Jump to content

Discussion on recent allegations about the use of illicit drugs in football is forbidden

Tinks

Members
  • Posts

    38
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Tinks

  1. 36 minutes ago, DubDee said:

    I’m happy about Wingard going to the hawks. So overrated. Never kicked more than 24 goals. Looks like a star a few times a year but is soft and lacks intensity. 

    I heard he wants a million a year?!? And trade would be one or two first rounders? 

    Madness!! 

    Smacks of desperation by Clarko n Co

    Kicked 43 goals in his second year (2013)

    43 in his third (2014)

    53 in his 4th (2015)

    then in the last two years he has moved more into the midfield and has averaged over 20 disposals and a goal a game.

    Not saying I rate him at a million dollars a year but he's certainly not a bad player

     

    • Like 4
  2. 1 minute ago, Demons11 said:

    I can see the trade now:

    Beams to Collingwood for pick 18

    Neale to Brisbane for pick 5 and 18

    Hogan to Freo for pick 5 and 18

    May and KK to Dees for pick 5 

    There's no way that either of the two QLD clubs do that but man would I love that

  3. 4 hours ago, P-man said:

    I can't answer the first question with conviction other than to say we started playing it last year and I hadn't noticed any other club using it until this year. OP is based on the assumption we were the first to use it.

     

     

    It's been used in the finals for about 3 years, I'm pretty sure we copied it. That being said, it suits us well so we copied it better

    • Like 1
  4. 23 hours ago, KingDingAling said:

    Well he is at least on 5. Has an easy run of ruck man coming up. Could very well be on 15-18 by the midway mark. Massive chance of winning the brownlow IMO, I am going to start offloading during the week, already into us to make the 8 at $12's, and heavily into Petracca for the rising star - which I still think he will win.

    Really want to be with you there as I reckon he will be the best player from this crop but Its really hard to win this having missed 5 games, in fact I think it has only been done once very early on if at all

  5. I agree but i put them in there for the sake of discussion. Some posters may disagree with you and I and I'm interested to hear what everyone has to say

    Id have Tyson in the middle and Brayshaw on a wing myself but i agree with the personnel

    I absolutely agree with you, I reckon people are really forgetting Tyson's 2014, he still think he has utter star potential, supposedly played through injury a lot this year

    • Like 1
  6. I love doing these, here we go

    FB: Jetta Dunn Garland
    HB: Melksham MacDonald Salem
    C: Watts Tyson Brayshaw
    HF: Petracca Pederson Vandenberg
    FF: Garlett Hogan Kent
    RR: Gawn Jones Vince
    INT: Viney Trengove Lumumba Harmes

    Depth: Pick 3 (Hopefully Parish), Pick 7 (Hopefully Curnow), Neal-Bullen, Frost, Bugg, Kennedy, Grimes, Stretch, Dawes

    Positives for mine are that this is becoming increasingly hard to do especially considering the fact that I can see (although maybe its real wishful thinking) Trengove getting back to becoming a really solid player rivalling our best mids). I can also see Salem improving into one of our best players and Tyson competing with Viney in becoming our number one mid. Frost is a real athlete and could push Lumumba out which makes for a really exciting young list.

    Despite the fact that it looks like we won't be so reliant on our veteran mids, I reckon if big Maxy Gawn or Jesse "The Kid" Hogan go down we are royally gone. I really don't rate Spencer around the ground and Dawes competes and seems like a good bloke to have around the club but the guy couldn't catch a cold. So here's to hoping we can get a ready made tall this draft. Anyone know of any good ruckman in the rookie draft or worth a sneaky late pick?

  7. I think the people that are annoyed he is captain are just the people that assume the captain should be the best player, if that were the case then yeah Trenners probably wouldn't be captain but according to people in the club (you know, the people that actually see his leadership) can't speak more highly of him. All we see is what's on the field and if people say he doesn't stand up I have seen it consistently from him way back when he got a hitout third man up through for a behind to win the game against port all the way up until he put us in front last week, didn't hear people complaining then when he again got 10 tackles, and 22 touches. As he gets a better fitness base, as he is 6 weeks behind, he will start to lift how many touches he gets. I would say Swallow is A-grade and last year in his captaincy he only averaged around 25 touches which is no where near the standard of Ablett or Swan (both averaging over 33) but because he averaged over 7 tackles a game as well. Obviously Jack has a way to go before he reaches that level but nothing tells me, with his attitude and hunger for success, that he can't achieve what any pick 2 should. Goes to show how reactionary footy fans can be when people were pretty pleased with his first few round back and then a commentator says something negative which plants a seed of doubt in an insecure melbourne fans head and they aren't confident enough to form their own opinions so they just copy Lethals

    • Like 1
  8. This is not my idea. i saw it on this article in the first comment.

    http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/more-news/draft-joust-to-secure-jack-viney/story-e6frf9jf-1226349309807

    but yeah, considering apparently the compo picks can't be used for the father-son rule, what if we traded our pick 3 for a player of high quality (such as the much discussed dangerfield) and then we get to use the 2 compo picks and get viney at a steal in the 2nd round. Not my idea but i saw it and wanted to share it with you guys?

  9. So agree, i read something today about one of the posters sons not wanting to be a demon supporter any more. A little harsh i thought.

    My dad has always told me that being a melbourne supporter was character building. we will do just fine in the future.

    hen we put in a bad performance I agree it hurts but realistically there isnt much we can do and we just have to hope for the best. We'll get there.

    Where are the Watts bashers this week?

  10. It can be bloody impossible to gain weight, that being said, we want strength rather than weight.

    If the players can be at the same weight and fitness but be significantly stronger then that sounds like a bonus to me

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...