volders

The pick retains the value it was this year, doesn't matter where Geelong finish in the next 3 years, it just goes lower down the order because there are no priority picks. So in 2013 it would be equivalent to pick ~#9-11 depending on how the new teams slot into draft order etc. (it would have been #9 this year without GC and priorities), I don't know if the AFL has made decisions on where exactly it will be in 2013.

Aussie Gun's List on BigFooty is better IMO, I think Hodge is a tad high and possibly Selwood too but otherwise much better than Sheehan's. BTW I think Daisy is definitely top 15-20.

nope

<3 Col, really solid year, had some really good games, a couple of poor ones but was very happy in what I saw from him. Should be really hitting his straps next year with a full uninterrupted preseason (although this is probably true with almost everyone)

I saw the Carlton boys out at eve the Thursday after they lost their final and they were all very well behaved, Fev was most of the problem at that club IMO.

Confidence and injuries imo, after 2009 he was probably one of the top 5 rated from the 2007 draft, I think people are forgetting how good he was for a skinny 19 y.o in 2009. He has definitely been disappointing this season but perhaps we were expecting a little too much from him because he was so highly rated. He isn't your standard midfielder because of his body shape it will take him longer than most to grow into his role. Think Brendan Goddard who was considered a waste of a no.1 pick for many years, his fourth season was his breakthrough season where he started to silence his critics iirc.

Where is Hayes? Deserves to be in 18, let alone 22. He is the stiffest by far imo.

haha nice work, we better send Tom our addresses so he can send us a thank you card!

Needs ~100 votes by my calculations, if you have google chrome; ctrl+shift+n, paste link, vote, close window, ctrl+shift+n, etc. edit: hmm weird, dunno how chrome incognito works because I can't vote anymore. got him from 34% to 42% in 5 mins though

Isn't Jurrah eligible? Maybe behind Dennis-Lane because Sydney won, but probably ahead of Jordie this week. Still Jordie has a chance imo because Dennis-Lane has plaayed like 2(?) games this season and Jordie has been very consistent over the past 2 months and was solid again today.

He would of got it the last 2 weeks if other players didn't play very big games (Garlett 6 and he has had a good year), he's been in the top 3 the last 3 weeks including this one. Early word has Trengove getting the nod this week.

only took 11 posts to mention bartram this week

Blair for Collingwood had 28 disposals (13 contested), 6 marks, 4 tackles, 2 goals. also trengove for PA had a good game too.

lol

Leunberger is in pretty good form imo, perhaps career best. Clark is in bad form but he is still AA from last year. They have one of the better ruck combos going around and I think Jamar would struggle vs both of them solo.

I'm not the biggest bartram fan, but he probably was in our best 8 if not our best 5.

I'd probably take Hill and Hurley over NicNat at this point

except the last two games he's played predominately as a midfielder

Really, really likes Macdonald and McKenzie games, went really hard, lots of contested footy. Moloney was most disappointing for me, even though he got injured, as a senior player he should of been one of the players standing up when we were getting killed. Bate was poor, could almost be dropped but probably wont be. Rivers starting to improve a little, Garland still a little untidy, Batram played one of his worst games. Frawley, Scully and Watts are improving every game and will be guns. I thought Bruce's form had turned, was starting to get his game right again after last week, but was back to his sloppy self this week Davey and Sylvia were both very good, Bennell and Jurrah showed glimpses and did what needed to be done. Morton was disappointing, but Bail was solid imo. Can't believe PJ's game, wd sir, Jamar was a bit down on usual but didn't lost to the galloping lamppost.

he's actually running out of the backline and trying to take the game on rather than sitting with the ball for 10secs then kicking to a contest/out of bounds like bruce, garland, rivers, etc.

looks like another week of: 'off with bailey's head!'

Martin is the standout, but is illegible. I think Hannebery, Rockliff and Trengove are top 3 atm.

ya this was very nice, resulted in a goal (or shot for goal) iirc

A few days ago? Maybe a few weeks ago, he's been good to very good the past few games. Still not 100% convinced he'll be in our best 22 for a premiership tilt, however on recent form he will definitely be resigned.

yeah dunn was solid, fisher didn't have much influence, he kicked 2 (should of been 3, wtf at that) and had some solid possessions.