Edm

Don’t get the Tom lynch or tex argument you can’t have more than 3 kpf i actually think it should only be 2 curnow most goals cameron probably best overall player this year and Tom Hawkins goals and goal assists probably gives him nod as well as geelongs record tom lynch only kicked 19 goals against top 8 teams with bags at the end of the year against hawks who didn’t even play sicily on him and Essendon who were cooked

If we could some how add Karl Amon and Tom dekoning to our list next year that would fill so many needs Need a classy mid who can kick goals and de koning perfect replacement for Jackson Whether we use freo first round this year for de koning and we still could Get freos 23 first too Would obviously need to shed some salary somehow too

Just read news clip from leigh Montagna about st kilda trading out some older players to reset their list. maybe we could be interested in a few players ie Tim Membrey, Jack Billings or jade Gresham for our forward line

Depends how you look at it bulldogs have a surplus of midfielders and key forwards, they need a fwd/ruck (lobb) key back (Jones) you have JUH and sam Darcy up forward and your not going to trade them you could fill out rest of squad with naughton trade, (two first round picks) get in some quality young talent or trade and get some X factor players like cam Zurharr etc imagine a team with English lobb and Darcy in it all over 206cm

Adelaide -rankine G coast - harmes,anb, pick 2 & pick 4 second round pick Adelaide melb - Ben king second round pick west coast west coast - Jackson we have plenty of small half forward types in vfl to cover anb and harmes and frees up some cap maybe Gold Coast use a pick on established mid like Tom Mitchell would u swap Ben king for jackson?

Maybe still want a freo first round pick?

Three team trade gws - get lobb harmes freo first round pick melb - Josh Kelly or Whitfield and Logue freo- Jackson ???

I’m terms of list management paying two ruckman 1.5 million plus a year, and they both don’t play that well forward isn’t a great idea?

As much as I love Luke Jackson, if he is too leave. What about a trade of Oscar Allen and no. 1 pick, maybe a second pick too for Luke Jackson. We need a key forward and he is about to hit his prime years

Yeah thats why I’m saying if they are willing to pay part of his contract we are in the window of winning multiple flags, doubt any first rounder is going to give great value next season offer 1st round pick and they potentially pay 150-200k of his salary jaegar very different to dunstan did u see jaegar against us this year was awesome in that drawn game

Surely Jaeger O'Meara is worth a look? Probably the only real need at the moment is outside polish and real class depending on how much his contract is and what Hawthorn will accept. Maybe the Hawks will agree to pay part of his salary?

I was ok with hogan leaving IF HE wanted too, only if we got compensated what he is worth. It feels like everyone is trying to come up with reasons for him not being any good.No player is perfect and remember he is ONLY 23 What about Carey, fevola,Alistair Lynch, Barry hall etc Players like hogan are franchise players who put bums on seats, yes hogan is a risk but so is the draft. im not sure what Gibbs treloar lever Weller Neale etc are all getting paid at there clubs but I’m pretty sure it’s not near 1.2 -1.3m what Fremantle think hogan is worth. Now Fremantle want to play hardball and take there own risks what if Kennedy has a major injury next year and west coast might start thinking Hogan’s available or even with these new rules ie no hands in the back, one player starting in goal square hogan could kick 70+ for Dees and win a flag, pretty sure he won’t leave Dees after that.