1. James McDonald

2. Nathan Jones

3. Matthew Bate

4. Brad Green

5. Aaron Davey

Top 4 is about right

No idea how Davey came 5th, but it was a shocking year for us

Would love to see the rest of the top 10

Anyone know where Sylvia came?

surprised no white

and didnt robbo get top brownlow votes for us?

surprised no white

and didnt robbo get top brownlow votes for us?

I would have thought White would have been close

what about bell he had an awesome year.

How the f ck did Davey make the top 5? He was very dissapointing this year, in fact Im not sure he even played 11 good games, let alone 22.

Bell's very stiff to miss out on a top five spot. I'd say he was probably ahead of Bate and definately head and shoulders above Davey. I know not many of our players had a great year, but off the top of my head I can think of a few who deserve to be there ahead of Davey; Carrol, Sylvia, White, Neitz (despite having a forgettable year), none of them set the world on fire but they contributed more than Davey. I know Im not going to be popular for saying this, but I'd almost say Godfrey was more useful than Davey this year.

Im a bit surprised Jones didnt win it, but I'm not confused or bothered by it; if they hadnt given it to him I would have thought JMac was a close second, and I can see why some people might put him first. But Davey making the top five has me absolutely stumped.