Although, I totally agree with his delisting, and think it was at least 3 years overdue (i acknowledge he got the best out of himself however), why was he delisted and not offered for trade?

I know he gained some respect in the media and may have been a tagging option for another club.

I thought maybe we could have received something for him (and another player) or at least tried to help him find a new club.

Or dont you think a club would have coughed anything up for him or are happy to wait for the draft?

Although, I totally agree with his delisting, and think it was at least 3 years overdue (i acknowledge he got the best out of himself however), why was he delisted and not offered for trade?

I know he gained some respect in the media and may have been a tagging option for another club.

I thought maybe we could have received something for him (and another player) or at least tried to help him find a new club.

Or dont you think a club would have coughed anything up for him or are happy to wait for the draft?

Geelong traded players instead of delisting them, however let's not kid ourselves. Who in their right mind would have given up even pick 90 for Simon Godfrey.

Geelong traded players instead of delisting them, however let's not kid ourselves. Who in their right mind would have given up even pick 90 for Simon Godfrey.

Haha....Point taken...although Carlton and Denis Pagan might have in that year he recruited those duds....(or years)

I guess there's an argument to say that you should hang on to everyone until the end of trade week, so you have the opportunity to trade rather than delist guys you're not interested in.

However, if players are not delisted until after trade week they are unable to nominate for the national draft (and are only eligible fot the PSD).