Jump to content

Brock 08

Members
  • Posts

    16
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Brock 08

  1. Can you explain this to me? What has Sylvia shown us so far? Has he had a BOG yet? I know Brock's had a few including a final.

    I am sick of the excuses for Sylvia about not having done a full preseason and injuries. I would be happy for him to move on now while he still has value, instead of us all writing in 5 years time "Oh, he would have been a gun if he could have got his body right". He may turn out to be great elsewhere, but they may be because he was given a wake-up call.

    i think sylvia is good and tough but could be good trade bate...always shows glimpses of potential like against the bulldogs when he kicked the goal to put us infront.....yet we still lost (i'm talking about the 1st time we played them)

  2. Pathetic

    This [censored] could potentially turn Judd away from choosing the MFC

    If so, McLean, Carroll and Rivers ahould all be traded

    Absolute brainless morons

    hey!! calm down mister yze magic..if any1 should be traded its yze. i would love to get judd. the news says that the other ppl have admitted to initiating the fight. what do u expect our players to do....sit there and call 000 (or whatever it is) and hope that the police come in time to save them?? (take that back btw. i actually really like yze, i just wanted a come back)

  3. i know its hard...but i think people should just wait for Judd to announce which club he picks.

    its getting abit rediculous people guestimating which club he's already supposedly chosen.

    hell prob announce it in the next few days...patience!

    thats a bit harsh, we're just trying to tell ourselves that judd is coming home. if thats ur opinion why are u reading all of the posts about judd..."paitence!!"

  4. Does it seem strange to anyone else that Jones can poll more votes than pendlebree and selwood (he polled the same amount of votes as both of them put togethor) yet he only gets 17 points in the bloody rising star. I mean I know Selwood has been playing with a lot of superstars, possibly making it harder to stand out but I definately think that Jones is more of a match winner. It is much easier to play good football if the team is able to feed the ball to you a lot. DOnt get me wrong, I think Selwood is going to be (and is) a fantastic player but it will be interesting to see how he goes when Geelong are 14th on the ladder. Will he be a favourite to get the clubs best & fairest next year???

  5. Let's be hypothetical and say that Chris Judd rules out all the clubs not at the MCG which leaves Melbourne and Collingwood.

    Apart from his previous loyalties, do we have anything to offer Judd?

    They have better training facilities until we move, but we will be sharing after that.

    They have bigger crowds

    Ian Johnson can offer his missuss a job, yet so can Eddie.

    We have a great young list, they have DALE Thomas.

    We have a new coach and a great start, they have up tp date technology like at WC.

    I don't like saying this, but it's better not to get our hopes up.

    What have I missed?

  6. With todays confirmation that Carlton have secured the services of our caretaker coach Mark Riley, we have now lost a SIGNIFICANT amount of player and coaching knowledge (that relates specifically to our team) at the top end. Daniher, Fagan and now Riley have all departed.

    Mark Riley had another year of his contract to run. What is the point in having contracts if we do not enforce them. I understand it would have been difficult for Mark to spend 12 more months in an assistant role when he had been a stand in coach but at the end of the day, that is what he was hired to do and would have done if Neale had remained until the season's end.

    His knowledge would have been invaluable for Dean Bailey during a one year crossover or transition period.

    I am a little angry at the MFC for allowing him to step away from his commitments and unless there are special circumstances we don't know about, I ask the club to "PLEASE EXPLAIN" - HONESTLY and issue a press release or e-mail to members.

    -I disagree, I want Bailes to make his own judgement of the team without danihers loyal influence (ie godfrey, ward, miller, giving up jolly). this way dean bailey can come in and make a fresh start and the players will have to EARN his respect. That's right...play well or there a GONER!! currans gone, rileys gone, fagans gone, danihers gone, now we have BAILEY, CONOLLY, and some new coaches who we dont really know too much about. i just hope the fitness coach lifts his game under deans instruction or is cut. go dees

  7. Obviously if we're to get Judd, pick 4 would probably be going to WC. But is he the only player we'd consider trading the pick for, or should we be shopping it around to see if anyone is interested, and what should we be trying to get for it?

    good call mate. dont forget that brock was something like pick no. 5 i think and judd was a no. 3 pick, so pick 4 is something in between--the skills of judd and the toughness and leadership of brock.....i hope

    btw, does anyone remember, was johnstone a no. 1 pick?

  8. David Neitz said he will hand it over.

    Brock is arguably too young and inexperianced.

    Leaving aside the unlikely event of judd coming to this club, who is likely to succeed the big man?

    James McDonald for one or two years?

    -opinions?

×
×
  • Create New...