AFLW: Intraclub and Practice Match

[Dees_In_October 3,346]

A successful intraclub went down at Casey on Saturday. Best of all, no injuries reported.

https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/1039515/a-real-genuine-hit-out-in-aflw-intra-club-match

Looks like a few ring-ins were involved to make up numbers

Scott clinging to her contested marking crown

 

[Dees_In_October 3,346]

A practice match is planned against Collingwood this coming Saturday.

Not sure of the venue, but if I had to guess, I'd say Olympic Park rather than Casey.

[Dees_In_October 3,346]

On 12/12/2021 at 10:34 PM, Dees_In_October said:

A practice match is planned against Collingwood this coming Saturday.

Not sure of the venue, but if I had to guess, I'd say Olympic Park rather than Casey.

Of course, as it turns out, it's at Casey.

10AM Saturday 18th of December. Teams to be announced on Thursday.

Each club will play one practice match, so this is it!

[Meggs 569]

Meggs unfortunately can’t make it.  Is anyone planning on attending and reporting?

[Dees_In_October 3,346]

2 hours ago, Meggs said:

Meggs unfortunately can’t make it.  Is anyone planning on attending and reporting?

I'm a maybe at this stage! It's definitely open to the public.

Here's the team for Saturday:https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/1041173/team-locked-in-for-official-practice-match

It's a 28-player side, of a 30-player list, so it's easier to say who ISN'T playing:

Purcell (still in ACL recovery) and Simmons (yet to debut).

As such, five of the six recruits will take part: Georgia Campbell, Tayla Harris, Eliza West, Tahlia Gillard and Ali Brown.

[FarNorthernD 5,839]

You there @Dees_In_October.? Any/all reports are always appreciated 

[Meggs 569]

Q1. Dees 0 Pies 15

Q2. Dees 16 Pies 15

Q3. Dees 17 Pies 22

Q4. Dees 41 Pies 22

A practice match win.  Must have been windy at Casey Fields.  Hopefully someone can share news on who played well etc

[Whispering_Jack 27,935]

Would have been a typical windy shocker out there at Casey. I would take it the game finished before the change came and turned the wind into a cooler southerly which happened where I am at just after noon.

[Pinball Wizard 272]

[Dees_In_October 3,346]

I made it! As I tossed up whether I should take the journey, one thing proved the motivator: to see Tayla Harris in the red and blue again for the first time in a long while (more on that later).

I arrived mid-way through first- it always takes longer than you think - after skirting the well-attended Covid testing queue and managing to snare a good parking spot, a Casey rarity. By my estimate, the crowd was about 100 strong, mostly Demons. Of course, it was windy. And of course, there was more bizarre weather coming. Classic Casey.

Q1

Fairly standard-looking line-up in the first (Paxman an obvious exception). First notable play after my arrival was a strong mark to Harris (wearing #4) in front of me on the wing. Also standing out was the rookie (and Casey B&F) West, who was very involved in the clinches, with second and third efforts. The Pies were kicking with the intense wind advantage, but our defence held up quite well under the onslaught, keeping the Pies to two goals when it could easily have been more since they had it camped down there. Not surprisingly, there was great difficulty transitioning to fwd 50, while the midfield struggled to get first use.

Lightning strikes nearby late in the first didn’t stop the game immediately, but quarter time was lengthened by about 10 mins. Naturally, the delay saw the return of blue skies and sunshine.

Melb 0.0.0 to Cwood 2.3.15

 

Q2

Kicking with the wind in the second, the Demons had better bounce off half back through Sherriff and Tarrant, and more midfield control. Goldie with a slightly nervous running bounce was enjoyable - calling to mind a practice match before her debut year in which she forgot to bounce at all while showing her now trademark dash. Just love how she takes it on. A ruck mix-up saw Parry nearly get a goal unopposed out of the ruck, while Daisy's forward pressure led the way.

The Dees peppered the scoreboard, with points to Daisy, Harris, Bannan (an impressive attempted long bomb) and West (I'm fairly certain, squinting from the other end) and two goals to Hore in her typical out-the-back or round-the-corner fashion. Zanker became more prominent, pushing the ball forward and distributing well by hands. A couple more strong takes to Harris and Birch were notable.

Melb 2.4.16 to Cwood 2.3.15

 

Q3

A stalemate of a quarter, with Collingwood failing to capitalise on the wind. The Dees tried to be smart going forward by short kicks edging closer. Our best chance for a major fell apart after a good set up by Scott to Daisy about 30m out on an angle, who then hit up Scott closer in, who took it a step too far trying to centre to 10m out. The idea was right though and showed the team's comfort with the conditions and ability to use different gears as required.

Meanwhile, Harris cleaned up Scott as they both crashed a pack early in the quarter, both played on. Harris was later reported for a sling tackle on Bonnici (I think), the latter commiserating with Harris while they waited for the umpire to re-start play. A good sign was that she was equally as hard but with better technique in her next involvement. Livingstone then got Harris high and apologised, so it was good sports all round despite the supposed “feud” between those two. Collingwood got a late goal after a quick transition forward from a ruck free kick, contrary to Daisy's clear instruction to "Lock it in!" in the last few minutes, which was disappointing. Interestingly, Parry had some time in the ruck.

