joeboy

My son's football team had a guest coach tonight who was asked to name the hardest opponent he'd ever encountered on the football field . He answered , Cameron Bruce , and his name was Brad Johnson - The Bulldogs' Brad Johnson .

And the winner is ... over to you Joeboy (you're the judge)

I'd have to say that Grimes 16 is this week's winner for his ( not unlikely ) prediction that Brown and Fevola would both be shut down .

6 - Sylvia - in sensational form

5 - McKenzie - must be nominated this week

4 - Frawley - an almost perfect defender's game , as usual

3 - Bartram - plays with vigour and courage

2 - Scully - would have voted higher but for some poor disposal

1 - Bruce - wiped Power , and mopped up almost everything that came near

Bail - fearless attacking game

Bartram- continued outstanding season

Bennell - was rarely sighted

Bruce - was great again

Davey - some important possessions

Dunn - loved his endeavour

Frawley - nothing to dislike

Garland - made few errors

Green - important when needed

Jamar - made an impression

Johnson - did his share

Jones - terrific in close

Jurrah - a poor game

MacDonald - fantastic first half

McDonald - effective tagging game

Morton - effective linking game

Rivers - safe and sensible

Scully - prolific but wasteful

Sylvia - in sublime form

Watts - effective without intensity

Wonaeamirri - had little involvement

McKenzie - a powerhouse worker

Bail - classy and composed

Bartram - tough and dominant

Bennell - some classy cameos

Bruce - outstanding first half

Davey - was all class

Dunn - an important ingredient

Frawley - seemingly perfect game

Garland - always so smooth

Green - great when needed

Jamar - continued wonderful year

Johnson - played his part

Jones - there when needed

Jurrah - ready to explode

MacDonald - Brisbane surely regrets

Maric - had an impact

Morton - tried but lost

Rivers - safe and sound

Scully - lowered his standard

Sylvia - what we wanted

Watts - just a game

Wonaeamirri - zest and enthusiasm

McKenzie - effective without frills

6- Bruce

5- Bartram

4- Frawley

3- Sylvia

2- Garland

1- Jamar

Adam Goodes to be the most unattractive player to set foot on the G during the game .

Yeah, he did a great job in keeping Eddie Munster to just 4 goals.

classic

No clear winner again this week , so the prize jackpots again

Joeboy, you forgot about Sylvia. I was looking for him cause he was absolutely terrible, he had 11 turnovers, double the amount of any other player on the field and most importantly 5 in the last quarter. I am sick to death of this team not being able to win the close ones

Sylvia - just a frontrunner

i read this 3 word player analysis every week, and i disagree with almost every one of your comments

You sound like my wife !

Dunn wasn't that good.

His opponent , arguably one of the best players in the competition , had 6 kicks !

6 - Dunn

5 - Watts

4 - MacDonald

3 - Davey

2 - Frawley

1 - Johnson

Bail - good under pressure

Bartram - was rarely sighted

Bate - selfish and pedestrian

Bennell - occasional classy moves

Bruce - mistakes but passionate

Davey - erred but thrilling

Dunn - career best game

Frawley - let nothing through

Garland - had occasional lapses

Green - couldn't gain momentum

Jamar - successfully broke even

Johnson - finally earned role

Jones - tough and relentless

Jurrah - thrilling but lazy

MacDonald - one of best

Moloney - poor until injured

Morton - needs caffeine tablets

Rivers - finding feet again

Scully - impressive relentless running

Watts - will be nominated

McKenzie - blood and guts

Yes he did. Best game I've seen him play.

Then obviously you didn't see him play against StKilda !

Anything wrong with what I said?

Firstly you were disqualified for making more than 1 prediction , and secondly Watts didn't play well

And the winner is ...

Over to you Joeboy. You're the judge!

Firstly , anyone who offered more than 1 prediction was immediately disqualified for not adhering to the rules .

Honorable mentions must be given to ' Demon Dave ' and 'Grandson of Gun' but from my point of view there were no clear winners and the jackpot is doubled for next week's game .

6 Bruce

5 Jamar

4 M$aloney

3 Mckenzie

2 Garland

1 Davey

GREEN ?????????

6 - Green

5 - Bruce

4 - Sylvia

3 - Jamar

2 - Garland

1 - MacDonald

Bartram - excellent stopping game

Bate - rarely got going

Bennell - didn't do enough

Bruce - wonderful all day

Cheney - was rarely noticed

Davey - some occasional brilliance

Dunn - fantastic first half

Frawley - performed as expected

Garland - Inspector Gadget returns

Green - a vintage performance

Jamar - owned the centre

Johnson - fumbled and stumbled

Jones - stuck at task

Jurrah - needed the run

MacDonald - provided important aggression

Moloney - important centre breaks

Rivers - reliable and safe

Scully - important linking game

Sylvia - an important return

Trengove - see Scully's comments

Watts - little to excite

McKenzie - tough in clinches

Joeboy to just get half of his 3 word player analysis post correct.

Let's make this a weekly column whereby all are invited to make 1 (and only 1) prediction for the Demons' upcoming match, and let's see who gets closest to the pin.

I'll get things started by declaring that Jordie McKenzie will be nominated for this week's Rising Star Award.

Why is there no comment on Cheney?

There is now, thanks.

Bell , Warnock , Rivers

Bruce , Garland , Frawley

Green , McDonald , Sylvia

Bennell ,Watts , Jurrah

Davey , Newton , Dunn

Jamar , Trengove

Moloney

Scully , Bail , Bate , Jones

OUT : Grimes ( inj ) ,Jetta , MacDonald , Cheney ,Bartram , Spencer , McKenzie

IN : Sylvia , Jurrah , McDonald , Warnock , Bell , Newton , Bail

6 - Watts - played 4 solid quarters , unlike most others

5 - Trengove - always kept running and involving himself

4 - Bruce - excellent first half only

3 - Green - clasy when he could get it , which was probably not regularly enough

2 - Dunn - showed some zest though body language can be improved

1 - Frawley - lowered his colours to Milne , but kept at task