jumbo returns

Haha! With Arnie Feather...

Wouldn't it be funny if JW got up to make his speech and declared he's staying??! Wowee! Biggest moment since the bomb hit No 96 and Mr and Mrs Gondolfus were written out of the show!

Let's line up the next scapegoats: Will it be.... a) Oscar Mac b) Bernie c) Melksham d) Tommy Mac wait! e) Dom Tyson or...will Col Garland get the blame for everything?

It's going to happen, Slim - off to Geelong I reckon #10 and #20 will be used for Lever

I reckon he can become a sensational midfielder

Awesome Another 'rebuild' Don't think I can take anothereee

You softened, Ben?

[censored]

Ffs

Never fully recovered from his hammy injury - whether that was from poor management or poor rehab practice Before that, was playing some fantastic footy

Fine There was no need for him to continue

They could be right, they could be wrong I don't support the club blindly - I think they're making the wrong call here Call him in and say 'here are your limitations - work on them, or you'll be traded or playing at Casey' .....then, don't blurt it out to all and sundry Allow JW to process the conversation and act accordingly, or fall by the wayside If I remember correctly, many moons ago, the FD called in David Neitz and gave him some home truths - as we all know, he duly delivered Watts has been treated poorly Let's agree to disagree

In your opinion So......keep the closing interview and feedback inhouse Do not critique a player in public and leave him out to dry

It's sad the way he's been treated, not his imminent departure

Yes we do - we all know, as does Ch 7, Fox Footy, Talking Footy, RSN, Trade Radio The coach told everyone What closed doors???

Supporters are emotional enough without the extra combustibles....

Because he's mindful of not talking down a fellow player in public I suppose that's okay for our FD though...

What do I expect the club to say? - Sweet FA You say that 'other clubs aren't dumb', so why say anything at all? Just seems dumb and dumber that if you want to trade a player, you wouldn't talk them down But, I'm glad that this scenario excites you no end

What's subjective? You think it's a good move by the club, who wants to move him on, to open up all his limitations in a public forum? Sounds dumb and poorly handled to me

Keep it inhouse Don't reveal closing interviews and feedback to players to Ch 7, RSN, Ch 9, AFL Media, etc etc

Genuine question: Why is this whole scenario played out in a public forum to humiliate and 'devalue' a player that is clearly not wanted? I do see a correlation between your username and Wattsy's relationship with the bosses at the MFC

School holidays

So.......has he gone yet?

Really?

I'm frustrated by Jack's performances, but his early development goes a long way in explaining some of these frustrations But, his last two or three years have been very good, despite the contrary opinion/s Anyhoo, is he staying or going?