Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Demonland

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Whispering_Jack

Administrators
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Whispering_Jack

  1. There are also some other considerations that come into play that are not directly part of the wild card debate but still related to the structure of the competition within which the game operates.

    We are about to see the introduction of the Tassie Devils as 19th club and subsequently, we will have a 20th. When you change the structure of the competition in this way, it raises questions like how many games each team plays in a season, how do you fit two byes per season in a fixture and how do you determine a fair draw given that it’s likely that the teams will play each other once but also play only four others twice?

    There are mathematical considerations involved as well as the fundamental principle of having a fair and equitable fixture and a balanced competition.

    A lot of food for thought packed in there.

  2. 1 hour ago, BLWNBA said:

    Whilst that applied for the zone changes, other changes including the AFL removing the criteria that allowed a player to be tied to a club if they were born overseas in the relevant zones, with all NGA applications now on relying on parents' cultural backgrounds, was effective from the beginning of the 2026 season.

    The first article linked states:

    Other important changes include:

    • the addition of the Pacific and Central and South American regions to the cultural eligibility criteria and the removal of European countries;

    • an expansion of age eligibility from 19 to 21 years to allow clubs to have more time to access players if they are late developers;

    • and a requirement that the player and their family must have resided in the NGA zone for at least 12 months before their application is submitted.

    Importantly, though the changes will not affect the 2025 draft class, all approved applications for future drafts that do not meet the new eligibility rules will be reviewed by the AFL in coming months, which could see players who have been tied to clubs ruled out for priority access.

    Personally I’m not exactly sure of the reason it’s being stated he’s no longer tied to us, but I would suspect it’s likely due to one of, or a combination of those listed factors.

    Perhaps, but this simply doesn't pass muster in terms of Prasad's eligibility and does not explain why an AFL review might have put a line through him remaining an MFC NGA.

    In the case of the first two dot points, they can't be interpreted as applying to Prasad who already fulfilled the cultural eligibility and age guidelines. The third dot point countermands the statement that the new guidelines will be introduced over the next three years because in Prasad's case it would mean retrospective application and not something to be applied in transition between 2026 and 2028.

    The only thing that seems to make sense to me is the fact the situation applying to the Ah-Mu brothers if Samoan culture is now specifically included in the new list of Pacific regions. If that was the case it would explain earlier reports that Corey Ah-Mu was tied to Melbourne's NGA system.

    Of course, it would be nice if the AFL or the MFC would simply tell us what the situation is with these players.

  3. 1 hour ago, BLWNBA said:

    A transition period will take place over the next three years with the reviewed zones to be in place by 2028 for the AFL, and 2026 for the AFLW rules.”

    My understanding is that this effectively means that if you were tied to a club’s NGA in 2025 then that situation would not be upset by the changes. Prasad was definitely included as a MFC NGA player last year. How is his position therefore affected by the changes?

  4. And if you're wondering how things stood on the eve of Gather Round at this time last year (note Gold Coast and Essendon had a game to make up as a result of Cyclone Alfred):-

    ROUND 4

    W

    L

    D

    FOR

    AGST

    %

    PTS

    HAWTHORN

    4

    0

    0

    363

    285

    127.37

    16

    BRISBANE LIONS

    4

    0

    0

    368

    308

    119.48

    16

    GOLD COAST

    3

    0

    0

    347

    201

    172.64

    12

    GWS GIANTS

    3

    1

    0

    377

    253

    149.01

    12

    ADELAIDE

    3

    1

    0

    500

    341

    146.63

    12

    COLLINGWOOD

    3

    1

    0

    327

    265

    123.40

    12

    ST KILDA

    3

    1

    0

    394

    351

    112.25

    12

    GEELONG

    2

    2

    0

    384

    283

    135.69

    8

    SYDNEY SWANS

    2

    2

    0

    343

    299

    114.72

    8

    WESTERN BULLDOGS

    2

    2

    0

    347

    345

    100.58

    8

    FREMANTLE

    2

    2

    0

    337

    364

    92.58

    8

    PORT ADELAIDE

    1

    3

    0

    317

    365

    86.85

    4

    NORTH MELBOURNE

    1

    3

    0

    352

    410

    85.85

    4

    ESSENDON

    1

    2

    0

    257

    332

    77.41

    4

    RICHMOND

    1

    3

    0

    293

    462

    63.42

    4

    CARLTON

    0

    4

    0

    250

    308

    81.17

    0

    MELBOURNE

    0

    4

    0

    248

    407

    60.93

    0

    WEST COAST

    0

    4

    0

    243

    468

    51.92

    0

  5. 11 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

    He wouldn't know. He's a journalist and like all journalist he likes to stick it up Melbourne when he can. If it comes from Melbourne then I believe it not from him.

    I had the pleasure of meeting Jonty Ralphsmith at a Coates Talent League game several years ago, where Harry Sheezel was playing for the Sandringham Dragons. He noticed my affiliation with Harry's family and supporters, we engaged in a discussion about him and the draft in general. Harry played junior football with one of my grandsons, and they have maintained a close friendship. Jonty Ralphsmith was seeking an angle for a story on Harry and presented himself as genuinely sincere.

    I highly doubt that he would harbor any grievances towards Melbourne or have a desire to disparage the club. I have attempted to contact him through the contact page on Zero Hanger, and if I receive a response, I will post it here.

