Jump to content


Life Member
  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Posts posted by Moonshadow

  1. 47 minutes ago, DubDee said:

    Why TF would Dunkley want to go to the cheats?!  must be money or a falling out with the Dags

    Money, length of contract, not played out of position, possibly play with bro, stay on Melb city.

    Also s*** hot drugs 

    • Like 1
    • Haha 1
  2. Well...... apparently Mahoney will not last beyond years end, Tmac for Polec, both McDonald's want a trade, club wants pick 9 for McCrae, we're after a young quick Saints player and some still think Burgo is leaving soon...

    From a semi-reliable source, well, er... not really

    • Like 1
    • Facepalm 1
  3. 32 minutes ago, Demons3031 said:

    Is Mason Cox an option..maybe as part of a two way package deal?

    Cox's contract is apparently backloaded. He'll be on $600k+ next year. Can't see us paying anywhere near that for him

    • Like 1
  4. 1 hour ago, Redleg said:

    4 players delisted. 6-8 more possible trades or delisted. That is 10-12 off the list. Brown in. That is 9-11 spots. AFL reduce lists by 2, that is 7-9 spots. We are drafting 7-9 players? No we are not.

    We will pick up a few more players in the next 10 days. We won’t  go to the draft with more than 4-5 selections.

    Rookie upgrades?

  5. Are his hammies ok? The club would do DD and we have Burgo to build on his strength

    Is the contract too much? Only the club will know that and they'll be aware of next year's OOC players. Tmac staying/going may affect this

    Does he pass the No DH rule? Does that even exist anymore? The club will do its DD

    Is he talented enough? Hell yeah!

    Does he meet a need and improve our list? Again, hell yeah!

    Does he want to come to us? Who knows except him and maybe MFC

    Assuming the report on his hammies is ok, my view is LET'S GET HIM!

    • Like 2
  6. 9 hours ago, Kelpien said:

    Criticism of Dr Evil is rightly deserved. It is the silly season and whispers and inside information is certainly appreciated but this guy continually doubled down and categorically stated that Smith would 100% be a Demon. 

    Things most certainly are fluid at this time of the year but It will be almost impossible to take anything Dr Evil says seriously ever again. 

    I'm sure you'll get over it..... eventually.

    • Like 1
    • Haha 2
  7. 29 minutes ago, JTR said:

    Watch Geelong turn their attention to Brown now, now they can't get Cameron for free...  ?

    This logic implies Brown is a FA, which of course, he's not. I think the Cats will get Cameron regardless. They see a gun forward wanting to come to them, they get the deal done. Smith and Higgins will cost them nix. Why would a GF team with 3 late first rounders refuse to trade for a gun key forward that fills a need? Brown would be a compromise on what they could get. We don't have that luxury, unfortunately 

    • Like 3
  8. 3 hours ago, Farmer said:

    So you think that at some point Weideman will kick 50 plus goals in a season ?  He had a good run of games this year, barely got a kick in the last few . The bloke we are apparently happy to let go, has already done it . Let's see what Tom ‘s “ new shape”  produces , madness to trade him out . 

    I didn't say that. Your outrage is trying to put words into the mouths of others

    Weid is worth preserving with. Imo he has more upside than tmac. He's young, still developing and is more important to us long term (with Ben Brown) than tmac

    I will agree to disagree with you

    • Like 3
  9. The compo system is terrible.

    That we got 3 for Chip is a joke. That the Bummers get 7 for a guy that can't get on the park is stupid. That Hawks got 19 for Buddy was ridiculous.

    I know it's based upon the team ladder position, but that is arbitrary to the player's real value 

    Get rid of compo. Completely. 

    • Like 5
    • Angry 1
  10. 10 minutes ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

    Or the Cameron one

    Need 10 or lower to get McCrae  if that's the target.

    Cameron might get matched, in which case Cats may meed to give up 13, 15 and maybe 20. Or a 3 way deal, eg cats get Jezza, GCS get 13, 15 and 20 (which will get pushed out further with academy bid matching), GWS get 5

    Daniher at pick 7 is a joke. Cameron is worth 5, easy.

  11. 7 hours ago, Demons11 said:

    Lots of clubs are very frustrated as not knowing list sizes is making things very difficult. 
    Vanders being shopped around 

    And our Hawks 2nd rounder at 23 just got pushed out to 25 with FA compo. Possibly 26 if Jezza to Cats compo comes through. And that's before academy or f/s bid matching. It will be 30-35 in the blink of an eye. 

    If possible, I'd look to trade it in a  bigger package to move up into single digit number at draft time.

    Our 2020 2nd, Preuss, Tmac and future 2nd or 3rd for GWS pick 9?

  • Create New...