Posts posted by Adam The God
-
-
-
-
24 minutes ago, Frustrated Demon said: Should have had an actual forward coaching the group 4 years ago. Blows my mind we had Stafford coaching the forwards. I’m pretty sure that’s who was coaching them
As someone who was a coach for 20 years, if you've ever coached, you'll know that the best coaches are often not the best players. Bizarre, I know.
-
5 minutes ago, Very Jaded said: It's very obviously @dazzledavey36
That's some nice shade Tim's throwing at himself. Perfect cover. 👏 I concur. Dazzler is Timmy.
-
6 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said: I was basing it on them getting picks from Hawks for Humphrey and then on trading. So if Hawks give them 8 or 9 (whatever it is now) plus extras Suns hold 7, 8 & 9 and pass on two of those to us for Trac. They still have enough points for Academy picks then.
Right, so trading Humphrey to one of their main competitors next year. Not gonna happen.
We hold all the cards.
It's okay. You can dare to dream.
-
19 minutes ago, brendan said: So Gold coast needs to decide petracca or Humphrey? Ball is in there court and which player gets them closer to a flag in next few years
Meanwhile, they risk Humphrey going to a competitor next year or when his contract is up, and the deal they get then will not be Christian Petracca.
-
-
-
Edited by Adam The God
2 minutes ago, old55 said: Pick 7 & 8 is not a ideal for us, it signals a full rebuild. Our midfield will be ultra thin in that case. We'd finish bottom 2 but I guess at least we'll have an early pick next year in the last year before Tasmania.
Humphrey (or retaining Petracca for that matter) provides more than just his playing contribution, he also provide a layer of protection for Langford, Windsor, Lindsay and Tholstrup.
Along with Viney, who now surely has to play a midfield role to usher these kids (Langford, Windsor, Lindsay and Kolt) through their 2nd and 3rd seasons. Sometimes you get an Oliver who has an immediate impact on contested situations, but most of the time, you'll need to develop their tanks and two way running, as well as core strength.
With Clarry out the door, even if Trac goes and we get Humphrey, it's a midfield that will struggle on the inside and potentially in transition until they get their tanks up IMO.
-
7 minutes ago, demoncat said: People might disagree with me here but honestly ANB
Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for being compassionate when it comes to our players, but ANB left a massive playing and leadership void in our team, and we seemed more than happy to ship him off for a token second round pick
ANB walked straight into Adelaide’s best 23 and leadership group - he was clearly highly rated by them but we gave them an easy out
I don’t think we should be like Dodoro was for Essendon and be a nightmare club to deal, but I think we’ve been too willing to take unders or too happy to overpay just to get deals done under Lamb’s tenure
I think he needs to get this Trac deal exactly right or he should rightly be under the pump going into next year
By being fair traders, that helps in a situation like the Trac one. Gold Coast know we're not trying to screw them. We like win win trades.
-
-
-
3 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said: They’ve committed to making a fair offer for Tracc, they have plenty of picks to do that.
They don't have plenty picks. What are you talking about, DS? If they traded both top 10 picks for Trac, they'd have to go into a point deficit and risk kids next year. They're not going to do that. They are going to posture, very likely up until the very last moment.
-
-
1 minute ago, Gator said: There's no comparison between Humphrey and Petracca.
Gold Coast's position is that they won't trade Humphrey and clearly Melbourne's position is that it will trade Petracca, even if they're reluctant.
Nothing Cameron has said is at odds with that situation. The only question is will they blink on Humphrey. We'll see.
They've committed to Trac, so they will. It's only a matter of time.
-
-
4 minutes ago, Demongirl35 said: When I checked a couple of days ago I put ‘football club’ in and nothing came up… now it does. I’m just praying my fat fingers pressed the wrong letter and that’s why it didn’t come up 😂
He'll be in a Melbourne jumper by the weekend, so he can start following Hawthorn as well if he wants, but it's not happening.
-
-
51 minutes ago, Neil Crompton said: I wasn't responding to you Adam. I was responding to @Random Task by asking a simple question - as I have no idea on Rogers.
But you didn't answer my question anyway.
I know.
And I've answered it elsewhere.
Rogers is a dynamic small forward / mid who has very nice skills by hand and foot, but as of AFL level so far, is not a big ball winner.
-
-
15 minutes ago, Neil Crompton said: Please tell me why Rogers will be a good get? I don't know him from a bar of soap, but he averages 7.2 disposals a game playing a role similar to Spargo i believe. Spargo averaged 11.2 disposals a game and we on DL canned him for not getting the ball enough. So honest question - why would he be a good get?
I didn't can him. He will be an important role player if he comes.
-
-
-

Rory Atkins potential development coach.
in Melbourne Demons
He also played with blonde hair for a bit like I did in Year 6.