Jump to content

No16

Members
  • Posts

    581
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by No16

  1. Great to see the Dees being active but is anyone else concerned that we have only picked up one mid at this point in time?

    Considering we have the worst midfield in the AFL I am a bit concerned.

    Apart from Jones no one else was in form in the mids.

    Jones, Sylvia, Grimes, Trengove, Blease, Howe, Magner, Byrnes, Viney and Pick 4 rotating through the middle has a pretty good ring to it.

  2. I was being a tad sarcastic. Gumbleton no doubt has serious talent but if Essendon were willing to go then alarm bells would ring for me.

    Definitely agree. If he gets his body right then he will be a great asset but for essendon to shop him around means that they can't or don't want to try a fix his problems. Only reason to trade for him is if he wants to leave.

  3. What's disappointing is the ease at which we could've picked Butcher, Darling or Sam Reid in the draft, and now some are prepared to trade a really important MFC player and clubman for one of those guys - indeed someone potentially inferior to those guys.

    It's not like we didn't know we needed such a player in those drafts. I really hope we backed the right horse with Cook.

    Butcher was never an option as he was not a top two pick (Scully/Trengove). If he was available at our next pick I am sure we would have picked him but no great loss as he has played 3 good games so far in two years. By that reckoning Cook has until this time next year to show something.

  4. Dawes is a pretty good No. 2 forward. I don't see him as the go to number one key forward as he does not have that many variations if he is having a bad night. For what we will have to give up to get him it wouldn't be worth it.

×
×
  • Create New...