Jump to content

  • Demonland Interviews

FarNorthernD

AFLW: Rnd 7 V W Bulldogs @ Whitten Oval

Recommended Posts

22 hours ago, Perago Validus said:

Here's the deal from my view guys. We've missed a GOLDEN opportunity to be something in a league that WILL grow in the coming years and will only become bigger than we could imagine. Next year it'll grow to 8 the year after 10, and it'll jut keep growing. We've had the best squad the last two years and have missed narrowly each time, due not to lack of talent but our coaches instruction RE conversion and forward 50 entries. I really hope Stinear gets the boot and we can get a coach next year minus unfortunately Mithen, Cranston, Hoare and others who will take us to the flag! Those lost playes WILL be Stinear's legacy. 

Where are Mithen and Cranston going?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Geelong

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As expansion comes we'll be diluted. 

We just missed the best opportunity to snag a cup and establish our real bone fide as a power club.

Ive seen under 16's playva cleverer style of footy.

I don't think the game coaching was at all where it needed to be.

Wasted opportunity. 

Back to drawing board Dees. Have a good and proper think.

Next year much harder.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 18/03/2018 at 12:24 PM, McQueen said:

This top two teams playing off is going to fail miserably with 10 or more teams.

 

Needs to be top 4 play a final to decide who makes the GF. Otherwise you end up with percentage kicking people from a GF which doesn’t sit right with me co spidering the different conditions the teams all play in. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Katie Brennan has not only lost her appeal against the one match suspension the Tribunal has made it two weeks! 

Don't from which rule book they pulled that one from!  iirc, an AFL player can now appeal and pay $10,000 but there is no risk of a higher penalty if appeal fails.   Different rules for AFLW?

In this case the MRP penalty for the 'rough conduct'(sling tackle) was a reprimand.  But because this was her second reprimand of the season it automatically results in a week off.  This seems a dumb rule as 'rough conduct' can be anything.

I think a week off for a sling tackle is fair but the rules as applied seem bizarre.

I feel for Katie.  There were far worse things in that game that didn't even get a free kick yet she misses the GF.  

I would be shattered if that was our captain, Daisy. 

  • Sad 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to Sam Edmund, the club wants our women's team to do a lap of honour before our round 1 game. The girls aren't keen apparently, as they want to save it for when they actually achieve something.

Surely this won't help the 'Melbourne getting ahead of themselves' narrative

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
32 minutes ago, Mickey said:

According to Sam Edmund, the club wants our women's team to do a lap of honour before our round 1 game. The girls aren't keen apparently, as they want to save it for when they actually achieve something.

Surely this won't help the 'Melbourne getting ahead of themselves' narrative

Why?  It beggars belief!

The club has its priorities wrong if it wants to celebrate missing the Grand Final for two years in a row on % when we had it in our control. 

Its no wonder the men's team 'drinks its own bathwater' when the club has a 'celebrate a non-achievement' mindset.

MFC should listen to Daisy and her players. 

Edited by Lucifer's Hero
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can someone explain to me what the go is regarding the Katie Brennan tackle?

More specifically, I thought it was a pretty textbook case of a sling tackle and given it's her second offence of a similar nature, I can't see any reason why anyone would reverse the ruling, although I can totally see why the Bulldogs would be appealing the decision.

The issue I have is that a sling tackle in the AFL for men can result in suspension.... but why was Brennan's tackle determined as reckless or something that would only result in a fine in the Mens' comp?  I understand that due to the nature of the women's comp that fines are not part of the tribunal process (given it's not fully professional) but Brennan slung the player to the ground and they had their arms pinned. It's unfortunate but it was excessive force as per interpretation of the rules IMO.

Did Michael Christian classify it too leniently? or did he classify it appropriately to enable the correct penalty for the AFLW comp?

Now it seems like the Dogs and Brennan are claiming discrimination with the Human Rights commission because if her ruling was interpreted for the mens comp she would only have copped a fine, but in this comp she if it was classified using a penalty in the Men's comp, would she have copped an even larger suspension than the 1 to 2 week which would have been a massive suspension in a 7 week comp. 

Thoughts??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Ouch! said:

Can someone explain to me what the go is regarding the Katie Brennan tackle?

