J Demon

IF he said that, then that is terribly disappointing. I know some die-hard, so-called "fickle" supporters - regulars of the dark period in the '70s and '80s, when there was virtually nothing to look forward to and who still go today - who say that "Daniher has to go". Supporters need to make their feelings known after the game when the players leave the field by the "few" still attending that what we are witnessing at the club is unacceptable. Then it is hard for him to categorise disgruntled regulars attending in lean times into the "fickle" category, if he indeed say it as stranga helpfully relayed it to us.

To be fair, I did notice that he took Bell off Brown late in the first quarter and put him up forward. Ward went onto Brown, who somewhat quietened him, but not by too much. Apart from the pathetic performance from the footballers ball watchers on the field, Daniher got his match-ups wrong and was generally outcoached.

The difference between Johnson and Bruce is that the first has an accuracy problem that needs to be corrected, the latter needs to re-learn the fundamentals of a drop punt. This is the likely reason why Johnson gets overlooked in favour of Bruce.

This is one of my biggest peeves. I have no problem if the ball is kicked sideways or backwards for almost all day, as long as the target is found. I am sick to death of calls for a long kick when the ball is in the backline. The worst thing to do in that position is to kick it long and hope for the best, because as you say that is the best opportunity the opposition has for a turnover and a quick goal It's not just in the MCC but the old red seats as well. The players deserve support when they are playing smart football, not discouragement and consequently encouragement of stupid football.

Our culture won't even start to turn around until we stop patting the players on the back for losing, regardless of effort. We have a definite and long-planted losing culture at MFC.

A special half-time mention must go to Godfrey who has kept Goodes quiet all game.

Fremantle fans on Yze's goal.

The trumpet guy was terrific! He really got me going for a game I was going to be utterly indifferent about, considering our season and chances. The key is for him to only play it about a further four times this year so we don't get sick of it. Surprise us with it once in a while to keep the crowd appreciation on a high.

So says the semi-literate. He did not have a go at you, so relax a little. Why didn't you go to the game? Just asking. You need a lie down, because two of the missing factors, in your very own opinion, would be enhanced by dropping Davey. He needs to stay in the side because he provides all of those things you think are important - pressure, tackling, speed - regardless of his performance. He is having a tough time of it at the moment, but he is still a ball winner in terms of catching opposition players on the run and it will be only a matter of time before he comes good. He does not get enough time in the forward line for my liking, anyway, but that is my passing observation, because I did not sit there with a stop watch and time him.

It's time to give Miller a wake-up call now. EDIT: Actually, I'm not happy that Yze was dropped. He should not have played in round one now that he has been dropped. One game does not make a player, whether that be a bad game or a good game. It's just a waste that he was played now.

:angry: :angry: :angry:

He always finds a way to come back from the dead.

One view from the old red seats: Holland: Our best player Bruce: Has he heart? Johnstone: Bad office day Davey: Conceded unnecessary frees Miller: Can he mark? Neitz: Missed crucial goals Robertson: Lacked the service Johnson: Had no idea Jones: Pushed too early You've got most spot on, and many of the ones I have listed complement rather than contradict.

The umpire was right in front of it, yet still didn't make the correct decision! Crazy.

$15 for full price. I would not be happy if I had to pay that much for what is essentially a game next to no-one is interested in (15,000 attendance). I paid $9 concession to be frustrated at the poor level of umpiring. They're like a whole other team trying to play against you. Nine umpires, and they still only had two on the boundary. Umpires could pay on the full regardless, but not that it matters. There was a mark before the line in the first quarter (by Robertson I think) and it was paid on the full, even though he was right in front of it. Whatever. Someone's laughing all the way to the bank.

There was plenty wrong with Miller yesterday, that being the main reason. All he had to do was stick his hands in front of him and he could have taken more than a few marks yesterday, but he failed to do that on several occasions. It's worse being in line with his back since it gives the perception that he is just running, oblivious to the ball coming in his direction. I have not been impressed with him; he simply has not been improving at an acceptable rate. He's always developing and it never ends. He might have to look elsewhere in the future. I am a fan of Bell and saw him do little wrong yesterday. He should be an important defender this year. Then why was I devastated at the result? And still am! But I do agree that Hawthorn is not a quality team. The only thing they have going for them is their endless running, which will not get them very far.

Looked like no. Melbourne members don't get that privilege, the ticket lady told me. I didn't see anything on the MFC website to indicate anything of the sort either. I'm sure once upon a time that was the case, but I haven't been attending pre-season games for years. I thought they were meaningless, but after actually attending one after so many years, I was actually as disappointed with losing a match in the NAB cup as I am when we lose in the league.

I've been led to believe about the possibility of getting into today's game with my membership (red seat reserve seat). I know the prices and will pay to watch Melbourne today, but have no idea of the benefit of my membership in relation to pre-season cup games. I really should know already, but there you go. Does anyone know? Thankyou very much in advance!