I don't agree. Is still in the game. Did pretty well at Adelaide and Geelong, record wise. Port has done well.
And unless there is a major character flaw don't you think someone who has been there stepped back, had time to refine and reflect, could come back in and be even better the next time?? His playing credentials are first rate.
I just think about if I went back to a previous role, work wise, I would be a lot better the second time around.
John Northey was better the second time around. SO were a number of coaches. Mick Malthouse for another.