Old Man Rivers

We have a midfield starting 4 the envy of most teams in the AFL with Big Max, Trac, Clarrie & the warrior Jack Viney however we seem to be getting dominated more often lately from sides like Brisbane, Sydney & Port Adelaide. How do we switch things up mid game to counter this dominance? Who should we add to the mix? Kozzie looks good when he makes cameo appearances & will be freed up even more shortly when McAdam makes his long awaited Demon Debut. Can Trent Rivers & Judd Mcvee transition into midfielder’s. What other options do we have to take back control & change things up in the midfield when we are getting dominated?

Demon Young Guns - Just incredible drafting over the last 4 years. Firstly Kozzie, Riv Dog, Bowey pre premiership & now the 2nd wave is just as impressive. Judd Silky McVee, JVR, Blake Howes & the smooth moving Caleb “The Duke” Windsor all making a serious contribution in 2024.

Just sensational vision from Jason Taylor. 

Do you think Koltyn Tholstrup will have the same instant impact when we unleash him later in the season? 🔴🔵🔴🔵

1. 88 Preliminary Final when we rolled The Blues at VFL Park. 

2. 2000 Preliminary Final when we rolled The Kangaroos at The G

3. 1990 Qualifying Final when we rolled The Eagles at VFL Park.

4. 2021 Anzac Eve v The Tigers 

5. 2004 (I think) Semi Final V The Crows (We Lost) The most amazing see - sawing final Iv’e ever been too. 40 points down at 1/4 time then something like 27 points up at 3/4 only to lose. Pretty sure Simon Goodwin was playing that night too. 

On 9/30/2022 at 9:33 PM, Macca said:

Gotta love these old threads ... filled with familiar names who are still posting now

16 years later and still going strong

I kicked off this thread some 16 years ago & am stoked it has come back to life in 2022. Some great modern day 5 minute wonders mentioned also. I have scarcely posted in the last decade but always hover in the background, follow the banter & love my Demonland daily fix. 🔴🔵🏆

I am watching from Port Villa in Vanuatu 🇻🇺 

🔴🔵🔴🔵🔴🔵

1 hour ago, David-Demon said:

Surely a player gets selected for the senior side based on his VFL performance first and foremost. I thought BBB was rather lazy last weekend in the VFL. As for Petty, he had a good limited timed game against Willie and in fact had 13 possessions. 

Watch this space. 

Disagree with your first sentence DD. In fact I’ll take it one step further & suggest it’s very old school yesterday thinking. Sure if a young player is attempting to break into the AFL starting 23 then it’s relevant but BBB ‘s circumstance was completely different. The dynamics & personal in the 2 competition’s are completely different. BBB was there to maintain match fitness only. He has plenty of credit’s & runs on the board to return ASAP. The bloke was a critical piece in delivering our Premiership & you want him running around at Casey, getting targeted off the ball by VFL thugs? Extraordinary thinking really. 

3 hours ago, David-Demon said:

Knowing Goody and the Team balance I think that there will be no changes for Round six against The Tigers.

BBB has not impressed me in his two outings so far in the VFL.

BBB smashed it in Round 1 & 2. Clunked everything in the air & kicked straight. You cant judge VFL form. Harrison Petty was awful 2 weeks ago in his return game & was sensational back in AFL team on Saturday. BBB return is a No Brainer. 

Clarrie, Salem, ANB & BBB all looking sensational. A few blokes look a bit dusty but thats what these games are all about. No Jake Lever or Bailey Fritsch so our structures are slightly out. Chandler showing a bit. Looking forward to seeing what The Weed can do in the 2nd half. 

2021 Jobs Done .. 

Looking forward to adding as The Dynasty unfolds 🔴🔵🔴🔵

I have seen us win 88 & 2000 Preliminary’s live. The joy leaving both those games was mind blowing & I can only imagine what winning that one extra week feels like?  On the downside I also witnessed us getting destroyed in both those seasons only one week later. I just want to see us win the GF. If that has to be on TV this year well those are the cards we have been dealt. That won’t take away the moment for me as there are no guarantees we get this shot again.  Just roll with it guys , if this comes together this will be an epic moment in all our lives!!!

