http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/afl...2-19742,00.html
i can smell a 2nd round pick + R Shaw!!!
that would annoy me but i know the MFC want picks....
i doubt they will give us pick 11 coz they told sydney they wouldnt for ROK and he is probably better than green.....
cmon melbourne lets do some dealing!!!!
maybe a 2nd round and a 3rd round pick???
i think we dont have many guys who can use the footy.....
particularly if we lose green and now we dont have YZE!!!
you need guys who can hit a target and accumulate the footy....
he is starting to do that and if he were to go somewhere and turn into a super player, which i really think he will be, id be extremely pi$$ed off
can someone tell me why CJ is on the table?
was he not one of the shining lights for the year??
would it not be a waste to put five years into him - use a father son pick on him - and send him to a club for not much for him to become a real solid player over the next 3-4 years!!!
am i the only one that would be extremely unhappy if he were to be traded.....
I would only want Seaby if we could get Vickery!!!
PJ and Vickery
with Seaby as the back up..... and if need be as a forward!!!!
better than Jamar and Meeson......
Brad Green + pick 19 to Port Adelaide
Pick 4 to Melbourne
Mark Jamar + pick 51 to West Coast
Mark Seaby to Melbourne
Pick 1 - Jack Watts
Pick 4 - Vickery
Pick 17 -
Pick 37 -
Seaby -
Etc
Etc
PSD pick 1 -
that would give us tall timber for the next ten years!!!!
1,4,17,19,35
do what we can to get pick 4 - if that means trade green and someone else then do it!!
if we can get watts and vickery - look out!!!
(Note- i love brad green and i would prefer to trade bruce but that wont happen)
Hawthorn get:
O'Keefe and Melbourne third round pick
Hawthorn lose:
First round pick and Boyle
Sydney get:
Green, Boyle and Wheatley
Sydney lose:
OKeefe and Second round pick
Melbourne get:
Hawthorn's first rounder and Sydney's second round pick
Melbourne lose:
Green, Wheatley and Third round pick
Thoughts?
back to the talking point!!
i will rip up my membership if we get rid of CJ!
we have put so much work into him - sacrificed a pick for father son and he is now starting to show his class!!
if they get rif od him for any pick i will be bitterly dissapointed
Laidley " Hamish McIntosh's name was mentioned today, so even with Hamish we'll sit down and if there's real interest there and a club loves Hamish, we'll have a look"
that sounds like a come and get me i reckon...........
nobody probably asked about him but they will now!!!
i think you will find that is laidley saying offer us a decent pick and you can have him.........
HT these are the games teams play in trade week....
http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/sport/a...5016212,00.html
it would be sad to see green go because i think he has been the one big improvement at the MFC.
But......... he is the only one we we can trade....... id would hurt me a bit to see it
but if we could get pick 4 - perhaps Green and Bell to PA for Pick 4
or Green and pick 35 to PA for pick 4
then you get perhaps Watts and a Vickery and there you have possibly ten years of serious size. strength and power in your team!!!
that would be nice!!!!
Jaded im with you
i would trade bruce for another first round pick!
he wont be there when we win a flag so lets getta another young gun!!!
picks are priceless this year and Bruce has some value!!
It actually saddens me to see Wheatley finish 9th.....
he should have been in the top three at least
and for him to finish behind bartram is not far of a discrace!
Agree
dont need him!!
PJ is a good payer and we have jamar for another year i think due to contract....
in tha time lets hope spencer steps up....
more important things to go after.... a straight out tap ruckman like taylor would be no good to us