  6. It’s not Monday but Tuesday will do

    Melbourne (109) v Gold Coast (89)

    Melbourne spent the last few years focusing on not losing games. They could defend, but they couldn’t score.

    They rarely got knocked out, but they lost on points.

    Under Steven King they’re the ones going for the knockout.

    It might not always work, but it’s fun to watch.

    And on the weekend, it really worked.

    It was helped a lot by a young guy named Kysaiah Pickett who’s worth checking out, and that big tall guy with the beard who always takes the marks.

    The Suns, were certainly not bad. Even with their talent you’re not going to win every game.

    Damien Harwick said it was a ‘kick right in the nuts’, which I’ve always said is something to be avoided.

    As a Dees supporter, I can say kicking someone in the nuts is more fun than being kicked in the nuts. I don’t think you need to be a Dees supporter to get that.

    https://www.titusoreily.com/afl/the-monday-knee-jerk-reaction-round-four2026

  7. Synopsis:

    Best differentials

    1 - Geelong (+44)
    2 - St Kilda (+23)
    3 - Western Bulldogs (+18)
    4 - Richmond (+10)
    5 - Essendon (+8)

    Worst differentials

    1 - GWS Giants (-23)
    2 - Gold Coast (-18)
    3 - West Coast (-14)
    4 - Port Adelaide (-12)
    5 - Adelaide (-11)

    Most frees for

    1 - Geelong (102)
    2 - North Melbourne (95)
    Eq.3 - St Kilda & Western Bulldogs (87)
    5 - Richmond (84)

    Best differentials

    1 - Geelong (+44)
    2 - St Kilda (+23)
    3 - Western Bulldogs (+18)
    4 - Richmond (+10)
    5 - Essendon (+8)

    Worst differentials

    1 - GWS Giants (-23)
    2 - Gold Coast (-18)
    3 - West Coast (-14)
    4 - Port Adelaide (-12)
    5 - Adelaide (-11)

    Most frees for

    1 - Geelong (102)
    2 - North Melbourne (95)
    Eq.3 - St Kilda & Western Bulldogs (87)
    5 - Richmond (84)

    Best differentials

    1 - Geelong (+44)
    2 - St Kilda (+23)
    3 - Western Bulldogs (+18)
    4 - Richmond (+10)
    5 - Essendon (+8)

    Worst differentials

    1 - GWS Giants (-23)
    2 - Gold Coast (-18)
    3 - West Coast (-14)
    4 - Port Adelaide (-12)
    5 - Adelaide (-11)

    Most frees for

    1 - Geelong (102)
    2 - North Melbourne (95)
    Eq.3 - St Kilda & Western Bulldogs (87)
    5 - Richmond (84)

    Least frees for

    1 - GWS Giants (58)
    2 - Melbourne (60)
    3 - Collingwood (63)
    4 - Adelaide (67)
    5 - Gold Coast (68)

    Most frees against

    Eq.1 - North Melbourne & West Coast (93)
    Eq.3 - Sydney & Gold Coast (86)
    5 - Port Adelaide (83)

    Least frees against

    1 - Geelong (58)
    2 - Melbourne (59)
    3 - St Kilda (64)
    4 - Western Bulldogs (69)
    5 - Collingwood (71)

    The 2026 Free Kick Ladder - Round 4

    Geelong (+44) has had four games with free kick differentials of +9 or more to comfortably sit on top of the standings.

    The Cats have received 102 frees and given away only 58.

    St Kilda (+23) sit second but are +21 behind the Cats, while the Western Bulldogs (+18) are third just clear of Richmond (+10) who have often been at the other end of the FK Ladder.

    As mentioned earlier, Vic teams make up the top eight with Essendon (+8), Hawthorn (+3), North Melbourne (+2)and Melbourne (+1) all with positive differentials.

    Down the bottom is poor old GWS (-23)who finished second bottom last year. It's back to regular programming for a Dimma-coached team with Gold Coast (-18) second last, then West Coast (-14) third bottom after finishing last year in 15th on the FK Ladder

    SA pair Port Adelaide (-12) and Adelaide (-11) make up the bottom five.

    The eight interstate clubs all have negative differentials.

    Make of that what you will.

    Brisbane (-3), Sydney (-6), Carlton (-6), Fremantle (-8) and Collingwood (-8) make up the middle table but all have differentials in the red.

  8. I believe that Kane Cornes is saying that the AFL is at a crisis point because of the discrepancy between the haves and the have nots in the competition. He might well have a point there but looking at the ladder after all teams have played four games, I can see North Melbourne and Melbourne on 3 wins and Port Adelaide in 8th place with leading contenders like Brisbane, Collingwood, Geelong, Adelaide and GWS all out of the eight. Yes, I understand it’s early days and there is the vagary of the fixture to take into account, but it’s definitely not crisis time quite yet.

    IMG_7305.jpeg

  9. 1 hour ago, Pates said:

    Are you serious? We are starting the season with a match, then a bye, then our second match, and another bye????

    This needs to be put on the agenda asap, it's a deadset joke and it compromises development and competition integrity.

    Settle down. KC’s being sarcastic about it because there are no VFL games at all next week due to the State Game between the VFL and SANFL associated with the Gather Round.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.