-
Posts
24,490 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
112
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Posts posted by Redleg
-
-
35 minutes ago, Rab D Nesbitt said:
If Dannyz thinks he's out the door then our club will be planning accordingly for his exit.
Has he said that?
- 1
-
15 hours ago, Abyssal said:
Jeff Gleeson KC AFL Tribunal Chair
FWIW
A brief browse of the internet shows
1. Senior counsel for Racing Victoria during the Cobalt positive saga.
Racing Victoria was widely criticised for it’s handling of the long running matter.2. Independent Commissioner for the ‘Melbourne Response’. A scheme set up by the Catholic archdiocese to compensate victims of sexual abuse.
The Melbourne Response was “criticised by the Royal Commission”Oh, and allegedly he is a Collingwood supporter.
Is he connected with Uni Blacks?
-
34 minutes ago, kev martin said:
I've noticed many tacklers show a duty of care and nurse the player to the turf.
Motorbike continues with aggression all the way through his tackle against Lever, and the AFL call him the "good guy".
If they are going to go with "good guy" adjudications, then they need stats for positive duty of care actions. These stats could reduce fines and occasionally suspensions. The effect would be that sporting actions may save them money.and so incentivise care to the opponent.
5 prior offences is not a good guy, it’s a recidivist.
Sparrow copped a week for a much softer sling. Obviously not a good guy.
I have never liked Gleeson’s findings and reasons, that change continuously.
- 4
-
21 minutes ago, adonski said:
He isn't a key forward
He would make our 23.
BBB probably gone end of season and Tom has gone back.
Only Jeffo to come, hopefully.
- 2
-
We are so blessed with quality key forwards, why would we want him?
That was sarcasm.
- 1
- 3
-
16 hours ago, picket fence said:
Will surprise many on here in time
I agree, ( I hope ).
- 1
-
2 minutes ago, forever demons said:
I dont like charlie have seen him do some off the ball stuff in his early years .Now the dislike grows as he gets a free pass .So AFL says ok kids do what you like your a good kid with no prior record take a free pass and I will meet your dad over at the pub a drink
But he had 3 priors, 2 for striking, just no suspensions.
- 1
-
4 hours ago, Lucifers Hero said:
Christian and Gleeson (who was the AFL advocate at the Tribunal prior to being made its chair) have a vested interest in seeing Collingwood's competitors for the premiership be weakened and imv their bias has been shown at various times. Port missing SPP for some key games. We missed Kozzie for a key game.
So how did Cameron get off a with a key game vs Cats this week ... maybe the AFL is concerned about some optics that @Ethan Tremblay didn't suggest in the post below.
Blind freddy can see the potential for conflict of interest of the MRO and Chairman and the AFL should fix it - at least rotate the Chairman to someone who has no interest in the accused's team nor who they play in the following weeks. Ditto the Tribunal panel.
Of course it won't!!
Except that Port play Pies and Butters out would have helped Pies.
-
Post on the Kozzie thread saying Cameron fined in 2017 for striking and 2020 for rough conduct and striking in 2021.
Tribunal said he had no prior suspensions. Didn't look at previous fines or incidents then.
3 previous incidents where he was found guilty and yet he is of such exceptional character, he is fined again, for medium impact which carries a suspension, when others would be suspended.
- 10
- 1
- 1
- 1
-
Was found guilty of medium impact, that is a suspension, unless you are a good bloke, who in Cameron’s case work's with Indigenous youth.
Robbo, Whately on 360 stunned, journos Jay Clark, Glen McFarlane and Ralphy on Midweek Tackle, also stunned and appeared actually angry.
We have one rule for some and another for others.
Can’t wait to hear Kingy.
Laura Kanes’ words of “all players are treated equally” are now quite hollow.
IMO the sooner the Tribunal Chairman and Christian are gone and the whole system is overhauled, the better.
Consistency simply does not exist in the AFL judiciary.
- 4
- 1
- 1
-
32 minutes ago, Young Angus said:
In our game Tmac just touched the ball as he was trying to pick it up and then it went out of bounds and they called deliberate...one of the most non-deliberate acts I think I've ever seen. How they can rule on those things makes the mind boggle.
