Jump to content

Sir Why You Little

Life Member

Posts posted by Sir Why You Little

  1. 44 minutes ago, BDA said:

    Do you mean we should have recruited better goal kickers?

    Fritsch missed 2 gimmes. thats on him, not the coaches.

    Our Forwards are not being Coached correctly or PREPARED correctly

    Some of that is on Goodwin, and some on the FD

    When have we seen improvement in our forward 50 craft since the GF??

    It’s not helped by a Pathetic VFL fixture, but other Clubs have that problem and seem to function up forward, but not us

    Simon’s Learnings obviously do not include the Forwardline, it has been neglected for 3 seasons

    6 Goals to 3/4 time on a Sunny afternoon when “supposedly” we had them on toast


    What Rubbish

    Other Coaches in the AFL would have sorted our Forwardline massive inefficiency in one preseason. This Season the problem has actually got worse, because we cannot run out 4 Quarters

    Intense pressure for no rewards takes its toll


  2. 25 minutes ago, Adam The God said:

    We are playing a completely different game style than 2021-2023 and most of 2024.

    Goalkicking accuracy is a completely different problem to game style.

    No it isn’t. They all have to be in synch

    Multiple entries for no reward

    It all adds up

  3. ·

    Edited by Sir Why You Little

    1 minute ago, BDA said:

    The game plan generated enough chances through 3 quarters to be 20 points ahead. But the players missed very gettable goals. Thats not on the coaches

    reckon our fitness is a much bigger concern than the game plan. We wilted badly again in the 4th quarter today.

    Of course it’s on the Coaches, it’s been the same return for 3 seasons

    That doesn’t excuse the players at all, but this is a gameplan flaw. It happens regularly

    Fitness is way off
.

  4. Just now, Adam The God said:

    You realise we led just before 3/4 time, plus had 4 more scoring shots than them to 3/4 time. We. Had. Them. On. Toast.

    if you're gonna have a pop at least show you have a feel for the game.

    We've completely changed the way we move the footy.

    We have had multiple entries into the 50 for 3 Seasons for atrocious returns

    You have a Team on toast when you maximize opportunities

    The entire Football Department needs a serious shake up. Not fit enough and not mentally tough enough
.

  5. 2 minutes ago, Adam The God said:

    Yep, that's pretty apparent.

    đŸ€Š

    You are obviously very easily satisfied

    Today’s game has been played multiple times over the last 3 Seasons


    It doesn’t work
.

  6. 1 minute ago, Adam The God said:

    What? We transitioned the ball beautifully many times and had them on toast for three quarters.

    Did you watch the game?

    Did you watch the game?

    Did you see the Score?

    Had them on toast, that is pure Comedy

  7. 3 minutes ago, DeeMee said:

    Well I was going to try and be clever and relate it to “The Journey” but decided the most flagrantly bad umpiring decision I’ve seen in 50 years said it all. Not why we lost obviously but I truly can’t understand the umpiring.

    Gotcha
I wasn’t able to see the game live, which is probably fortunate, as i have seen the same game so often

  8. Just now, Disco InTurno said:

    We absolutely were the better team.

    But you are right that the key forwards are a problem. We dominated for 3 quarters in nearly every aspect of the game except once we had to do something with it inside 50.

    I understand what you are saying, but we have been shocking up forward for years now, so it’s obvious the Club is not learning from mistakes and experience.

    We are just repeating bad habits.

    The Forward 50 is where the cream should rise


    This Coaching method is going nowhere


  9. 1 minute ago, Disco InTurno said:

    We were the better team today. They’ll finish 6th and go out in the first round of finals.

    No we weren’t. Get real

    Our offense was amateur hour and it’s been in that category for 2-3 years

    Where is the Development of any key Forwards???

  10. 1 hour ago, BoBo said:

    You might be missing my point.

    I’m not saying (or would even argue on the merits of the act in isolation) that he should get suspended.

    I’m saying that if Archer (chuck in Curtis from North as well) got 3 weeks, then the Freo player should get something.

    If he doesn’t then the MRO/AFL is being inconsistent.

    Which it is.

    To be perfectly clear, I don’t think any of them deserve any weeks. Including the Freo player tonight.

    You could be right, i am not arguing

    I am just making the point that, that particular incident was a genuine 50/50 with both players genuinely going for the ball, there was no malicious intent from either player, so i would find it difficult to suspend a player
.

  11. ·

    Edited by Sir Why You Little

    54 minutes ago, BoBo said:

    So was Archer and the dogs player but they still rubbed out Archer

    Who is the aggressor??

    Proactive/reactive??

    It looked 50/50 to me

  12. The Filth have done this off a 5 day break

    Can we learn to be this resilient please?

    Can we learn to field kick with some precision?

    It should never take 2 years to learn a gameplan


  13. 3 minutes ago, BoBo said:

    If Archer is suspended for 3 weeks then (Clarke was it?) also needs to go. He didn’t have to jump into Shultz.

    And I also am not saying it should be a suspension, but if players have to take ‘reasonable care’ then he has to be gone.

    No suspension. Both players were committed

  14. 24 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

    The Pies work off the ball is off the charts. That’s why they’re in so many games.

    and their precision field kicking to each other

  15. 2 minutes ago, Demon Disciple said:

    Longmuir has to be about on his last legs as coach of Freo, surely?

    With the list he has, they should be doing much better than their current output. Their game plan is worse than ours.

    The Shockers are having a crack, but they are also hoping for something to happen rather than creating it