8 minutes ago, Roger Mellie said:

Remember years ago (can't recall the opponents, but WCE sounds like a good fit) where he paid us 1 free kick for the game and our opponents 11 (or something like that). After that, he didn't umpire MFC games for a few years. I wish that was still the case.

I would assume that was close to the same differential last week with his decisions for & against. He was brutal on us. 

Under the Radar is exactly where we need to be leading into September. Then we Launch ? 

10 minutes ago, Clintosaurus said:

Disco Turner can play a bit.

This is guy has been super solid & winning multiple one on ones on debut. 
The kid can seriously play ….

27 minutes ago, Boots and all said:

I was only a young fella in 87. Does anyone know how we were placed in terms of flag favouritism during that year?

We got on a late roll in 1987. We were solid for the last 2 months that season but only just stumbled into the 8.... 2021 is completely different , we are ruthless & afraid of No team. Definitely got the Cats 2007 feel about it. 

11 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

My God, Brereton talks through his massive cloaca. Gives us no credit and basically is saying we only won because the Dogs were off and made uncharacteristic mistakes. Just maybe they made mistakes because of the pressure applied and the way we were set up. [censored]. 

Derm is still living off his 5 time premiership player days from 30 years ago & still sees the Dee’s as the easy beats of the competition in his mind & always will until we achieve the ultimate success. Like BT he’s stuck in a time warp. He couldn’t of been anymore dismissive of Melbourne’s season to date & refuses to accept we are a genuine chance in 2021. He’s just another smug media personality trying to remain relevant. We just need to keep the Lid on, remain humble & just keep turning up each week with the same relentless pressure & focus. The Dermie’s of the world have had there moment, ours is just around the corner....

Very tough read. 
I remember those 9 games in 91. 
He was explosive, kicked a couple of bags then did his knee & we never saw him again. 
Hope he finds peace @ some point. 

Such a fine line between Future Superstar & Dud. He got a few touches in the first 3 quarters. Then had a great breakout leading & marking final quarter but couldn’t finish his outstanding work. Had he kicked 3-4 like he should have we would all be having a different conversation. 
I reckon he will tear the competition apart sooner rather than later. 

4 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Wrote my round 1 team down on a post it note.  let me know your thoughts

Probably start Bertram on the ground ahead of Bennell & maybe Miller ahead of Bate. 
Apart from that looks good ?

Don’t look back in Anger ? ? 

31 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

We weren’t good enough OMR

Regardless of the opponents 

No dispute on that one. 
my point was 2018 has not been our only decent year in the last 50 years ?‍♂️

37 minutes ago, loges said:

To be honest, what work would it be that we'd be admiring? We've done nothing but have a moderately successful 2018 in the past 50 odd years.

Loges 20 odd years not 50

You disrespect the line ups we had from 87-94. 
Unlucky not to pinch a flag in that era.

98 & 2000 also had decent competitive sides on the park. Just ran into a once in a lifetime Bombers unit. 
Things might just turn around quickly when we least expect it. ?
 

12 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Is understood to be very close friends with Maynard and would love to play his footy with him.

Easy fix.  We target Maynard ?‍♂️

Sad news, like Hannibal Inc, I also had contact with Mark when he was distributing the Robbie Flower DVD years ago. We both worked in Bayswater at the time  & being a fellow Demonlander he was more than happy to deliver the copy to me. 

RIP MarkC 

I don’t know Mick Green @ all however I did have a brief random 3 minute meeting with him in Woolworths in Boronia about 12 months ago. From memory Brownlow Medal night 2018. We were both grabbing Munchies before the count & he struck up a chat about the Footy. He was quick to tell me who he was & we chatted about the Dee’s & The Giants. He came across as a super proud Dad & was very excited about Toby’s career. I hadn’t really thought about it much again until the last few days. 

I watched the replay on Sunday & thought the exact same thing. Even when Jones dropped his shoulder into him after the headbutt he was wiping his mouth of non existent blood as there was no contact anywhere near his mouth. It was purely for the umpires benefit. He can play but he is a deadset [censored] after that 4 quarter acting display.