his offensive game goes to shlt. What use is that.....really.... In all seriousness.
  11. Maybe not directly , maybe provide currrency to shop eleswhere. It's a maybe
  12. Quite frankly the relevant factor is what would you get as a result ? If it betters our side then THAT alone is the criteria.
  13. Youre not alone Selecting seemed "different' in the preseason Seemed more purposeful i.e horses for courses
  14. It ought to be straight forward, it ought to require not much more effort than observing the rules. However, for poor Gil ... it's so hard ...
  15. Simple really isnt it.
  16. correct. It should be very straight forward if ( read WHEN ) required )
  17. to suggest he isnt tradable is more lauaghable Youre missing the point
  18. i'm going to suggest something unpalatable to some. That not all players turn up 100% to each and every game ( who'd d a thunk huh ) T Mac for mine is definitely in this group. Some games he's far more switched on and his t/o's are less and kicking better and He's "ON" Many other games he's like playing 90% and all sorts of errors come flooding back. In some areas we've seen his ceiling, in others he still has a way to improve. Its between the ears....again question is...what is between his ears !!
  19. Ay ..here's the rub eh It's not if, but what. What do you want?what coukxyou get, what benefit / improvement for doing so ? These are what governs a trade. Not if. Of course he is.
  20. For mine the question posed is .. Is he tradable ? Of course he is. Another question might be ... Would you ? I'd listen to offers before making a stance.
  21. 3-4 is the new 4-6 !!
×
×
  • Create New...