DubDee

wow that is stark in think I get why we are playing poorly now. loss of talent and playing kids

Can’t wait to the Kolt go again. Had a tough debut, like many before him. worked hard at Casey. Deserves another call up

The primary argument for keeping Petty is there is no one to bring in. despite his horrible form. he has the potential to play well unlike BB who’s body is done not saying I agree but all the hand wringing is silly given our lack of options

Good changes Good to see two kids and Tommo come in Billings held accountable too. he is turning out to be a bust

I don't agree that Trac is mentally soft. quite the opposite Yep, I could see Moore or Sidebottom doing the same thing Not a Viney or Maynard though I agree with your last comment of course, they were far more committed and wanted it more

yeah soft as Trac just played on with broken ribs and ruptured spleen not physically or mentally soft, our Trac. He is just able to differentiate during game with pre or post game

We certainly need some energy and enthusiasm within the group so I think this debut is a great call

I hear Malthouse and Cornes don't rate Brown (trying to get some posts going)

Kid who’s shows good potential. flexible and a good mark. Wish he could get a run of games together glad he wants to stay

Good lord, bevo would be a nightmare. maybe try dreaming of fembots instead of crowbots

things are so bad we can’t even find joy in a father son debuting? The clubs development of young players has been very good, I trust them that he’s ready Good luck Browny junior

So we could have around $650 free in the cap next year to sign someone. this in addition to retirements land a big fish please!

Remember the old days when DL posters used to bag Jordon and ask for him to be dropped Now he is the missing link guess i shouldn’t be surprised

So you suggesting our captain cracked it and was thinking of himself rather than the team? This is bloke that united us and got our first flag in almost 60 years. Deliberately staying on the bench during the GF so a kid could stay on. Gawn is a selfless team first man.

how many teams do you know play two dominant first rucks who can’t play fwd? Schache was brought in to cover for Weid leaving as you would know

ok. why we didn’t make it work? we tried it for many games. neither is a forward. We made a big change by Gawn not being first ruck always what didn’t we try? sometimes stuff doesn’t work but at least we tried something different

I reckon Goodwin has done a lot different this season, the problem is not much of it has worked Players playing in different positions, change to game plan, playing kids, imports. Not sure what is left to try or more so what we could actually deliver on

A player we traded out is playing well for another team Get over it. Never heard so much whinging in my life. We got him in, it didn't work. Move on

he is doing very well. good on him weird thread

who cares about the start of the game? Gawn played plenty of time fwd last year. He had zero impact 2 rucks was a disaster. i can’t believe i need to argue this

I get the frustration but Woey is a developing young player. He had a couple of full games and was poor. Understandably dropped. Has made an impact as sub so he continued as such. Then dropped as needed some full game time. Not a travesty just a young player being developed. Just how Jordon, Sparrow, Bowey, etc etc were developed. We have been excellent in this area under Goody

you think anyone would come to us if we keep players against their will? can we be real?

Collingwood signed him to a 10 year deal and mis-counted the money and had to ship him out for almost nothing with 5 years to go

better than Gawn? lol not even close so you think we should play them together like last year? please answer the question

recruiting him for a second rounder or trading him out for second rounder. what’s your specific issue? clearly he didn’t work as a fwd and clearly we already have the best ruck in the league. I personally thought he was worth the risk with very limited fwd options to trade in