-
Posts
995 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Posts posted by Face Your Demons
-
-
Is it just a Coincidence that no team has won a game this season after playing Melbourne. Might have to load up on Sydney next week.
-
From The Contested Footy site
The Pink Umpire debacle
After Friday nights game against Melbourne and the Western Bulldogs the question has to be asked what is the AFL thinking? The AFL has in recent times made a point of ensuring that the umpires are distinguishable form the players on the ground. This has meant a shift from the traditional all white attire to an assortment of colours depending on the teams playing.
Last night however the AFL decided it would be wise to have the umpires in a pink shirt and black shorts. You may think, well that is not an issue is it? Well it is when the Demons have already marked their intentions to wear a strip that contained pink instead of the traditional red. Make no mistake I think the gesture from the AFL is great to show their support for a worthy cause but surely it could have been done in another way.
I say this because late in the last quarter Melbourne players could be seen in the heat of battle handball directly towards the umpire due to the pink strip. This I believe is understandable from a player knowing that their jumper on the night consisted of pink in the top half. If this was not a close game questions would not be being asked. However Melbourne was leading when Clint Bartram handballed to what he believed to be a team mate, which turned out to be an umpire. The result was a turn over and subsequent goal to the Dogs. Captain of Melbourne James McDonald has said on the issue “I don’t think it was thought through too well. As players we make mistakes and obviously someone’s made a mistake at the AFL.”
The AFL has apologized for the mistake which is no consolation for the Melbourne Football Club or football fans. This is a multi-million dollar business and mistake like this should not be happening. Clubs live and die by wins and for a club to be at a disadvantage due to the umpire’s attire is ridiculous in 2010. I personally never had a problem with the all white strip the umps have worn for over a century. Yes it way not be great for telecasts but who watches the umpires anyway? No club has an all white strip, yes Collingwood, North Melbourne and Geelong have plenty of white but it was never an issue before.
Consistency is all we ask for as supporters of this great game. The AFL should be doing more to make sure mistake like this do not occur. The standard was set the umpires should not clash with the clubs jumpers, which I have no problems with. But to suddenly change the rules seems like a ridiculous decision considering the subsequent clash that eventuated.
-
agree 100%
3 votes for Scully come brownlow night.
And who gives the brownlow votes? They got everything else wrong last night
-
It hurts but its a good hurt. we now have a team to be proud of. as for the umps,enjoy your few weeks off
-
Whats the point of two goal at each end umps if they are going to be over ruled
Thank god it wan'st the grand final. unless of course it was the flith getting robbed
-
Bring on the future. flag as early as next year guys
-
MFC ask for the ump to be to different colors tonight and where overruled
-
I don't like to blame umps but you saw it
-
we are being robbed here guys
-
2min 15 sec
-
3 min 45 sec only 3 points
-
5 min 45 sec to go
-
cant be much time on
-
I'm so [censored] at the monment . are we home
-
we have to go on and win now
-
I have a good feeling about tonight, not sure why. But a win and were in the eight for at least one week
-
It Jimmy thinks it okay, Then i'm fine with it.
-
Bring your A game or lose. One quarter will never win a game.
-
Out Macdonald in JORDIE MCKENZIE. Anyone knows what was wrong with him today
-
Takes a lot of getting used to.
-
did i mention that i picked the wrong day to give up smoking!!
Demons showing things now that i didnt think they could. well done.
This is the reason we do smoke
-
Six in a row. 14 points and the 3 quarter time
-
Gee $1.51 0n betfair could have got $8.50 only 5 min ago
-
Gee North look tired, dees are running.
Three things we'd like to see this saturday?
in Melbourne Demons
Posted
Nic Nat had one hell of a limp after the game last week