adonski

Some truth in that, but even top 4 sides put out some absolute duds on any given weekend

I mean both Brayshaw and Harmes had career best years under Goodwin, probably Melksham too. Brayshaw & Harmes are victims of playing under Viney. Melksham is anyones guess, with T Mac & Jetta just physically cooked.

We got overs for Frost even when considering Hawthorn's pick will be pushed to roughly the 8th round in the draft

Forgetting Brayshaw, Harmes is faster, bigger, better defensively & a better decision maker in the contest than Jack. Gotta take the emotion out of the name!

I think we may find in time, that Rivers may have been worth the first rounder alone

Thoughts on Bailey Laurie

Big yes if the price is right

Williams should be able to chip in all going well

Could Bradbury the finals and a Brownlow medalist

Well he has something over Harmes then! Who we persisted with down there for 14 odd rounds

Jack leaving would be a massive win if it allowed us to bring a ready made winger (Williams or similar in). Fills a need and also lifts the output of Brayshaw & Harmes.

You're all stuck in the Goodwin school of stubbornness - embrace the vision!

It is time to make the shift, Goodwin - We should be using Spargo as our budget Caleb Daniel, Good kicking (albeit not penetrating) High footy IQ Good decision making, composure Not afraid of the rough stuff But lacks the X-factor & explosiveness to thrive as a small forward. 2021, the year of the Spargo.

Jack almost seemed to deliberately avoid giving it off to certain people in the game. Maybe I’m just reading too much into it!

Looked confident tonight. Great to see him more involved in the play. Give me Pickett & Riv over another inside mid any day...

In: Harmes, Lockhart, Hibberd Out: Viney (Geelong), Jetta, Smith

6 - May 5 - Trac 4 - Langdon 3 - Rivers 2 - Kossie 1 - Salem

Burnt Trac there

Hero ball again from Viney

We'd have to give up a future first for a B grader. Not sure.

I was expecting about 2 comments. Defs overs.

Cogs dropped

Effort only goes so far. Retaining Jack backs the effort philosophy, in retaining a player who constantly gives their all. Letting him go backs the talent...allows Brayshaw to play a bigger role & getting a highly rated player in through the draft who may have a higher ceiling than Jack. It's an interesting one.

Surely if Jack goes, we then go hard for Williams with the cap room, then take the pick to the draft for the best outside player/small forward available. The old 2 for 1...!