Red Card Rule

1 hour ago, monoccular said:

 

 

All sounds good, though should it be totally outcome related?    A king hit is a king hit (poor term I know as nothing noble about it).

And the sin binned player should not be replaced - ie the offending team plays one short.

But it would have to be blatant stuff, as there are some 'line ball' things like the Moloney Bartell "incident" where contact wasn't even made but Moloney was ousted.

I would suggest it has to be like for like but only on potential concussion related incidents mono.

If the player on the receiving end is off for a concussion test (as determined by a neutral AFL doctor only) then the offending player also sits out the mandatory 20 minute assessment (no replacement ...opposing team is also 1 player down).

If the player potentially concussed is then deemed fit and eligible to return the sin bin on offending player is lifted.