Hawny for Gawny

Honestly? None, maybe Pig for Bowey depending on his arm. I think the only ins and outs are injury dependent with only. Anyone have news on Oliver's ETA?

Getting Burguess'ed has got to be a top 3 demoralizing feeling.

St Kilda being able to start the last two seasons the same and fade out the same is uncanny,

Don't see goody and the team doing it this year, but maybe if they convince JJ to stay next year with offer of competing or taking that wing.

FFS you have to having a [censored] poor day with this attitude, who cares if they get the kids involved, do you really think having the kids in the song is going to impact us?

Are we watching the same game? Lachie seems to take contact all the time from what I've seen this season.

Thank you, this is a team that should have beat Collingwood 2x and their wins were gritty and tough. While ours is disappointing? Come on

Only if you want him to turn up for 30 mins, as sad as it is he is the PERFECT sub

6. Viney 5. Chandler - the lack of votes for him so far insane, 3 goals, 2 goal assists, 10 score involvements. 4. Brayshaw 3. GAWNY 2. Pickett 1. Salem/Langon

Crows with some big outs, Obviously Laird is a huge out for them but I think Michaelanny has been unreal for them and him being managed is good news, with Rachele out we can't let Rankine or Tex get loose.

I reckon it depends on how the rest of the season, if he can keep his spot I can see him resigning but if he gets booted out again once clarry comes back I think he leaves.

Not in favour of it as those above have mentioned along with the fact I don't think more than half the comp should make finals, there is also more drama/emotion in sneaking into finals at 8 then getting in at 10

Disagree, Felt like Taj had more impact than Spargo did therefore Spargs is at the bottom of the small forwards list atm

McVee to put Rankine in his pocket, after what he did to Charlie I want him on Izak

While I don't mind the idea of bowey in that position I'd rather keep Bowey where he is playing well and bring Chandler in for Spargo

Votes make sense, can't dispute it while Joe had some soft ones he was having a good game

There's been a lot of comments about who the most important player on this team is and the consensus seems to be either May or Oliver but is there any one as influential as a firing Max Gawn?

Exactly, covers forward and back but the important part is his athleticism, his biggest thing is his speed and leap. Injecting that into the game in the 2nd half is more valuable than a player like JJ who a solid player but doesn't have an xFactor quality

don't forget about Tom "Swallow" Sparrow and Lachie "Ed Langdon" Hunter

Don't need it when MAX is playing like that

MAX GAWN its been a while since I've felt this way but I'm living my name

6. HAWNY FOR GAWNY - Brody stays out next week, immense, sorry I ever doubted anything about you ever (4th highest rated game of anyone this year) 5. C Petracca - 4 goals, enough said 4. Melk - 2 goals, the winner what a mark. 3. JUD - Charlie Cameron who? (Yes I know he kicked 2) 2. Gus - Helmet 1. Gawn again - BEST PLAYER, BEST BEARD

I don't think Goody is the type of guy to suddenly make the call to take Grundy out ahead of this 2048 point game against the Lions, I think grundy has probably pulled up sore and won't be able to compete, but all we can do is speculate.

I agree, we say we want 3 tall FWDs but we don't have 3, Gawn can provide that structure and create contests/clunk a few while we play JVR and Fritta/whoever, this is only possible if Gawn commits to the time and gets the training. Max is probably better behind the ball but our defense is good enough that it isn't needed.

He always has been, Max has been an average to slightly above average tap ruck but his value around the ground has been what's made him insane. I don't think he is 100% fit after that injury, an older and giant body doesn't bounce back in 5 weeks though he may be healed. If we look at Tommo's acl he was pretty stiff and average last year but this year he's looked decent when in, obviously not the same person but I think Gawn may need a rest against a North or Hawthorn.