Score: Melb 2.5.17 to Cwood 3.4.22 

 

Q4

Caris, Petrevski, Magee joined the game, with both Pearces sitting out the last. My quest to see if every player was used resulted in me noting Gillard (backline) and Campbell (forward) also on the field, and working out the player I'd been mis-seeing as Lampard was actually Ali Brown, and likely both had been out there, perhaps all along...

Fitzsimon - who played 1, possibly 2 games early last season - followed up a great tackle with a good kick to Harris as the target, which resulted in a goal to Hore out the back. That seemed to kick-start the Dees, and they were in control from there. Great link-up play in the midfield, including a nice centring kick by Zanker, led to another classic snap by Hore. Zanker again upped the ante after going missing a bit in the 3rd. Birch with more strong marks, Colvin mopping up some unconvincing forays by the Pies (though she needs to tidy up her kicking!). Harris another great mark but shot offline. A good tackle by first father-daughter Campbell, appropriately in the #1, set up a nice goal to West. Hanks piled on another one out the back, the Pies' pressure wilting and the Dees running out the game well.

Score: Melb 6.5.41 to Cwood 3.4.22

 

Unsighted: Paxman. Resting? Injured? Really wanted to give Harris her #4 jumper? I have no clues.

Considering they put on the "B-team" (no disrespect!) in the last with the wind to carry them home, a good result and a chance to see our depth in action.

Really happy with Harris, everything you'd want in terms of contest, only a goal would have capped it off. Birch's game was impressive as well. In the first, she dropped a mark, and I thought at the time, "Would really love her to take more of those with conviction". Cue her clunking pretty much everything from then on!

Always interested in the development of the Irish players. Goldie was her usual see ball, get ball, side-stepping self, which lead to some great defensive stops and rebounds, though she got caught a few times - par for the course for her style. Magee barely got near it due to coming on in the last and rarely seeing the ball enter the backline, which was a shame as match practice is crucial for her.

Was good to see Caris get a go and she looks a serviceable back-up ruck.

All in all, it was a pretty even performance. The gap between the stars of the team and the rest narrow every year, which is a pleasure to witness. As far as I could tell, Collingwood's key players were all involved, but I'm not across their list enough to really say if they were at full strength or might have been trying stuff positionally/strategically. Still, in terms of a practice game, I figure there are three things you want:

1. No injuries - TICK (in the sense that no one was stretchered off or obviously injured)

2. A close-enough standard to a real game - TICK

3. Not a demoralising loss that will throw out preparations - TICK

 

Bring on Round 1!

[BDA 19,992]

32 minutes ago, Dees_In_October said:

I made it! As I tossed up whether I should take the journey, one thing proved the motivator: to see Tayla Harris in the red and blue again for the first time in a long while (more on that later).

I arrived mid-way through first- it always takes longer than you think - after skirting the well-attended Covid testing queue and managing to snare a good parking spot, a Casey rarity. By my estimate, the crowd was about 100 strong, mostly Demons. Of course, it was windy. And of course, there was more bizarre weather coming. Classic Casey.

Q1

Fairly standard-looking line-up in the first (Paxman an obvious exception). First notable play after my arrival was a strong mark to Harris (wearing #4) in front of me on the wing. Also standing out was the rookie (and Casey B&F) West, who was very involved in the clinches, with second and third efforts. The Pies were kicking with the intense wind advantage, but our defence held up quite well under the onslaught, keeping the Pies to two goals when it could easily have been more since they had it camped down there. Not surprisingly, there was great difficulty transitioning to fwd 50, while the midfield struggled to get first use.

Lightning strikes nearby late in the first didn’t stop the game immediately, but quarter time was lengthened by about 10 mins. Naturally, the delay saw the return of blue skies and sunshine.

Melb 0.0.0 to Cwood 2.3.15

 

Q2

Kicking with the wind in the second, the Demons had better bounce off half back through Sherriff and Tarrant, and more midfield control. Goldie with a slightly nervous running bounce was enjoyable - calling to mind a practice match before her debut year in which she forgot to bounce at all while showing her now trademark dash. Just love how she takes it on. A ruck mix-up saw Parry nearly get a goal unopposed out of the ruck, while Daisy's forward pressure led the way.

The Dees peppered the scoreboard, with points to Daisy, Harris, Bannan (an impressive attempted long bomb) and West (I'm fairly certain, squinting from the other end) and two goals to Hore in her typical out-the-back or round-the-corner fashion. Zanker became more prominent, pushing the ball forward and distributing well by hands. A couple more strong takes to Harris and Birch were notable.

Melb 2.4.16 to Cwood 2.3.15

 

Q3

A stalemate of a quarter, with Collingwood failing to capitalise on the wind. The Dees tried to be smart going forward by short kicks edging closer. Our best chance for a major fell apart after a good set up by Scott to Daisy about 30m out on an angle, who then hit up Scott closer in, who took it a step too far trying to centre to 10m out. The idea was right though and showed the team's comfort with the conditions and ability to use different gears as required.

