Search the Community

12 Demons played against a Willy side that had not one AFL-list player. If you include Troy Davis, a very reliable defender last year, we had 13 players who should be very prominent and confident. We lost by 80 points. I know some of you are blaming the standard of the Casey lads this year and some of you just reckon our fringe Melbourne players are crap. But you don't lose that badly without something not being right. Quite obviously Rowan Welsh has lost them and I suspect Brett Allison's highly critical player reviews would be losing some as well. You don't bag players in public as Allison has been doing. Some may also be questioning how Dom Barry, with just nine disposals (eight in Allison's review) and two tackles gets great praise for a game in which he quelled the influence of Sam Iles, who is so good, he is not on a list anymore! That is not to say I'm not pleased that Dom will get a chance to see if he can lift at a higher level, but there would be 10 guys in that side who would have felt aggrieved at his promotion ahead of them. Here's my remedy. 1) Give Brett Allison the next month off doing reviews - he's about as positive as Mark Neeld. 2) Get Jade Rawlings in to take over from Welshy for the rest of the season - the players all respect Rawlings. He will clearly give them Roosy's gameplan and the players will have confidence that he has Roosy's ear when it comes to selection. 3) If we are not broke, lure a couple of in-form players from country or amo's on a three or four-game trial basis with the aim of having a look at them to see if they might be up to AFL rookie list level next season.