BDA

Adem yze is the one that got away. He should be our head coach and we let him walk out the door

I won’t defend any of our senior players Gawn gives his all but he is not a driver of standards Viney tries hard but stitched the club when negotiating his last contract. Tim Lamb stuff up that one Trac is no leader. Threw a massive tanty last year about standards. he's all bout himself. He's not invested The Clarry we know and love is a distant memory. The current version is miles off it I think both Trac and clarry should be moved on Keep viney to lead the young lads. Gawn is a legend but I’m not sure captain should be his go anymore (no idea who takes over. Lever preferably but he is too injury prone now) And Goody might be trying his best but I’m afraid its no where near good enough. No instruction from the sidelines yesterday as the game turned against us. Kossie and Melks on the bench. His coaching was putrid. He’s been there 9 years. A strong coach does not allow player power to take hold. that's on him as much as anyone A big broom required and clear the lot of them out

Its character building for the lad.

I’m not on social media Hopefully the blowtorch comes from the media as well

Maybe not Our supporter base is quite docile. The few tragics on this site are not representative. There will be no revolt from the faithful just a shrug of the shoulders I reckon.

So you’re not going to give him a chance? Him and Brad greens would be in regular communication I’m sure. The next month or so vital for us. He will have to have a plan. If no change to the sen coach at seasons end we’ll have our answer

We’re in self flagellation mode. It’s just part of the process of coming to terms with where we’re at again

I'll be speaking to membership this morning. I'll renew when we have a new senior coach it's the only leverage i have at this stage normally i'm pretty good at moving on from defeats but this is different. we need big changes. will tune out for the rest of this week until gameday. no point wallowing in misery when i can't do anything to effect change

I actually think Steve Smith is a very good option as president. Kate Roffey was totally out of her depth so he'll be a big improvement there Pert was an absolute [censored]. a disaster for us. Why oh why didn't we back in Jacksons choice Mahoney I know nothing of the CEO. No background in AFL does not give me confidence. We need a new senior coach and major surgery throughout the FD. Tall order for Guerra to come in and sort that ****show out without AFL experience Very sad where we've ended up.

He could be referring to the govt work done by the big 4 consultancies such as PWC. Very shoddy and very expensive

[censored] the bed against the pies in the last round in 2017. pies with nothing to play for missed the finals by the smallest percentage margin ever

I'm sick of chocco milking us to top up his super. he can pack his bags as well. i'd let chaplin be interim coach

.

I can understand if he's re-assessing his options that said, he's had a really poor year so he won't be inundated with offers from other clubs

any mail on who our next senior coach might be?

please don't replace one coach that drove a premiership winning team into the ground with another no thanks

the 4th quarter fade outs have been happening all year he needs to go as well

i think members will vote with their wallets no change of coach no membership renewal and besides, after today's shambles, a lot of supporters won't turn up anyways

On Gawn and i know this won't be popular Uploading a social media post of your son singing the Carlton song after they've embarrassed you is not funny. And its not cute. Or cuddly. it's embarrassing actually. I thought it demeaned the club and your role as captain maybe i need to chill a little but it really grated with me this week.

Clarry kicking it out on the full when a point would have put 2 kicks between the team late its so sad to see where he's at. From a champion to this. i'm falling into a depression this evening

I've never considered withholding membership renewal. after that capitulation i can understand why members would do it. i know there is a monetary penalty involved but the cost of not sacking him will be far greater. Another wasted year is not worth the financial hit from paying him out This club is so [censored] amatuer

what do you think of the coaching Bing

Best to go now Simon. you are tarnishing your legacy

Congratulations St Kilda. Stuck at it and won a famous victory Weak pathetic last quarter from us I hope the media apply the blowtorch to the entire club. We deserve it There are no standards. Our fitness team need to be dismissed tomorrow morning. Goodwin and the FD needs to be cleared out Clarry has to go, probably trac as well 4 years from the flag to this I’m disgusted and heart broken to see this

great tackle spargo