Meanwhile, Harris cleaned up Scott as they both crashed a pack early in the quarter, both played on. Harris was later reported for a sling tackle on Bonnici (I think), the latter commiserating with Harris while they waited for the umpire to re-start play. A good sign was that she was equally as hard but with better technique in her next involvement. Livingstone then got Harris high and apologised, so it was good sports all round despite the supposed “feud” between those two. Collingwood got a late goal after a quick transition forward from a ruck free kick, contrary to Daisy's clear instruction to "Lock it in!" in the last few minutes, which was disappointing. Interestingly, Parry had some time in the ruck.

Score: Melb 2.5.17 to Cwood 3.4.22 

 

Q4

Caris, Petrevski, Magee joined the game, with both Pearces sitting out the last. My quest to see if every player was used resulted in me noting Gillard (backline) and Campbell (forward) also on the field, and working out the player I'd been mis-seeing as Lampard was actually Ali Brown, and likely both had been out there, perhaps all along...

Fitzsimon - who played 1, possibly 2 games early last season - followed up a great tackle with a good kick to Harris as the target, which resulted in a goal to Hore out the back. That seemed to kick-start the Dees, and they were in control from there. Great link-up play in the midfield, including a nice centring kick by Zanker, led to another classic snap by Hore. Zanker again upped the ante after going missing a bit in the 3rd. Birch with more strong marks, Colvin mopping up some unconvincing forays by the Pies (though she needs to tidy up her kicking!). Harris another great mark but shot offline. A good tackle by first father-daughter Campbell, appropriately in the #1, set up a nice goal to West. Hanks piled on another one out the back, the Pies' pressure wilting and the Dees running out the game well.

Score: Melb 6.5.41 to Cwood 3.4.22

 

Unsighted: Paxman. Resting? Injured? Really wanted to give Harris her #4 jumper? I have no clues.

Considering they put on the "B-team" (no disrespect!) in the last with the wind to carry them home, a good result and a chance to see our depth in action.

Really happy with Harris, everything you'd want in terms of contest, only a goal would have capped it off. Birch's game was impressive as well. In the first, she dropped a mark, and I thought at the time, "Would really love her to take more of those with conviction". Cue her clunking pretty much everything from then on!

Always interested in the development of the Irish players. Goldie was her usual see ball, get ball, side-stepping self, which lead to some great defensive stops and rebounds, though she got caught a few times - par for the course for her style. Magee barely got near it due to coming on in the last and rarely seeing the ball enter the backline, which was a shame as match practice is crucial for her.

Was good to see Caris get a go and she looks a serviceable back-up ruck.

All in all, it was a pretty even performance. The gap between the stars of the team and the rest narrow every year, which is a pleasure to witness. As far as I could tell, Collingwood's key players were all involved, but I'm not across their list enough to really say if they were at full strength or might have been trying stuff positionally/strategically. Still, in terms of a practice game, I figure there are three things you want:

1. No injuries - TICK (in the sense that no one was stretchered off or obviously injured)

2. A close-enough standard to a real game - TICK

3. Not a demoralising loss that will throw out preparations - TICK

 

Bring on Round 1!

Great report DIO. Thanks

[Roger Mellie 3,485]

Thanks DIO,

Great report! We could be in for an exciting season.

So Parry replaces Zanker as the back-up ruck? I assume Caris is that very tall developing ruck?

Cheers,

[dworship 3,342]

Thanks DIO, how were the Midfielders particularly Hanks and Mithen?

[Dees_In_October 3,346]

12 hours ago, Roger Mellie said:

Thanks DIO,

Great report! We could be in for an exciting season.

So Parry replaces Zanker as the back-up ruck? I assume Caris is that very tall developing ruck?

Cheers,

Yep I'd say so, though it might have just been an experiment for Plan B scenarios. I can see them both chipping in depending on the opposition. And, yes, Caris is just as you describe. I thought she showed good presence and held her own. If we were to lose L.Pearce, I'd expect them to play her.

Fun fact I heard on a podcast called "Footy, Actually", much recommended for AFLW analysis. Top two tallest in the league are at the Dees: Caris and Gillard both at 190cm.

11 hours ago, dworship said:

Thanks DIO, how were the Midfielders particularly Hanks and Mithen?

Midfield struggled a bit to get their hands on it in the first, but came good after that. Hanks and Mithen were their usual selves. I felt Hanks was a little rusty, but the longer the game went on, the more she got into it and by the last she was everywhere. Mithen - you know what you get with her and that was her game on Saturday - tackling pressure, lots of setting up teammates by hand. Would love her to really nail her disposal by foot and even hit the scoreboard a bit.

Probably the notable thing in the midfield was how they went without Paxy. She's so dominant and such a fixture, it's actually hard to remember a game where she hasn't had a big say. But it wasn't the gaping hole it would have been a few years back, so that was interesting (obviously would prefer her out there!).