Alan Smithee

Ummm, token gesture at best Nasher. It another interesting comment by Gardner. Going by what he said in the press, he's pretty much already made his decision, wouldn't you think? "Believe me it's no fun playing footy under a coach you think is an absolute dick" You're right there. I am sure I saw a bit last night that just helped to reinforce that theory.

Fair comments Nasher. I too agree. My immediate thoughts on this matter( bar the obvious issue of what lay ahead for the club and the board), was with Gardner making the comment regarding the fickle supporter. I trust he had considered the ramifications and possible misirepresentation of his comments. I also trust he had differentiated in his own mind the difference between the emotion driven 'cut snake' supporter and the paid, voting member of the club who has simply had enough of this 10 year roller coaster journey.

Deanox, I'm not sure he Sickto does. I can't speak for him. He makes a valid point. THe footy dept. is crucial in the business plan and the long term financial future and security of the club. We can't afford to neglect it. Gardner needs to be accountable. Just my interpretation mate.

I just heard the re-run of the interview on-line Mfc. I can't help but agree with you. That comment, and the context in which it was pitched, was disappointing. I'm sorry to say this, but I fear his wish of having a few xtra scarves come monday just may come true.

Thanks for the heads-up on the article Seddo. My take on the article as far as Gardner's position on the coaching issue is one of resignation and acknowledgement that there has to be action. "I think last night has just about dusted it. It was probably done a few weeks ago, if you're honest about it. "In many ways the situation for discussing it more seriously is certainly upon us." I also feel for Sickto and his points. I firmly believe the responsibility lay upon the whole club, which needs to continue to improve. He said the team was performing in stark contrast to Melbourne's off-field record, where it had become financially stable with a strong administration and was looking forward to a new Olympic Park headquarters. I don't want to see a finger pointing exercise occur within the club. IMO Gardner needs to accept his fair share of accountability. He should not be (esp publicly) distancing himself from the football dept as he appears to be in this article. He talks of complacency. Lets not see the current board fall into that trap either. Its easy to do. Their job is far from finished.

Sylvinator, I agree with your take on 'fickle' mate. I would like to know if thats what Gardner was implying. As I said earlier in this thread, I didn't hear the interview. Does anyone here have a transcript of what he said?

breyside, all due respect here Bud, how can you be so sure of this. Surely Gardner & the board can't park on this one?

I didn't hear the interview. As for his comments, I hope that was not the case. As he is the President of our great club and the mouthpeice of the current board, he can ill afford to alienate the supporter base. On further thought, I can't understand why he would say something like that. Disappointing.

Take it easy Biff...just a bit of fun. You're being a bit sensitive. Is it just your pre game nerves tnite? Go Dees!!

Beautiful work J.

It would potentially be up there with Gough's spat in the mid '70's?

Cheers Tim..I just cruise the board now & then & its enjoyable - a good read mate.

I may be wrong but haven't a few of those posters left the scene?

Uh huh!

Its up & running

Is there some kind of 'code of ethics' or similiar whereby Demonlanders who post on "ology are hereby despised, shunned or whatever?

Yep. Same here Deanox. Probs with their server.

Yeah , probably

Agreed. Can't help but feel it can get better once we settle in to our new home & pull this 'Team Melbourne' gig together, Pool resources, revenue and sponsorship ...it is the way forward.

Now thats more like it!!

We definitely went Broady Deanox. I think the Govt were one step beyond & shifted the posts on us with the gaming boundaries. J.A era if I recall.

Why not. It would be your best post of the night.

Given that, what then trigged our move into Broady where there ws no pokie license? Are you so sure?

Fair enough 45HG...I admire your passion & hear what your saying!! It would be something else if it happened!

45 I don't think few of us her on this site do. With all respect, what's your point? I am just pleased for Neitz to make it to 300. Celebrate it as he will. Make sure you be there for it if you can.