DEE fence

1 hour ago, Roy Boy said:

Don’t know why May was never tried at FF.

Nice kick, good mark, would’ve brought ball to ground.

Goody a bit reluctant to throw the magnets around.

Oh well, think it’s the right call, was found out quite a few times this year.

Can you imagine the sads he would crack at our delivery into fwd 50, would make Richo look like the Dalia Lama, anyway would like to have seen this tried.

2 hours ago, Demon Disciple said:

AFL shot themselves in the foot buying Docklands for some astronomical amount, when if they waited another year they’d only need to buy with $1.

this x 1,000,000,000. N one held accountable for the most obvious grift of all time.

I know he knocked it back (and I looked over the last 5 pages but couldn’t see any comment), but I was totally impressed by Troy Chaplin. I thought he stepped up so seamlessly and had a subtle difference to SG in communication. He is senior coach material.

Went to the game yesterday only 4th game in 5 years 3 wins 1 loss. Defense did plenty, dogs much better around ball.

6 Gawn

5 Tmac

4 Petty

3 Rivers (some of his kicks stopped 6 votes)

2 Bowey

1 Turner (better than McVee/Langford/Langdon/Salem) the amount of ball going in was no wonder Aaron N got plenty.

Hon Mention - Frisch, Clarry got into game 2nd half, is probably deserving of a vote but our back line was enormous yesterday considering how badly we were beaten around the center and ball

No votes - Picket + Windsor, such nearly games, got plenty of ball, shocking disposals, but the future is bright. Picket also missing last qtr.

16 hours ago, whatwhat say what said:

2025 has been the year of dishonourable losses

6 losses by 13 points or under now

Not fit enough to run out games

If you said mentally fit enough I might agree with you, for me it is all between the ears. Dogs started on fire every quarter, then the Dees would have the better of the later part of each quarter. Nothing wrong with fitness, confidence definitely,

Will never buy another membership if it’s Hird. Horse if he wanted it. Simmo is cooked after WCE, although I think he is a decent guy. Buckley had same in game issues as Goodwin had.

Personally I think Chocco, needs to go as well as Alan, not convinced Nathan has done enough either. I don’t have any insight into the untested but would love to know who has been doing the window shopping. I have no confidence the club had a plan.

Who ever leaked this is a selfish dog, utterly classless and a profound embarrassment to the club. There are numerous other adjectives required.

Simon you are a stand up guy, thank you forever.

10 minutes ago, Satan said:

Good tackle by fritcsh

I’m not watching , is this true/sarcasm/blue moon.

1 hour ago, Jaded No More said:

At least Adrian Anderson’s record remains intact

I had given up when I saw he was doing the defense. I follow quite closely his musings and just don’t think he has the skill set for these tribunals.

Kolt was looking like a kid early on, the Perth game he was too excited for sure, but I have seen something worth persisting with. He is brave and has a heart, I am perfectly happy for him to settle. All these critiques could have been about ANB 10 years ago.

Could everyone please watch the post game presser, I actually think it was his best ever (apart from standing his ground a few weeks ago). He explains a couple of things really well in his usual dry manner.

We as fans (speaking for myself) go mental when we miss gimme goals - the reason... we worry that the players will drop their heads from missed opportunities. What Goodwin explained really clearly (we're not focused on outcome mantra) at the 03:30 - 04:00 min mark of the video, was that the team - 'work hard unconditionally' and that 'they were able to continue with the same mindset...irrespective of the outcome of the scoreboard'. i.e. he has coached the team to deal with what is our (my) biggest fear (speaking again for myself/MFCSS). That if we don't make every post a winner we are done.

If you think about it, the idea that with enough opportunities (quality f50 entries) the reward will come (scoreboard result), is so much better than making each shot on goal a pass/fail moment that will only increase pressure on the players. This is something top tier european football teams do all the time. The flip side is, as confidence builds from the process working, the pressure reduces and we will kick bigger scores.

By way of contrast - Look at where Carlton are with Curnow and McKay, they have this approach that their gun forwards will do all the work. I would much rather have 10 goal kickers (Kozzie with 5 doesn't hurt either). That said, Gawn shouldn't have laid off that shot at goal, that is not taking responsibility. I want that coached out, same for Trac, take your bloody set shots.

Needless to say, Goodwin has walked the path he said we were going to take and has fronted up to everything. Kudos to a legend of the MFC.

https://www.afl.com.au/video/1330462/goodwin-post-match-r11-its-a-pretty-special-bond-that-youre-starting-to-see?videoId=1330462&modal=true&type=video&publishFrom=1748169119001&limit=50&tagNames=ProgramCategory%3APress%20Conference&references=AFL_COMPSEASON%3A73%2CAFL_ROUND%3A1157

I once had the great pleasure (while escorting the umpires as a young uniformed constable) at the G, of telling Sticks Kernahan 'not to sook', in those words, as he came over and started berating the umpires after a close Melbourne victory. Was walking on air, (and I knew he dearly wanted to belt me) was my most rascal moment I'm willing to admit to publicly.

