old dee

Must be the hardest place in southern Australia to get to. The quick answer is no. Interesting in today's Hun we won one. Story on Simon Buckley and his poor driving record and they listed him as X Collingwood player

bb I am about to commit suicide by naming them. With a couple of proviso's The gods will fall upon me but here goes. Davis - Has had plenty of time and cannot kick Nicholson - Fast and gets the ball but cannot kick Jetta - has had a lot of injuries but he will need a big 2013 to justify keeping IMO Bail - cannot kick J McDonald - cannot kick Davey - past it I think and contract up at 30+ Fitzpatrick - had a long time on the list and little to show he can make it at AFL level. In danger group Tapscott - have yet to see what he brings besides aggression Sylvia - Probably off under free agency Gawn- needs to prove his body can stand up to AFL football this season. Now I will wait for the wrath of Demonland to descend.

No footballs

Board Chairman Redleg

be as critical as you like Bossdog The comment is based on at the end of the 2012 season we had IMO at best 20 players that were AFL standard or of a quality that would allow us to play finals football. We changed 14 for season 2013. There are a couple like Rivers that walk because they wanted out that I am confident we would have kept. That leaves 6 - 8 at min. that IMO need to be moved on at the end of 2013. Lets not kid ourselves the list is still far from wonderful

I don't believe in curses, bad luck etc Redleg But gee do we every get a good break. It just shows how important it is to have good depth in your list. Another 7-8 need to be changed again at the end of 2013

RtG As I see it at least half the list at the end of 2012 was below AFL standard or at the least unable to get us into finals football. You only have to look at the results over 2011 -12. We replaced 14 at the end of 2012 and I think there is at min. another 8 to go. Nothing I saw in the team that played Richmond on Friday night suggested there are not still plenty below the required standard. This year when all are fit I would say we have an improved best 22 but after they we still fall away badly. IMO to be a side capable of playing finals football you need 30 - 32 players of good quality IMO we are still way short of that mark.

Only my opinion RtG I just say it as I see it. The result show I think I am close to the money.

It is every game If you cannot kick in today's game you are a liability. When JM struggles to make the 22 we will be a good side. How come he never gets injured and the good players do. I would swap him for Trengove in a heart beat

I thought you predicted 2 losses Redleg. Fairly confident it is not your fault we still have a lot of players who are way behind on skill Another 7-8 changed again at the end of this year will help. Lets not forget we are trying to undo 7-8 years of poor selections in a couple of years. We have at least one or two more to go to get back to where we should have been at the start of 2011

You never cease to bring a smile to my face dc God don't leave

He was one of a very few that looked the quality of the opposition H_T Seems like I was wrong The sad part is he won't play in the real games and with his loss I would say we would be barely better than last year. Same old same old to me tonight H_T On that form we have no hope against Port next week. Only 22nd Feb and the year looks very long already The only upside I saw tonight was we won't get accused of tanking in 2013

How is the date tonight dc?

Now there is an interesting organisation Bbo

Always thought us micks were banned anyway But perhaps my mum made that up

Has not worried the previous members for the last couple of millennium Bbo

Don't think you have any chance Biff Your morals are way to high

Should have seen that coming. My excuse I am a little tired after a tough day and a very ordinary Tuesday and Wednesda. But e are going to win tomorrow so the weekend is looking up

That is a very old one 90% of people on here would not know what a conductor was You are dating yourself Bbo

Sounds like the only thing that has dc!

Decided last night that it is time to move on dc. what is done is done there is bugger all I can do about any of it. why belong to something that only gives you grief . So lets get on with season 2013 and hope for some joy from the MFC. Surely it has to be better than 2012 doesnt it? I have zero confidence for tomorrow night but hell it has to be better than the last 12 months. Go Dees

Spot on H_T There is a ways to go in this farce. Until we rid ourselves of the enemy within we are going nowhere fast. What happens if these same people ring the gaming commission?

I think mine surrendered on February 19th 2013.Why does everyone around me have on white coats!

I don't think 1 banana has done it for me. Still looks to be the same god unholy mess as when I retired last night but now we have a gambling commission investigation. Not much fun left in being a Dees supporter. wonder what else I could do in winter that offers less pain.

Don't think I have a reply WJ