monoccular

MFC alone wouldn't be taken notice of but if the whole Vic based clubs protested possibly there could be some traction

Without doubt the integrity blessed MRP will have a good unbiased look at that ? How about waiting for the full medical report before writing off Max and our year?

Nothing ever is certain, though everyone who sees a surgeon does not necessarily need nor have surgery.

Spencer in for Gawn Maybe Pedersen in for Weid or Hannah? Frost if fit for Melksham

Vindictiveness after a loss Or he plays and puts in a shocker.

Are you referring to Smithy? (Would work ok now that Joely is out for a while)!

Bruce was certainly excited.

Bloody maggots -- Jones should have benn given 50, instead a freebie goal to Collingwood.

Collingwood have taken handball lessons from Luke Beveridge -- how many times do they get away with blatant throws. And outrageous free to Collingwood for below the knees when it was actually kicking in danger.

I am a fan of his brother Sigmund Freude

Alir reads the play well and lays a decent tackle.

Is Brock McLean still involved with Carlscum?

Both Carlton and the AFL just ooze with integrity, don't they. Gil needs to make a statement - but of course he will have to run a poll first.

Can / does / will he do ruck relief?

Maybe this could spur the AFL into setting up an inquisition inquiry into Carlton's duty of care to their concussed players. (I know they won't, by the way, but it should).

I wonder if the Carlton doctors will allow that poor victim Rowe to play this week?

Whether or not Gus is suffering from concussive issues, he and the selectors need to decide where and what he is to do best. At the moment he is played on a HFF as a sort of default undecided spot. IF and when he regains full fitness where will he play? Will or should he play for Casey this weekend? But back to selections, Kent will surely add zip and pace to the forward line. Looking forward to seeing Smith - haven't seen him. Is he a genuine back up ruck?

I would be very very pleased, and thank the chaps for putting on a jolly good show.

1) other than Sandilands to whom else would you be referring ?

Pedersen ??

* vindictive bastards. Two can play that game. Don't expect Mr Nice Guy from any other clubs, you squealers. # risk of serious injury obviously doesn't include an elbow to the jaw of an opponent on the ground, or a deliberate knee into the mid spine

What is done is done. Could this allow Hogan in particular to "manage" his mystery injury? Come back refreshed in a couple of weeks. He does need to get some help however into how to cope with niggling - he WILL be a target, probably more so after this week. Is there anyone at the club such as a sports psychologist to help him learn how to handle pressure better?

Are people surprised that Carlton resort to lowlife tactics to distract from their own internal issues? IF what is described is true then the club doctor(s) is / are behaving completely unethically. See above - there should be a top level AFL enquiry should these concussed players take the ground this week. (As there should have been when the concussed Dangerfield played after the Trengove precedent decision.

Mods -- we desperately need a "dislike" button! Anyway, the random way the MRP works, if Clearance is ahead of <whomever the AFL decides should win> no doubt they can find some way to rub him out.

Can you add dementia to dementia? I can't remember if you can or not....what?