More specifically, I thought it was a pretty textbook case of a sling tackle and given it's her second offence of a similar nature, I can't see any reason why anyone would reverse the ruling, although I can totally see why the Bulldogs would be appealing the decision.

The issue I have is that a sling tackle in the AFL for men can result in suspension.... but why was Brennan's tackle determined as reckless or something that would only result in a fine in the Mens' comp?  I understand that due to the nature of the women's comp that fines are not part of the tribunal process (given it's not fully professional) but Brennan slung the player to the ground and they had their arms pinned. It's unfortunate but it was excessive force as per interpretation of the rules IMO.

Did Michael Christian classify it too leniently? or did he classify it appropriately to enable the correct penalty for the AFLW comp?

Now it seems like the Dogs and Brennan are claiming discrimination with the Human Rights commission because if her ruling was interpreted for the mens comp she would only have copped a fine, but in this comp she if it was classified using a penalty in the Men's comp, would she have copped an even larger suspension than the 1 to 2 week which would have been a massive suspension in a 7 week comp. 

Thoughts??

I think you have understood it very well.

I don't know of the classifications these days but if Christian had classified it the same as Dangerfield's sling tackle late last year, Brennan would have got a week.  Same result but with less confusion.  WB could have appealed but on different grounds and we wouldn't have the Human Rights case that is now brewing.

Now it seems like it is 'the system' (ie two reprimands = one week suspension) that is the problem (ie different penalty to men's rules), rather than the incident.  I think it deserved a week but Christian should have called it for what it was. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

I think you have understood it very well.

I don't know of the classifications these days but if Christian had classified it the same as Dangerfield's sling tackle late last year, Brennan would have got a week.  Same result but with less confusion.  WB could have appealed but on different grounds and we wouldn't have the Human Rights case that is now brewing.

Now it seems like it is 'the system' (ie two reprimands = one week suspension) that is the problem (ie different penalty to men's rules), rather than the incident.  I think it deserved a week but Christian should have called it for what it was. 

Ok, so I wasn't missing anything.

After seeing how that tackle 'ended up' I don't think anyone should be surprised about the suspension. The intent however is based upon the training that these players do. The goal is to immobilise the player and either pin the ball to the player or force the ball to be released. I don't disagree with Brennan's comments that she executed the tackle exactly as she would have been taught at training, however pinning both arms, slinging and not giving the player the chance to protect themselves from impact cost her a spot in the Grand Final.

There has been no outrage in the media other than feelings for Brennan missing out on the biggest game of the season. I think everyone knows that tackle, whether in AFL or AFLW, is going to end up costing the player executing it. The men know the risks when they tackle and it turns out wrong,... Brennan and the AFLW know this now too. 

1 week in a  7 week comp = missing 14% of the season.  1 week out of 27 weeks is ~4%. That is the inequity between competitions.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Social Media

  • Match Previews, Reports & Articles

    THE BRIGHT SIDE by Whispering Jack

    I don’t often agree with Dermott Brereton but he came close to the mark last week when he labelled Melbourne a “team of downhill skiers” that works much harder offensively than it does defensively.  And he was looking at the bright side of the team’s game plan. That proposition has been clear since before the season started. It was obvious from the first JLT game against Richmond when the team leaked multiple goals in a short space of time as players gave metres away to opposition forwards.

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    CASEY VS THE AUSSIES by KC from Casey

    The Casey Demons played an exhibition match against an Australian Under 19 team at the MCG on Easter Saturday but the game was played with more than half an eye on the fact that whilst their senior counterpart was taking part in their AFL Round 5 game against St Kilda later that afternoon, they also had an assignment just four days later against Richmond.  The team, with 10 AFL Demons, opened strongly and dominated the first half to lead by four goals at the main break before taking most of

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Casey Articles

    EASTER BUNNIES by George on the Outer

    Easter is supposed to be an occasion of hope, revival and ultimately celebration.  But for the Demon supporters it was none of these as yet again their team was made Easter Bunnies by the Saints. With the exception of Christian Salem, there was not a single winner on the ground.  The danger for the Demons was giving the Saints their own hope and enthusiasm by conceding early goals.  That is exactly what happened in the first quarter, although with some ridiculous frees from the umpires clos

