CatFishPig

5 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Not agreeing or disagreeing with you but who would be your starting winger if Hunter is out of the Sydney game, Brayshaw is a near certainty to be in the opening centre bounce (if Clarry's out) and JJ is wearing the oppo's colours?

Calf injuries seem to linger for weeks...

Tingay, his original number would be vacant

On 22/11/2023 at 17:58, Jibroni said:

Have we come up with a nickname for him yet?

Koltyn > Koltrain > Coltrane > Saxman

15 minutes ago, YesitwasaWin4theAges said:

Are we any chance of getting into bed with them regarding a pick swap with them? 

We could pursue their pick 13 in exchance for a future 1st plus something else if we take on Billings' cash?

That would leave us with picks 6,11 and 13 if Lamby could twinkle his wand of magic.

Great thinking. Like it

Can't wait for him to get to hawks, then when he plays Pies he ducks, gets a high freekick and the pies fans lose their minds.

Will be so enjoyable

It also sends a message to the Crows. You give us an offer too good to refuse or f off.

Thilthorpe and 10. No? We'll stop trying.

2 minutes ago, BLWNBA said:

According to gettable on Trade Radio, we have offered a future second rounder for McAdam. 

That is overs I would of thought

11 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

one of the greatest heists ever - doesn't even show that the crom traded all those picks for bryce gibbs, who was out of the competition before his contract with them even expired

What site is this from pls?

If we were recruiting blokes for Casey twos.

10 hours ago, layzie said:

Yes, close the thread because this guy hates it. 

Its done. I'm not happy about it but [censored] move on. Focus your energy on something positive.

Can we please close thread I hate seeing it near the top when I come on the site

What did Tom Browne and Tom Morris say? I have seen them referenced multiple times

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Tim O'Brien's is a 193cm 3rd tall defender for Western Bulldogs?

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Tim O'Brien's is a 193cm 3rd tall defender for Western Bulldogs?

HAHA I just lost it

Don't you get 10 minutes to buy tickets? Why are so many people timing out?

You shouldn't need more than 5

22 hours ago, Colm said:

The unexpected nose dive by the dogs might move them into pole position for the suns pick. I expect them to get beat by the Cats this weekend and probably end up with pick 8 and Brisbanes first round pick. They have a father/son around pick 10. 
 

21 hours ago, Nascent said:

Swans another with pick 12 and 22.

It all comes down to points. Dogs still need points for their father son at approx pick 10 as you say so they can't sell the farm to get ahead of that pick.

The bonus for us is we have our current picks, plus maybe more picks to come in for Grundy and any others that might be on the way out.

We surely have to have the best chance to get the Suns pick.

50 minutes ago, demoncat said:

This or a similar deal with the Swans for McLean would be best case scenario I reckon 

Despite the partnership with Gawn not working as intended this year, we could still come out winners in the Grundy trade if we land a promising young player out of it 

As much as I feel for Grundy on a human level, he’s a great asset for us to have either as a second ruck or as a trade piece 

McLean? no thanks

7 minutes ago, deelusions from afar said:

Isn't the difference, we're happy to keep him for insurance / playing in the twos.  Whereas the pies needed the salary cap space and had made it clear they wanted him out?  If so I think we've got a stronger bargaining hand than you think

Yep. Pick 27 was with a discount.

1 hour ago, Stiff Arm said:

Gee... imagine if we traded up and landed Curtain and Duursma, as well as Kynan Brown... maybe Freo's 2nd rounder (24) in there as well

Our 2023 1st (18) and 2024 1st (18) for GC Pick 7. Maybe our 2nd if need be (36). These will be pushed back with bid matches

4 + 7 + 24 + Brown

Archer Reid with 24

Wowee, oh boy!!!

Why would Suns do that trade? Some of the suggested trades I see on here are amazing. 
 

Maybe see if Suns will throw in Ben King as well as I think you’ve offered them too much. 

5 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Assume the ride is out of commission this weekend?

People surely want Freo to win so we can go ahead of Brisbane on the ladder....right?

Nah we just need to win by 15 goals more than the lions.

1 hour ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Hopefully another player that Fremantle has low-balled and they’ve decided to leave.  We were very keen but maybe his price has risen too high.

 

 

This, unfortunately he has come on this year. Needed to get him for nothing and then have him improve, now they will want a more than we might be prepared to give.

5 hours ago, Colm said:

Points for father/son won’t be an issue. They already have 2nd round pick and can do a 3rd round pick swap with Suns and their future 3rd. Might pick up a lesser pick during trade period either or if they were stuck they could go go into points deficit for next year. 

Really wouldn’t  be hard for them to trade with Suns and be able to have enough points for father/son. 

Yeah but if they don’t offer their second round pick as well suns won’t make thr trade. Which is my point they need to keep that. 

1 hour ago, Demons3031 said:

Does this mean we lose not just 4&5, but 4, 5 , 15 and second rounders LT?

In what world will we have 4,5, 15 & second rounders? 

1 hour ago, Colm said:

I can’t see us getting the Suns pick for that. Other teams are better placed than us I think. The dogs have two first round picks and a father/son that will be around their picks. By trading uk they get a top 6 pick and their F/S. 
I do like the thinking though as I think we need a Key defender so if we do the deal to get Reid we need to keep a decent pick for this year as well.  
If the Suns lose Flanders this year then they may not need as much points for their academy players and may be interested in a future pick as part of the deal. 

Yes but you are missing the fact that dogs still need points for the father son kid. So they can't just give up their picks for Suns as they will need to hold onto some points. That gives us an advantage. 

Getting good vibes from this kid. 

Developing nicely.

4 minutes ago, Deebauched said:

MFC can definitely pick up Reid if the Eagles want to recruit local players in the ND. 

But we cannot give them our top three  picks. Thats ridiculous.

Give them 4, 23  and a quality fringe player  ie. JJ 

While you're at it why not see if they will chuck in Allen. 

Clubs will offer much better than you are suggesting. You are acting as if they are having a firesale.

FYI. JJ is a FA so you can't include him in your trade dealings.

Your understanding of the word ridiculous is quite humorous.