We are in the premiership window.
Losing Hogan is bad. Hogan is better than lever and Melbourne was in a much better position than adalaide (contracted vs uncontracted)
I think minimum is neale compensation, plus their first and brayshaw with seconds going back the other way.
Trading is "player worth" plus what the team can pay. Hogan is worth more than picks 4 and 5 and freo can pay if they want him.
For those arguing differently one year of hogan may be the difference between a premership or not. And if he stays for one year he could stsay for more.
Anyway i hope we keep him