nosoupforme

So JW is a nice guy? GOOD CALL.....but he hasn't finished last. Work that one out.

Then don"t if you are not sure.......... go find the papers on those days look it up learn before you have your big say.

OK now Pederson is good but will he be a regular in Goodwins team if he has a lean period or plays just fair? Garlett played just fair when he had to be better in some of his games even though he had some personal issues.Tyson can lift and he has too and Hogan lets hope that his head is clear. You picked the 15 that you think in your opinion are better than JW l am sure he would then fit in your 22 . I don't think that you are a critic of JW but if he leaves, I wonder if you would be happy when he does play well for someone else? Howerver he had a very good season or 2 under Roos, he didn't drop him when he had a lean period JW asked to be dropped and only for that one match and came back better. ROOS didn't degrade him like NEELD and GOODWIN had done.

Your opinion on JW is hard. Name all the Melbourne players l mean all that are better prospects than JW. SEE AGRRES WITH YOU.

I see what you mean however he did have his mind on the training track and for some reason at times l felt he was lairising. We need him and has plenty to give.

Again you make alot of sense however l think that maybe Goodwin has lost the plot. l think Watts knows why.

I like you to.

You are welcomed You L ittle ???????????? please yourself

SORRY but you are dreaming hard like a Snow white. Ask Goodwin what he thinks??????????

Pray that he decides to stay instead.

Richmond won the flag? SH T happens.

Collingwood next suburb down jumped on the bandwagon . All ferals Can't stanzya George.....

Well done with the ratings. the only one that l rate higher is Wagner late second round. i expect he will improve. You know your DEMON STUFF.

Congratulation Richmond on winning the Premiership cup. SH T HAPPENS

NEELD CRUCIFIED WATTS AND GOODWIN HASN'T HELPED HIS CASE BY not picking him in the practice games at the start of the season . However Goodwin went one better and dropped him for poor form when there were worse players than Watts. now he doesn't want him????????????????? Could not help but think that this drama is not going to help our team morale. hmmmmmmm.

If you wait one more year we can l presume get Gaff for much less,a high 2nd round pick l think. iTS WORTH THE WAIT.

CONGRATS TO JT CHAMPION PERSON. ALWAYS WITH A SMILE. Dustin to miss holding the Premiership cup.

Maybe l misread it. However the day comes that Jack does leave, the Watts critics will regret it and the simple minded ones that bag him constantly won't know what to do with themselves.

Can't help but read your comments about Jack Watts how overrated you think he is ???????????? HMMMMMM Obviously you don't go to games or maybe you listen to the Watts critics. Grumpy o m.

Watts is old news now , he has been on on the trade table since the early days at Melbourne. More since Neeld almost stuffed his career. Get over it he won't leave . You just have to put up with it.

Hey Lampers I see your point. Lets wait after the Finals to see if Lever crosses the Border. Its a nice romance. l would like to see Frosty given a fair go and be happy to watch him tuck the ball under his arm and run the opposition ragged and bust the lines. I believe he is hard done. Watching with anticipation to see Lever play at the G this Saturday and to find out his worth. Lets see if his worth the first two round picks that many say but for me Lever is overvalued. I hope he proves me wrong.

Hey Lampers, What is it with Watts that you think could be one of the trades for Lever ? If we get Lever and he is not over the line in any stretch of imagination, it will be for a first round and a pick maybe a third round. don't listen to all the other cats out there .

Leigh Mathews a Melbourne Supporter before joining Hawthorn,.