CASEY: PF vs Brisbane

[Bystander 859]

Forget double header. It's at Casey, unless there is a change of heart...which I very much doubt

[Demonland 64,431]

[MadAsHell 4,088]

Optimistic of a good win on Saturday. We're tough to beat out at Casey Fields at the best of times and by my counting we could have up to 19 AFL listed players run out against the Lions. Throw in Jimmy Munro, Mitch White and Matt Buntine for support and we should have our 3rd Grand Final appearance in the VFL in seven years.

[poita 3,573]

Three Queensland teams in the preliminary final - can someone remind what the V in VFL stands for again?

The biggest threat to Casey winning is Goodwin having a change of heart at the selection table and putting Dunstan and a couple of other Casey guns in the Melbourne side.

[Jaded No More 57,685]

My stupid niece is having a birthday party during this game. What a selfish 4 year old! 

 

[In Harmes Way 7,477]

19 minutes ago, poita said:

Three Queensland teams in the preliminary final - can someone remind what the V in VFL stands for again?

Valid

/sarcasm

Edited September 5, 2022 by In Harmes Way

[Bystander 859]

Forecast for Saturday...cold and rain. Rather different to last encounter against this mob.

[layzie 28,523]

2 hours ago, Jaded No More said:

My stupid niece is having a birthday party during this game. What a selfish 4 year old! 

 

I'm honestly lucky to watch any game other than the Dees on a given weekend at the moment. Responsibilities galore. 

[WERRIDEE 5,198]

Massive game on Saturday the 10th of September at Casey at 1:10 pm. Casey has just had the bye after beating Sydney by 47 points. Brisbane are also in the PF after beating Carlton by 12 points last week. The winner will play the winner of the Southport v Gold Coast game.

Possible team

B: D.Smith, Turner, Rosman

HB: Bowey, Tomlinson, Rivers

C: Howes, Dunstan, Baker

HF: Laurie, van Rooyen, Joel.Smith

F: Bedford, M.Brown, Chandler

FOLL: Weideman, White, Munro

IC: Buntine, McVee, Woewodin, Moniz-Wakefield, Valentine

 

I think Rivers will make way for McDonald in the senior team.

Edited September 6, 2022 by WERRIDEE

[Bystander 859]

I stand to be corrected, but I'm not sure bowey is eligible to play. He has played too many AFL games , more than 12?

I managed to find the rule, 20, but it is extremely difficult to interpret. Written by a very big committee?

[poita 3,573]

2 hours ago, Bystander said:

I stand to be corrected, but I'm not sure bowey is eligible to play. He has played too many AFL games , more than 12?

I managed to find the rule, 20, but it is extremely difficult to interpret. Written by a very big committee?

I don't believe these restrictions apply whilst the AFL team is still playing. If the AFL side loses this week, Bowey wouldn't be eligible to play in the VFL Grand Final.

[Bystander 859]

It is Rule 20, see subrule b and g.

Really hard to read and I get paid to read stuff and understand it.

What makes it hard is that most of the subrules start off by saying in effect "despite the other rules..." but you end up going in circles.

[MadAsHell 4,088]

@poita is right. While our AFL team remains alive, all players are eligible for VFL finals. So a win over the Lions on Friday Night in the AFL ensures we have a full list to choose from for the VFL Grand Final should we make it.

[Demonland 64,431]

[Bystander 859]

Yes, that is what subrule (e) says, but it is followed by (g) which says despite other rules maximum 12 games. It also says b applies which provides that if a player has played a game in the ones after 1 July, he has to have played 6 VFL games to be eligible.

What complicates matters is that while 20.g is expressed to be despite the other rules, so is 20.e.

Good fodder for the High Court now that appeals to Privy Council are abolished.

But, maybe I'm wrong.

[layzie 28,523]

Bit rough on Bowey. 

[MadAsHell 4,088]

1 hour ago, Bystander said:

Yes, that is what subrule (e) says, but it is followed by (g) which says despite other rules maximum 12 games. It also says b applies which provides that if a player has played a game in the ones after 1 July, he has to have played 6 VFL games to be eligible.

What complicates matters is that while 20.g is expressed to be despite the other rules, so is 20.e.

Good fodder for the High Court now that appeals to Privy Council are abolished.

But, maybe I'm wrong.

Don't overthink it. Cyril Rioli played 1 game for Box Hill in 2014 which was the Grand Final despite playing exclusively for Hawthorn when fit earlier in the year. Why could he do that?? Because Hawthorn were still alive in the AFL.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-09-21/footscray-beats-box-hill-to-win-vfl-grand-final/5758992

[Jaded No More 57,685]

30 minutes ago, MadAsHell said:

Don't overthink it. Cyril Rioli played 1 game for Box Hill in 2014 which was the Grand Final despite playing exclusively for Hawthorn when fit earlier in the year. Why could he do that?? Because Hawthorn were still alive in the AFL.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-09-21/footscray-beats-box-hill-to-win-vfl-grand-final/5758992

Maybe Clarry and May can play a double header. Can't see Casey losing then 🤣

[640MD 2,749]

Peanuts.  Peanuts,  shilling a bag. Peanuts 

every other vfl ground. And the Vafa Preston grounds port Melb and Prahran if I remember

Sandringham and Dandenong too

[dl4e 5,581]

3 hours ago, 640MD said:

Peanuts.  Peanuts,  shilling a bag. Peanuts 

every other vfl ground. And the Vafa Preston grounds port Melb and Prahran if I remember

Sandringham and Dandenong too

Used to always enjoy a noon pie they sold on the wing at Prahran.

[poita 3,573]

I understand that entry to the preliminary final is free. I assume no need to book tickets, just rock up at the ground?

[Bystander 859]

No booking required last game

[Bystander 859]

Or Saturday.

[WERRIDEE 5,198]

Due to being no change in the seniors I have to put McDonald in the side.

 

B: D.Smith, Turner, Rosman

HB: Bowey, Tomlinson, Baker

C: Howes, Dunstan, Woewodin

HF: Chandler, van Rooyen, Joel.Smith

F: Bedford, McDonald, M.Brown

FOLL: Weideman, White, Laurie

IC: Buntine, Munro, McVee, Moniz-Wakefield, Valentine

[KC from Casey 6,484]

CASEY DEMONS

B: D.Turner 42 A.Tomlinson 20 J.McVee 41
HB: M.Buntine 71 C.Ellison 79 J.Bowey 17
C: B.Howes 22 L.Dunstan 27 O.Baker 33
HF: R.Steele 54 M.Brown 38 K.Chandler 37
F: T.McDonald 25 J.Van Rooyen 21 T.Bedford 12
Foll: S.Weideman 26 M.White 52 J.Munro 47
I/C: G.Grey 68  A.Moniz-Wakefield 29 F.Rosman 19 D.Smith 34 R.Valentine 65 
Emerg: R.Baldi 56 J.Bell 73 B.Milford 74 A.Quigley 57

In: J.Bowey J.McVee A.Moniz-Wakefield R.Steele
 


Out: B.Laurie A.Quigley D.Smith T.Woewodin