I'm a critic of his.
I also have a jumper with his number on the back of it too.
For me he is over rated, he was flying years ago and then the last few years has been quite average.
His disposal is poor to good, he went to playing a more outside game than he use to (but seems to be going a lot harder again thankfully)
But for some one who had great skills and talent galore he has not lived up to the standards he himself set years ago.
That hit from Guerra pretty much sent his career backwards.
He is touted as a captain and I personally have never thought he has shown enough to warrant to be a captain of the club and even when standing in over the last few years I have not seen anything to make me think otherwise.
I am happy that he was started to get back to that level and I hope he gets better again,
Is he a champion.....No.
Is he a great Melbourne player, yeah I'd stick him there, but not A Great.