Jump to content

Sir Why You Little

Life Member
  • Posts

    46,434
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    74

Everything posted by Sir Why You Little

  1. Quite Possibly. Both Roos and Goodwin dropped him he had numerous chances
  2. Jack was always on the edge this year after being unfit in the preseason
  3. Looks like that slime bag Waldron was right
  4. It is not a pass mark if you have factored in those last 2 results. It was a choke. Same as the year before
  5. West Coast this year...
  6. It’s not always just the stats ‘39 a lot of Jones kicks are turnovers, i wish they weren’t.
  7. Yeah. Good Point Marketing is a huge problem. Has been for years. We don’t use the name “Melbourne” at all well It is a massive advantage that we seem to shy away from...
  8. You are probably dead right. But the Senior Coach is the first in the firing line
  9. But you are not factoring in that in Round 22 we were 6 goals in front and then stopped (almost) against the bottom side, and then Round 23 The Filth were down about 9 players and smashed us in the first Quarter, Game over. Goodwin better learn from it fast and get it right because so far he has failed, and considering he had 2 years under Lord Roos to learn all he could, this is very concerning
  10. And what happened the week after ‘39? that also tells us a lot. This club has had a lack of continuity for decades, win a big game and then fall over once expectation is generated. I don’t think Jones is mentally strong enough to right that sickness. I wish he was, this is not a personal attack at all. But what happened in Round 23 this year was so predictable and it is why i was very concerned when the club made that video of Jones gearing up for the finals and showing it in July/ August. We hadn’t done the work yet. A video like that gets shown this week....
  11. Jesus Chook you are in for a long year. Personally i was glad Gawny was flat and shattered in that video drive to improve
  12. Speak to Cameron Schwab he was the soft one who dumped copious amount of crap on the club. The club is mentally soft, yes. We all know that The rest of what you ask is strange. Were you around for the Northey years?
  13. Dr. G. You just cannot say it was a good effort overall with the performances of Round 22 & 23 as they were. We were in the finals and took the foot off the gas before the end That must be unacceptable at all times, otherwise we are all wasting our time. Imagine this week if WE were painting the CBD Red and Blue as Tiger Supporters are doing to Richmond. Goodwin as Senior Coach still has massive problems on Game Day, Pre Match. The team is just not prepared correctly. Yes i saw some improvement this year, but overall it was a failure, that can be fixed, but i don’t want to hear about our young list again. AFL is a young persons sport. Toughen up or fail
  14. Good Captains thrive in September pressure. Infact the really good Captains help create that intense pressure to break games open. I can see Jack Viney doing just that in time Nathan Jones i cannot...
  15. What a truly strange topic, i mean really, what is it’s purpose??
  16. I questioned the same thing. But who makes the call? A player maybe borderline ready. Is it Goodwin's Call or Misson's? i wouldn't imagine Misson would be allowing players back early as it's bad for his name interesting...
  17. Well then be ready for another year just like the last 2....
  18. Having 2 Captains means neither is 100% in charge. It's time
  19. This^^ Jones is a great bloke. No arguement at all but Zac would beat him in the backyard he is too nice
  20. That's how i have always seen Jones, as a good solid contributing player. Many people will be offended by that, but so be it. It is one of the many reasons why the MFC has failed for so many years 2017 ended exactly the same as 2016 even though we won 2 more games for the season. When the pressure was turned up to almost maximum, the MFC capitulated without a whimper. That is all about lack of leadership. We need 1 Captain who will stand up and demand excellence in all areas of the game. Jones has been there long enough and his best is just not enough.
  21. We agree to disagree...Jones goes missing when the heat is turned up far too often for my liking. Great Captains thrive on serious pressure
  22. God help us all when he retires....
  23. Jones is not a natural leader, never has been. He has tried hard, but it is not his thing. Let's be brutal here, The Gold Coast were an unravelling shambles this year. They gave no resistance in that 3rd Quarter. We need more than that Viney will play like Cotchin did last Saturday given the right team around him...
  24. Viney is the player who pulled us over the line in 2 games this year, both when he was injured. Meth Coke and Port Games. Jones has never done that. Viney has learnt quick, he is ready
×
×
  • Create New...