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

    MARCHING IN by The Oracle

    The most embarrassing loss of the 2018 season (perhaps aside from the Preliminary Final) for Melbourne was the one it suffered in Round 15 against lowly St Kilda. The Demons came into the game as a red hot favourite but were embarrassed by the Saints' speed and willingness to take the contest right up to them for virtually the full four quarters. It was a defeat that they were to bemoan for the remainder of the season. Their arrogance in going into the game and taking an opponent lightly was a c

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    RELENTLESS by KC from Casey

    The Casey Demons returned to the winning list with an emphatic 54 point victory over a limp North Melbourne VFL combination at Casey Fields on Saturday. Smarting from last week’s thrashing at Box Hill, the Demons came out of the blocks intent on redeeming themselves for their embarrassing start to the 2019 campaign.  After a brief early bout of inaccuracy, the goals flowed as a result of relentless pressure applied to the visitors who were constantly forced into error. The pleasing thi

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Casey Articles

    TO A “T” by George on the Outer

    Thursday night football - not something Melbourne FC are accustomed to doing, especially after barely garnering a Friday night game for years. Yet with this opportunity, the Demons soundly beat the Swans at the SCG and put their season back on Track. This was not only a game of mental toughness, since the Demons had so far failed to win a game in 2019 and faced possibly a season ending prospect of 0-4, should they have failed in Sydney.  History was against them, and Buddy Frankli

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

    SWANSONG by Whispering Jack

    They said that in 2019, the Melbourne Football Club was going to take its game to another level but we were never prepared for the level the club is reaching as it approaches the fourth round of the season holding up the entire AFL ladder in a match that could be its swansong for the year.    We were meant to be premiership contenders, not playing off for a wooden spoon which is what will be the case unless there is a sudden and dramatic turn around in our fortunes!    And whilst there

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    A DAY TO FORGET by KC from Casey

    The Casey Demons started the 2019 in unimpressive fashion with a 62 point loss to the  Box Hill Hawks at Box Hill City Oval. It was a total contrast to their 2018 opening when they monstered the Coburg Lions but the circumstances were entirely different. Twelve months ago, the Demons were able to go into the match with a large contingent of AFL listed players while yesterday, they went into the game with 12 Melbourne players, mostly inexperienced.  They were also hampered by the AFL sc

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Casey Articles

    2019 IS NOT 2018 by George on the Outer

    Seems like an obvious statement doesn’t it?   Yet the MFC coaching staff/team seem to have forgotten to change their calendars on January 1st. A 3 goal loss against the equal bottom side in the competition and now with a 0-3 record for the current season, it should be obvious that things have changed from 2018.  Not so on the field, as Melbourne continue to play the style which got them to a Preliminary final.   Once again the Demons saw 20 goals scored against them for the game.

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

    THE NIGHT OF THE TORTOISES by The Oracle

    Friday night sees two clubs of which a great deal was expected in 2019, facing off in the battle of the slow starting tortoises. Both have had calamitous starts to the season and are sitting at 0-2. One of them will, by the end of the evening, be seeing their season slipping away from their grasp.   Both clubs are playing without confidence and without purpose. The Demons, who had the best-performed attack of all clubs last year, managed to convert 73 entries inside their forward 50 metre a

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    THE CAT RUN by George on the Outer

    It truly became a “Cat Run” with an 80 point win to the home side, an outcome that had us wondering what happened to the Demons of 2018 when they got to a Preliminary final on the basis of their “brand” of contested football?   Well that part hasn’t changed any, since the likes of Clayton Oliver can win the ball 44 times in a game including 15 clearances, Angus Brayshaw racks up 33 touches with Jack Viney chipping in for 27 of this own.  In the ruck Max Gawn had 53 hitouts on the night, and

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

    REDEMPTION? by the Oracle

    How much should we be making out of Melbourne’s opening round loss on its home ground against an unfancied team from interstate in Port Adelaide?  The game was barely over before the excuses were coming out that about the lack of preparation of the team, the fact that some players were playing injured or unfit and unable to handle the humidity and the heat, the team’s lack of run and spread, the lack of experience and having too many key players injured or (in the case of Steven May) suspen

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

×
×
  • Create New...