-
Posts
142 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Posts posted by the pearl
-
-
6. Martin
5. Watts
4. Scully
3. Trengove
2. Frawley
1. Sylvia
-
2. Sylvia
-
I've heard this touted a bit.
What's it based on?
Watts, to me, seems a very confident young man.
Jack Watts' confidence is more to do with whether or not he is prepared to take significant risks when he gets the ball, and when he is trying to get the ball. He would rather try to do the 'safe' team things at this stage.
As a junior footballer, he was free flowing and attacking and really good. As a basketballer, he was amazing as a decision maker and an aggressive offensive player. He is not showing much of this type of confidence at this stage. He looks scared to make too many errors.
He may still look confident to you but there are many different levels to sporting confidence.
-
In the spirit of change, youth, vigour and genuine gutsy progress, let's go for the dynamo, Colin Sylvia, for captain next year. It would be perfect for the team, the club and for Sylvia.
-
6. Bruce
5. Bail
4. Rivers
3. Sylvia
2. McKenzie
0.5 Jamar
0.5 Frawley
Bartram tried hard - too many howlers!
-
6. Frawley
5. Bruce
4. MacDonald
3. Green
2. Scully
1. Jamar
-
Hardest to decide this season. Started with a short list of 18.
6. Sylvia
5. Frawley
4. Jamar
3. Bruce
2. Rivers
1. Garland
Backline players set everything up.
-
There will be no scores and no possessions for the whole game against Swans. The game will just consist of tackles - legal and illegal - over and over again. Each team will amass over 700 tackles for the game.
-
Bate - Casey, Casey, Casey
Watts - melts under spotlight
-
Based on Foxtel viewing.
6. Frawley
5. Rivers
4. Scully
3. PJ
2. MacDonald - even though I don't rate him
1. Sylvia - when it mattered
-
6. Green
5. Jamar
4. Sylvia
3. Trengove
2. Garland
1. Bruce
-
One of the all time classic comments from Choco about stepping down. Said he was suffering from illness and fatigue - his supporters were sick and tired of him!! Ha
-
Bartram - has exhausted welcome
Bate - had no influence
Bennell - rarely gave whimper
Bruce - excellent first half
Davey - rarely showed interest
Dunn - lively and involved
Frawley - kept at task
Garland - was rarely noticed
Green - still all class
Grimes - injured and missed
Jamar - had little influence
Jetta - did almost nothing
Jones - taught a lesson
MacDonald - tough but slow
Moloney - displays diminishing zest
Rivers - milestone to forget
Scully - was rarely noticed
Trengove - a rare winner
Watts - our best player
McKenzie - overwhelmed by class
Spencer - an underwhelming display
Try these:
Davey - can hit targets
Watts - craps himself sometimes
Moloney - couldn't get free
Jetta - what's he thinking?
-
6. Trengove
5. McKenzie
4. Green
3. Dunn
2. Watts
1. Frawley
Can't say I agree with people giving votes to Davey (especially 5/6 votes wtf?) only had 14, and Jones had a field day. Struggle to see how Green wasn't in our best 6 either.
In Davey's case don't be misled by stats. Look at the quality of his possessions and the one percenters.
If you need to rely on statistics, then you're not watching the game.
-
Who's simplifying the clanger? We find the most complex ways of constructing clangers.
-
The absolute clanger is an important stat in today's football - especially against a team of predators like St Kilda. By halving our clangers and handballs to players, compelling them to commit a turnover, (because there is nothing else they can do) we will win these games. There might be quite a few of these players who will never plays finals football with us. There could be a few, whom, when surrounded by quality, might cut it as top AFL players. There are a few who will develop into AFL A graders and I don't know who they're going to be yet - but doesn't Trengove look good!
Every haphazard handball that puts one of our stationary players under pressure is a howler at the moment.
What must the players think when they watch the clips and video through the week? Do they compare their efforts with St Kilda's uncontested marks and clean ball handling?
Does this drive them towards improving their skills?
Do any of them ever consider that they're not good enough at this stage?
Or is this their problem? Do they not believe in their ability strongly enough?
Were they resigned to the idea that they were going to lose too early in the last quarter?
There are up there with persistence and physical effort for the most part of most games.
-
6. Jordie McKenzie
5. Aaron Davey
4. Jack Trengove
3. Lynden Dunn
2. Brad Green
1. ... ah ... ah ..Frawley maybe!
-
6. Davey - stunning performance. Near enough the best player in the AFL.
5. Jamar - commitment personified.
4. Moloney - never keep him down. Great kicking penetration.
3. Warnock
2. Scully
1. Jones - love his desire and tenacity.
-
6. Gysberts
5. Green
4. James McDonald
3. Davey
2. Sylvia
1. Jones ( yeah .. I know .. I was wrong )
-
Not the guy who wouldnt buy a membership???? B)
You have to love those people who make such a silly stand as if its going to have an impact. An ultimate lose-lose outcome.
Not in the eyes of the coaches. A player born with a great leap and no 2nd efforts
Grossly oversimplified portrait of Robbo. Robbo put in second efforts as intensely as any player of his time. The problem was that the efforts weren't good enough. He was too easily defended by strong defenders like Scarlett, Glass etc. He had physical limitations and skill limitations but did his best.Every so often, he lifted his team with a mark using the "great leap" you remember him for.
-
Leave Bennell alone! he was one of our better players today
Yeah! He just gets little bit frightened.
-
What about "the brotherhood of satan" OR "the magenta petals"!!
-
I was there. I saw it close up. Bruce looked like he had concrete gumboots on when it counted. Stats mean naff if you stuff it up regularly. Loose man in defence, no opponent, was the best from him today and enabled him to run off a couple of times. Other than that, if he's not at Casey next week we're treading water with little imagination when it comes to team selection.
Absolute rubbish
-
Yes it is.
And it is ridiculous indeed.
YM is taking a break for a while.
On his break, YM has morphed into TIG.
Bruce was servicable and at times, clever and reliable.
My 3 word player analysis V Richmond
in Melbourne Demons
Posted
Green turned down a couple of shots he should have taken! The one in the last quarter where he gave it off to Jones was a certain goal if he'd had a shot. It's never a certainty if you give the ball off to Jones.