4 hours ago, speed demon said:

Loved Max rag-dolling Grundy to take it out of the ruck and snap truly. Perfect start and set the tone for the day.

https://www.melbournefc.com.au/video/1790882/gawn-v-grundy-max-banks-early-win?videoId=1790882&modal=true&type=video&publishFrom=1748152740001

One of the many things I rate about the coach and the team is the respect at the end of the game from our team to opposition. Grundy left, but quite clearly didn’t burn any bridges. There was some ‘heavy’ traffic involving Grundy both ways. Yet I saw him pick up one player in play and Clarry giving him [censored] about the grey whiskers in his beard after the game was fun. It didn’t work but that the separation was graceful shows heaps of class.

6 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

so much so that luke hodge's kids are more likely to go to the bears' academy than to dingley as a father-son selection

Is it off the Hawks or Clarkson? (I would mention Jeff but that might come across as political ;-)…)

4 hours ago, Nasher said:

Out: Spargo

In: Viney

I’m not dropping AJ. He offers 1%ers - the taps, smothers etc that our other talls don’t, and those created goals today. He doesn’t do the “tall things” very well (like contested marking) but I don’t yet trust that van Rooyen will do them either. If I have to choose between two talls who can’t clunk it, I choose the one who is already in the side, proving he does the little things.

Lever had cobwebs to be blown out but I’m not dropping him either. It’s normal for elite players to find form in the seniors and he fits that category. The higher intensity will accelerate his return to the top. Assuming he’s not injured, anyway.

The club video with Lever doing his recovery was informative, he made it clear he struggles for touch when he returns and was trying to remedy it. I actually thought with that in mind and thinking of other returns, he wasn't as 'rusty' as he normally was.

Chin's delivery inside 50 was superb:

Hard Flat Passes

Waiting for Kingy to retract his Oliver is unlikely to be an A grader again.

Pickett

Gawn

Oliver

Trac

Salem

Langdon

Apologies to Turner, Lindsay, Rivers, McVee in fact most of the team. Pretty damn excited to be able to name Salem, as Coach Ted said… now we have two aces. Gun rebounding HBx2, exactly what you need as a finals team.

AJ has presence, and is a great 2nd ruck. I also like his positioning and he runs with the fall of the ball. I sincerely hope JVR comes good, but the way AJ is moving when the ball is on the deck applies pressure that JVR doesn’t bring. He still ball watches, after he feels the contest has past him, AJ keeps moving regardless, it’s valuable. And his nouse to tap rather than take possession should get more credit, kept ball alive. Oh by the could the previous Petty haters (apart from STFU) apologize, all that garbage about him not being invested.

10 minutes ago, Dingo said:

Liam Jurrah like

Better, Kozzie is a disrupter of opposition composure. The way Max takes long down the line out of the equation, Kozzie puts the fear of God into rebounding defenders. Jurrah a better mark, but everything else Kozzie.

11 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Viney out for another week.

Not great news

Culley is slow at Casey and in recent weeks has not impressed. Is he better than Sharp as a sub. Maybe

That would allow lever in moving Turner forward and Fritsch back in

Viney has taken the pressure off the selection group but will it work?

Am a bit stressed about Viney, I know we all think he is made of stone, but three weeks suggest his bell was well and truly rung. Thinking he could be a bit longer still than what the club is saying. Don't love that symptoms were delayed and while it was a decent hit, it wasn't the biggest we've seen him wear. Am worried he's getting to the stage where he is just more susceptible.

9 minutes ago, GS_1905 said:

One of few podcasts I’d look forward to every week.

In retrospect it takes a certain personality to make a successful podcast and having two larrikins in Gus n Gawn was a treat.

If Chin was to take over, he’d need a side kick. Not sure who though

Fair point, I think Gawn is maxxed out (sorry) with MMM, I love Melk's no BS approach to questions in the media recently. Of the AFLW crew I'm not sure who is the slickest media performer, well Bannan is a fave player (her running is electric) Eliza and Kate seem media savvy. Of the other blokes, Lever or Rivers can hold a sentence together without using every cliche under the sun, some forward/back tension would be good too. I presume someone like GW would have more of a clue on who could keep their end of a microphone up.

I miss Gus and Gawn, I get that its time has passed, but I really would like to see another - I propose to nominate Chandler to lead it, I even have a working title:

CHIN WAG

Tell me that isn't a nice play on words, open to other suggestions though.

Cheers

I love to have a bet with friends, my family has owned and trained horses and I only mention this to say I’m not a wowser.

But seriously sports betting on phones has to stop, it cannot be that easy to get high. It’s like your phone is dispensing fentanyl.

Felt strong enough to post about it, John Oliver can be a preachy git, but he’s not wrong here, is worth a watch, and the harm is real, let’s push to limit the damage.

Oh and to be clear I don’t mind people talking about their bets, in the same way I favour legalization, but with limits and controls.

I actually think it is in the lap of the gods, we have the talent and the effort, the god part is the confidence, our small forwards nail a few on the run and we’ll skewer sides. Our leaders continue to shank goals from gimme positions the season will sink without a trace. My very knowledgeable Hawks mate was laughing at how the Hawks escaped with a win. Dogs and Collingwood are the only teams I’m really worried about. Dogs and Melbourne might just be the heavyweight clash of midfield clearance for the year. Collingwood I think we will beat once, (maybe) twice would be a miracle because they are annoyingly good. Dogs while more consistent I think we match up well on them and have good recent history.