The Great Pretender

If you look at the teams on an individual basis they’re pretty evenly matched.

Who will dominate?

Petracca (in game #182) or Neale (in game #250)?

Love Steven May’s courage!

Can the Lions stop Max?

Will Melbourne kick straight for goal?

How will Brisbane cope without the loudspeakers playing their favourite songs when they kick a goal (I anticipate they won’t kick many anyway)?

Demons win because the Lions will simply suffer stage fright on the G.

Who do we death ride in 2024?

1 hour ago, Gawndy the Great said:

Pies will go 0-4 and will drop out of contention. 

Carlton and GWS Giants were seemingly out of contention well past the halfway mark last year and yet, both finished close to playing off in a grand final. Even at 0-4, I wouldn’t write the Pies off.

8 hours ago, Leopold Bloom said:

No Verrall ... is he set up to be mystery injury of the week?

Seriously, didn’t play for Casey at the weekend and didn’t train yesterday. Not on the injured list.

What’s the story?

We can all laugh but regrettably they have the silverware from 2023 and we don’t. 

After the election, the Tassie Devils will be cactus.

6. A. Bannan 
5. K. Hore 
4. O. Purcell 
3. R. Watt 
2. T. Hanks 
1. B Mackin

The remaining free agents - 

2023 AFL FREE AGENTS 

* Previously delisted

** Restricted free agent 

^ Previously a free agent

ADELAIDE (1)

Tom Doedee**

BRISBANE (3)

Nakia Cockatoo*
Rhys Mathieson*
Dayne Zorko

CARLTON (2)

David Cuningham
Sam Durdin*

COLLINGWOOD (1)

Cooper Murley*

ESSENDON (1)

Will Snelling*

FREMANTLE (1)

Joel Hamling^

GEELONG (2)

Tom Hawkins
Rhys Stanley

GOLD COAST (5)

Jed Anderson*
Levi Casboult*
Charlie Constable*
Sam Day 
Jake Stein*

GWS GIANTS (2)

Matthew Flynn
Lachlan Keeffe*

HAWTHORN (1)

Fergus Greene*

MELBOURNE (2)

James Jordon*
Jake Melksham

NORTH MELBOURNE (5)

Todd Goldstein
Daniel Howe*
Ben McKay**
Liam Shiels*
Kayne Turner*

PORT ADELAIDE (1)

Scott Lycett^

RICHMOND (1)

Bigoa Nyuon*

ST KILDA (5)

Tom Campbell* 
Jade Gresham**
Daniel Mckenzie
Liam Stocker*
Jimmy Webster

SYDNEY SWANS (0)

WEST COAST EAGLES (1)

Zane Trew*

WESTERN BULLDOGS (3)

Taylor Duryea^
Toby McLean
Roarke Smith*

As noted above, ZZ at 196 cm won't cut muster as an AFL ruckman so the question is what are his credential as a KPP?

Forward or back?

6 Hore

5 Hanks

4 Purcell

3 Lampard

2 Pearce

1 Heath 

A mate of mine who today is a very jubilant North fan is going to Casey today but isn’t confident. Tells me that by his reckoning, the Kangaroos have only 7 AFL listed players and Casey should win easily.

 I’m not so sure.

If Ben Brown’s injury woes continue I think the club definitely needs to have a conversation with him regarding retirement from the AFL. He could play next year with the Casey team or take on a coaching role. After all, aren’t we being constantly told that we need a forward coach who has played in the role, rather than a ruckman presiding over the forwards.

Christian Petracca said on AFL360 that he didn’t think his last shot at goal against Carlton was touched and Toby Greene agreed with him.

Interestingly, the vision shows Weitering arriving at the scene late and slapping the goalpost. I’m not sure if this was raised previously but I bring it up because there was an element of post slapping in the case of Keays’ disallowed goal for Adelaide, the sound of which is said to be a possible reason why the goal umpire might have believed the ball hit the post.

Anyway, both incidents are now water under the bridge. 

6. Jake Melksham 
5. Jake Lever 
4. Jack Viney 
3. Trent Rivers 
2. Angus Brayshaw 
1. Christian Petracca

Clarkson sure to go with youth.

Anyone have an idea when the teams are announced?

Why didn’t Gold Coast play like this against Fremantle?

James Harmes was the sub last night but only came on in the last quarter and had 16% time on ground. Given the minimal time on the ground, is he eligible to play today?

Chris Cavanagh in HERALD SUN Online -

“He played the first half entirely as an onballer, attending every centre bounce for which he was on the field.

However, close checking from Bulldogs opponents limited his ball-winning ability as he went into the main break with just five disposals to his name.“

Moved around in the second half. Spent some time forward and then half back in the last when he did a couple of nice things.

It seems that playing of half back is where the good young players get their start these days.

Match of the round next week has to be Freo v Hawks. The outcome will answer all the questions that we’re asking on this topic.

A big win tonight and a Collingwood loss tomorrow could see us on top of the ladder.

Question is whether we want to be there at this early stage of the season?

Melbourne has selected a squad of 26 for the Eagles game. Will all players travel to Perth or will a couple stay/return to Melbourne to play for Casey on Sunday? 

8 minutes ago, DemonDave said:

The main VFL graphic at the top of this post has us playing the Darebin Falcons..how can they get this so wrong?

The graphic is for the VFLW and not the VFL.

The Sydney vs Hawthorn game is reminiscent of Melbourne’s dark days. There’s a world of pain facing the Hawks over the next five years.

That’s just a hop, skip and a jump away from Mansfield where our boy Oliver Sestan celebrated some big goalkicking feats last year. I’m expecting a big session from him.