Gorgoroth

I was a massive critic of his pre delisting and was mystified why we rookies him. Been proven wrong since but was right prior.

Tbh is leave the backs as is, I'd bring Salem in as a winger or half forward. Unless they want to put H back on the wing?

What's a play off?

Dawes is also smart enough to not take his man near Hogan. He does a lot of work that benefits the team. I don't dislike him like most, I think he brings a lot to the team, Pedo was in better form early before he got injured but he ain't the answer either.

Tbh, I've never rated him, he will play one good game then do nothing for four weeks.

I seriously hope we don't go anywhere near Yarran. Soooooooooooo over rated!

On Grimes he was put under the pump three times by the mid way of the 3rd quarter. One thing I have seen in this game is more shepherds and blocks than I have seen all year.

I'm loving this, but I'd like to keep a version with the normal commentators.

Ha ha, forgot that part...

Yeah I'd love to see Ox, Titus, Sheehan and Lyon do a press red for, but prob safer to wait a few years til we have a rough idea we are going to win that game.

I've said it before, PJ could be the best thing that this club has ever had.

Awesome, I'm taping this!

Harmes may get rested, I know he did well as the sun but if bring Salem in as the sub if fit. Prob only change I'd make. Grimes whilst his kicking was t great at times still defends really well. Michie deserves another game to show if he is up to it. Maybe Newton to return if he plays well.

Any link to the PJ interview? Or what station it was on?

After watching today I wish Moore had chosen us over the filth, he looks like he will be a bloody good footballer.

Thanks for the link. Was a good listen.

Behind Goldie as the best but he is catching fast. If he can stay on the field and get his fitness to allow him to run out a full game he could be as good as or better than the great whose number he wears.

Disagree on Dawes. I thought he was good today. Tysons disposal early was horrible and so was hi awareness but I thought the second half he got much better. Dunn was superb, thought Garlos was good too Cross killed Sidebottom after halftime, he had 21 to half tim then Cross went on him and he was hardly seen after that.

That does surprise me. I would have guessed 10-12 disposals at 70% I agree with you Ralph, I thought he was more involved than 6 possessions.

Yeah fair enough, prob should have gone with a few praises. Hogan seemed to want to make up for being beaten last time and really stamped himself on the game early which I thought was really impressive. Dawes I thought played quite well as the second ruck today, Brayshaw doesn't seem to be getting the ball as much but my god doe he choose the right option all the time. Bernie... Please get to 100 games and have lost of boys who choose us.

What was Michies disposals, I didn't see heaps of him, but when I did he seemed to do well.

Lol

A truth. I thought this was a discussion, if you want only positive comments open a thread called "roses only, our shite don't stink" I want our club to be ruthless, I'm enjoying the win, but reality is we did our best to stuff things up all game especially in the second.

Starting to be a little narky during games too, must be starting to believe. He will never be a crash bash player, but as long as he gives effort he will be a very good player.

On Foxtel doing a Collingwood call with Daicos, Shaw and Straunie, was great to listen to it once we were on top.