leave it to deever

Viney should not be dropped. Fritta is very lucky. But I dare say if we play like this again this weekend, then the calls for Goodys head will start to grow. He's a premiership coach and that counts for heaps. But as the old saying goes ...a week is a long time in footy. Would be a shame to lose him but after yesterday, I'm not sure we are heading in the right direction. At what point do we seriously consider his replacement? Does failure to make finals again this year count?

Absolutely needs to be dropped. But we who can we replace him with? Probably doesn't matter because you can't gift him another game after that.

Ditto

Absolutely not. Well maybe Turner but we do not have that luxury as yet. And the high hopes for Jvr to be another champion chf are fading fast. I don't think putting him the ruck last year helped his form and confidence. As for Disco he's a lovely shot at goal but i think we are messing him around too by playing him in a position he's not really suited for. Id certainly try May fwd but we tried Petty there and it didn't work in the slightest. Here's an idea Mfc, rather than having to keep trialling players in positions they are not suitable for, how about simply recruiting some who are?

For sure. They still have issues growing grass due to the silly orientation of the ground and it's stand heights so there's that.

We haven't rebuilt the fwd line. I'm glad we are giving Jeffo a run but we really only have one replacement for Jvr and Fritta and that's Milkshake. And his body must be close to cooked. And he's not a tall fwd either. And Turner hasn't proven himself as a fwd yet. So yea my expectations are in check with a fwd line of Fritta, Jvr and Disco. For sure. But yesterday it wasn't just our fwd line. It was the entire team. Apologies to Chandler. But sheesh one player against last year's second last team. Now I really have no expectations

Yep. We played well against the giants but to be comprehensively smashed by last year's second last team is demoralizing. Fritta should be dropped for a month for his performance. Not a single tackle off the back of a lethargic game prior and a lackluster year last. It's one thing to have an off day but the zero tackle count really speaks towards attitude. I didn't play a great deal of the game and for sure wasn't very good but I always knew that if had trouble getting a kick, I could always lay a tackle. But the club hasn't really recruited any decent replacement for him for three years now. No wonder he doesn't fire. A game each week is a given.

Thank you. Someone's head should roll. Surely. I really don't know that much about footy but I certainly know that we have done absolutely nothing to fix our fwd line set up. Credit for trying the Grundy experience but we let him go and didn't bring in any replacement. It's just baffling

This is what really urks me. We've all said it. Those responsible need to go. Now. And as for the players that openly talked about trades, do we really want them at the club?

We have relied on May, Lever, Oliver, Max, Tracc, Fritta and Kozzie. Two were out. The two midfielders have been all over the place . Max gets no support and Lever and Fritta have gone backwards.

A couple more performances like this and absolutely.

Not disagreeing but how well did we do without one in 23? Melksham made a big difference and without Gus going down we would have more than likely won a flag. And yet here we are 18 months later playing like this. It's mind boggling. We know that we have had some players that have had trouble that has been advertised outside of the club. Our backline today put in its worst effort I can remember. But back to our fwd line, Fritta has a lot to answer for and Jvr has definitely gone backwards big time. Why has the club been so lazy on not addressing this glaring dearth of consistent talent? There's an old saying that complacency brings failure. Perhaps winning a flag after so long has contributed. For whatever reason, this was a great list we had and it deserved more than one flag. Surely heads must roll.

What the hell happened?

Very worrying signs.

I think it would be almost fair to call or season finished after this game. It's a long list of non performers but Fritta not laying a single tackle sims him up. It's one thing to be out of form but not laying a tackle speaks about intent and attitude I'm afraid. Props to Chandler and JV today but I'm struggling to find any other positives. I feel like the wheels fell off today and this will be like the Freo game last year. It's early in the season and I think last week exhausted us but the ot was the skill level that troubled me all day. Plus the predicament I mentioned pregame about not having a fwd line three years in a row. So there's that. Goody is officially under the pump and that's not easy for a premier coach.

No. He's still a very good player. Trouble is he's had to carry everything by himself for eons. The club admitted as much when it recruited Grundy. Did it bother replacing him ? Na. Just didn't care.

I want to see a lot of players dropped after today. But what I really want is every single person at the club responsible for not fixing our fwd line issues that have been so glaringly obvious for just too long. Surely that's fair. I think those of us who pay their membership and go each week deserve a lot better than this. Much,much ,much, better. It's hard to understand that we won a flag less than only FOUR years ago. And how far we have fallen since we almost beat the 23 premiers and we're likely to win a flag. I guess there are a couple of superstar midfielders that let us down and the club has done the rest. It's a shame really. I know it's early days but I think this will be a bad marker like that Freo game when things went belly up. I know it's not Goodys fault but I think it's alarm bells now and time to panic.... Time for a sweep for me. Cheers guys.

Yep. And to think we pinned our season on him last year as a fwd. He was good last week but had a mare today . And some people were complaining about the time slots we have. No wonder when we serve this type of tripe. I'm laying the blame totally on the club. How many of us have been howling about our abysmal fwd line? I hope Fritta gets dropped for a month. I don't care . It's one thing to not touch the pill but it's inexcusable to have not laid a single discernable tackle. See ya Fritta. Jvr has gone totally backwards. Oliver and Coney and Chandler have done well. But so many of them have been terrible. But the club goes first in blame for not having any players we can replace any of these players up forward. Big time.

The club has been expecting the backline to win games for us. Defenders don't kick winning scores.

I know our fwd line is non existent but this is not a good idea. In fact it sums up what has been wrong with this chub for three years. No forward line and no desire or effort to resolve it. As evidenced last year moving Petty up fwd. Didn't work then and won't work now. I understand why you mention it but it won't change anything. The club has been relying on our backline year after year to win games. Problem is and I'll type it slowly so the boffins at the club can read it , back lines don't kick winning scores. Where's the replacement for Hogan? Grundy, Joel Smith, Tmac, Jackson? Nah let's just not worry about it. Let's even move Jvr to play in the middle instead of finding a decent support for Max. As bad as our skills have been today, the club has to accept responsibility on not having the cattle so we can drop a few of the offenders out there . They have been equally as bad.

That handball by Spargo sums it up.

Third quarter almost over and Fritta has his third kick. He is a shadow of the guy that helped win our last flag. We have been playing such lazy footy all day. It's been a disgraceful effort.

How was that no free. So just go to ground and not get pinged then.

Might as well just kicked it for them. Well done Goody for making a change before it's all over.

That was ghastly.