We have seen players pick up the ball and run 5 steps, or drag their opponent 5 steps to the boundary, with no problem and other times, a player takes possession of the ball as he crosses the boundary and is pinged.
The one consistent thing in the AFL, is the lack of consistency.
- 3
-
2 hours ago, Jaded No More said:
Further proof that the AFL protects high profile players and Brownlow hopefuls
If this same action was done by a nobody, say I dunno Hunter, it would result in suspension. And has.
Kozzie doing the same action gets 3-4 without any question.
Hunter as mentioned got suspended for the same thing.
- 7
-
We are currently 2 short on our list without Gus and Smith, usual issue of injuries aside.
As they were senior players, not just backups, it is more significant.
- 4
-
I hope he gets a run at it and is left in the side.
He will improve and the experience of Anzac eve big crowd will be invaluable to him and a couple of other youngsters.
Kozzie back might add some opportunities too.
- 1
-
11 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:
So as we head into the bye
Clayton Oliver- finger - test
Marty Hore — thumb / 2 weeks
Shane McAdam — hamstring / 2 weeks
Charlie Spargo — Achilles / 3 weeksChristian Salem - hamstring - 4-5 weeks
Jake Bowey — shoulder / 5 weeks
Jake Melksham — knee / 10 - 11 weeks
Angus Brayshaw - medical retirementof the 44 on the list, 8 likely unavailable for the Tigers clash.
Don’t we add Smith to that list as being unavailable.
Our list is 2 down before injuries.
- 2
-
10 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:
Want to see Ricky in the Under 18s academy game v Coburg game. Love the see another exciting small forward added to the list.
The only hope of him getting to us is to not have a great year and be selected outside top 40.
- 1
-
37 minutes ago, Demon Dynasty said:
Nothing that a dose of 'Ports of Paradise' couldn't shake off!
Bless ye olde Palmtree Paddy
Can’t I just use Malibu and Diet Coke or Khalua on the rocks?
- 1
-
Lovely thursday evening we spent.
-
5 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:
Wow, you sure are hellbent on ditching Clarrie. This is the second thread tonight in which you’ve suggested we trade him. You say he’s a country mile away from the player “we know he can be” which begs the question: why would we trade him when we know what he can (and will again) be? He’s playing with the fingers of one hand strapped together ffs.
Anyone who suggests trading or demoting Clarry, who is playing injured, has to be joking or trolling.
Clarry is the best contested ball player I have ever seen, in well over 60 years of watching footy.
- 4
-
7 minutes ago, pitmaster said:
Brisbane had 3 games in 14 days.
Playing North atm isn't much of a game.
- 3
-
3 games in 13 days, injured players playing and a few good ones missing and the poorest of disposal and that is what you get.
- 4
-
5 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:
It all comes down to the midfield. We are getting smashed in clearances and contested possessions. That’s the game.
You can’t blame the forwardline when the midfield is not able to win the ball.And when we win it we give it back.
- 1
-
4 minutes ago, forever demons said:
what thread was it i will give it hell
It might have been the one started by that dummy Redleg.
- 3
- 1
-
I hope all Dee’s fans are realistic about Kolt in his first game and aren’t disappointed if he doesn’t have a great game.
On what we have seen he has the talent to make it, but may need time as most young players do.
Then again, he could turn it on.
- 7
Harrison Petty
in Melbourne Demons
Posted · Edited by Redleg
Well he has a great record with his info, so I will prepare myself for a Petty departure at seasons’ end.
Given BBB will probably retire, Smith is probably gone too and Jeffo isn’t up to it atm, we will have a desperate need for a couple of experienced key forwards.
A player like Lukosius who is rumoured to be available and a bigger bodied experienced key forward, would have to be targets for us.
I wanted Treacy included in the LJ deal, but it didn’t happen.
I think Turner could be a chance to play forward in the future, if we are desperate.
Verall is another who could play forward, as he has good hands.
I wonder if Fullarton could also be trained up to play a more permanent forward role. A bit more muscle could help him.
I am sure if we know Petty is leaving, we will be preparing for it. It will be an interesting watch.