Captains' pick competition

I proposed this in the intraclub thread and then tried it myself and it's incredibly complex and insightful. 

Self-quote sorry: "I no longer care about injuries (in terms of our season rather than the personal impact on players) so would love to see the teams divided evenly and let them go at it on the MCG. Maybe for the sake of entertainment in lieu of no football (the remaining fixtures for today just rub salt into the wound) we can run some captains' pick modelling between Viney and Gawn?" 

I did a coin-toss and Gawn goes first. 

Gawn:

Viney:

Gawn:

Viney:

 . . . .

I have no clear idea how this competition could run for those interested. Maybe we could nominate two avatar captains who have the final say and the rest of us debate each selection before it's made? My initial instinct was to stack the mid-field and select the best players, but then KPPs come into the equation and who might work best with who. It's definitely a challenge. 

Let's assume everyone is injury-free. When does Max go for ruck shut-out? Who do you think Viney thinks is the best alongside him in the middle? At what point do you build your spine  while sacrificing your engine? It somehow gives some insight to the questions the recruitment department have to face. 

Anyone interested in playing?