Kev

The talls are too one dimensional. Straight line leads, no repeat efforts or coordination between them. The three talls could all be moving in opposite directions, then going again, making space and causing the opps to be spinning their heads in confusion. The static set up we have at the moment is a defenders dream.

Let the opps defend grass by zone, push everyone out and get our best kicks to deliver with precision. The congestion in there is the last few seasons strategy (Though it allows us to hold the ball in). I believe we should congest the wings and our back area, and open our forward area, at least sometimes during the game. Open forward area allows us leads to the flanks and ability to get it over the back.

I believe they all have their strengths that the structure doesn't cater to. Schache can mark well when given clear air and is a good kick. Needs the others to kick well to him and for the halves to pushing be away from goal. Chandler will hit the ball at pace, manoeuvre in tight areas and when 'on', snaps well. Ball has to hit the ground or a chaos delivery, for him to come into his own. Laurie is more of a mid, though works best when the stoppages occur, powerful through the hips and will bring others into play. Spargo is a pressure forward, though if they get the ball into his hands outside the 50, he can hit up players. Bombing it in, then he is focused on the defender and not creating.

Given his size and light frame, why isn't he flying above the packs. I agree, throw himself recklessly at the high ball get his knees up high and into the opps, worst effect is it puts some opps on the ground and pushes the ball front and centre. If only the coaches would tell him that is what they want from him. If they are telling and he is not listening, then that culture, brand and Melbourne way doesn't work with him. Take a leaf out of the book of Bowser.

Thanks for creating the debate. It is the way we play. The coaches haven't evolved our ways. First half, we tried the old get the ball in and hold it there (2 goals in a half). In the third, the clearances from the centre got us back in, by having some space for Fritta to operate in. Sydney adjusted, and went down the corridors on us, as we tired in the fourth. Cannot waste the domination of inside 50's, like we did in the first half. Push those little forwards out of the area. They are clogging the space, and not getting back to be front and centre. The angles of the lead are straight, really need to hit a pack from the side, or run into space with angles. In my opinion Derm is wrong about the players, it is the structure. At this level they all have some capacity, if only we could bring the best out of each other. Get a forwards coach!

Wow, very little respect for anyone and the league, also runs through the pre game drills of GWS. I guess, so long as Woodens are up, the club doesn't mind having fools in the side.

Why are the GWS cheers referencing sheep to the Woodens?

Huge isn't it. The halfback stocks are dwindling. I'd be tempted to play Spargo back there. Fast, can put pressure on opps, has a good kick, loves spreading to get away from the opps. Not kicking enough goals, and plenty of small forwards to choose from. Spargo for the big men's club!

In the before Christmas preseason, Jed was hammering it. Looked fit, put on more size, was getting plenty of plays in the sims, and generally showing good skills. He was looking like a Petty clone. After Christmas, not as much involvement as the others really started to ramp up their intensity, he tapered off. He will be given a chance in AfL, sometime this year, in my opinion.

I believe the fixture is to oppose the NRL, the O (opening) round will probably stay and we should continue to claim the first game against Sydney in NSW.

Carlton better do something, otherwise the Northern States opening round is a game of errors Thursday (except for Sydney's last quarter), and an early blowout Friday. Not a great spectacle or encouragement for AFL.

FRIDAY, MARCH 8 Essendon v Northern Bullants (NEC Hangar, 5:00pm, 4x25min) Casey Demons v Port Melbourne (Casey Fields, 6:30pm, 4x25min) Geelong Cats v Werribee (Deakin University Waurn Ponds, 6:30pm, 4x25min) Frankston v Williamstown (Kinetic Stadium, 7:00pm, 4x25min) SATURDAY, MARCH 16 Casey Demons v Coburg (Casey Fields, 12:00pm, 4x25min)

FRIDAY, MARCH 8 Essendon v Northern Bullants (NEC Hangar, 5:00pm, 4x25min) Casey Demons v Port Melbourne (Casey Fields, 6:30pm, 4x25min) Geelong Cats v Werribee (Deakin University Waurn Ponds, 6:30pm, 4x25min) Frankston v Williamstown (Kinetic Stadium, 7:00pm, 4x25min) SATURDAY, MARCH 16 Casey Demons v Coburg (Casey Fields, 12:00pm, 4x25min)

Not the only one to take too much out of the praccy against the Boos. We regularly fail to cope with a slippery ball. Hoping for some repent and redemption. Coaches to help them see the problems and fix it. They must be hurting! Balloon has been popped, time to build the season. We need team work and an unselfish approach to assist your mate to be a better player. More 1 percenters, talking and to hit the targets. Good result to build the NSW AFL vs NRL.

I thought we got back in the game ear.y in the third, kicked straight and put enough pressure on them to kick only points. The lead changed a few times then Sydney went down the middle and our half forwards did nothing when the ball came in there. No answers, no plan, no connections and lacked tempo control. Disappointed with our skills. In those conditions need to just do the basics well. Aberration, reset this week, and make sure they all have a ball in their hands 24hrs a day. Wouldn't have minded getting a forward coach, our leading patterns didn't work, the crumbers were unseen. Good start for Caleb and Blake. May kept us in the game in the first half. Grundy gave us a lesson in aggression and dominated. Nothing like our game against Carlton last week. Will need to pull the finger out in time for the next one.

Wow, Sydney are going to be fired up, given their pre-game. Hoping they blow up and cannot run out the game, from all that emotional energy lost before the bounce.

Goody says Clarry, "happy and healthy". Great to hear that the engine room will be running on all cylinders. Go Dees.

I've heard they do that.

I agree, Billings will have to earn his spot or they want to ease him into it. Given Kossie is back next week, the small forwards are under pressure for spots.

@leave it to deever

Agree, watching him at training, he is a plodder, always well behind everyone during laps. His close work is good, but we will know that, though if he gets the ball to the outside runners, could become a dangerous link.

From the training, I forgot to mention that Williams has been supervising Traccs goal kicking at the end of the sessions. I mostly see Choco emphasising the spin the right hand gives to the ball as it leaves the hand and drops to the foot. It is the slow spin for Tracc that he slams home. Occasionally gets the ball spinning too quick or with a wobble, and the ball will go a little left or right. The lovely drop happens when not much thought or he starts kicking them. Hoping his constant repetitions and hard work have paid off and he gets 3 or 4 goals tonight.

Will be a good game against a tough team. Go Dees, hit them early and frequently.

Scarfs are still sent out, used to be able to pick them up at the game. In the app or website of the MFC, there is a page that you indicate if you want a voucher or the scarf and the plastic members card. I also think an email was sent giving a link to the opt in/out alternatives. The links send you to the ticket masters site. I have attached a screen shot from the email. I cannot send links as they only work after I have signed in to my account.

What is the rule for substituting an emergency for a selected or interchange player prior to the game?