Demonland Player of the Year - Round 17

[Demonland 72,236]

Cast those votes please - 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 ...

[warren dean 193]

6. Lewis - composed and used the ball well

5. Vince - clearly beat his man - not many did tonight

4. Hunt - great run and that goal!!

3. Kennedy Harris - got a lot of it

2. Hibberd - was disappointing with his ball use and a little fumbly but was still better than most

1. Melksham - kept us in it in the first half

[spirit of norm smith 16,478]

6 Hunt  

100% heart, great goal, ran all night 

5 Lewis

got the pill, battled in, needs support

4 Frost

beat everyone he was on, quietened Walker, ran hard

3 Melksham 

Kicked the goals, battled hard, setup 2 chances both fuc&@$ed up by Garlett 

2 Hibberd

Smart, ran hard, cleared the footy out of the 50 about 20 times 

1 petracca

always does the right option, battled in, classy goal

Apologies to no one 

Then others were down... 16 strugglers & passengers.  Very very disappointing.  

 

[joeboy 3,166]

6 - Lewis ( composed and assured all game )

5 - Hunt ( has X factor in spades )

4 - Hibberd ( got lots of the ball but was surprisingly wasteful )

3 - Kennedy-Harris ( finally brought some of his Casey form to the table )

2 - Melksham ( for a fine first half )

1 - Wagner ( showed grit and endeavour)

[spirit of norm smith 16,478]

Sorry Vince was ineffective and undisciplined. Not even close to one of our best.  

Wagner fumbled and cost us. Not the worst but was frustrating. His failure in marking contest in the last quarter cost us any momentum. 

Edited July 15, 2017 by spirit of norm smith
X

[GM11 781]

6.Lewis

5.Hunt

4.Hibberd

3.Melksham

2.Oliver

1.Vince

 

[CityDee 738]

6.Lewis

5. Wagner

4. Hunt

3 . Hibberd

2. Melksham

1. Hogan 

[chook fowler 19,459]

Lewis

Hunt

JKH

O MAC

Melksham

Hibberd

 

[Big Demon 197]

6. Hunt - worked his but off for four quarters

5. Vince - one of our few winners on the ground and came in with the right intensity

4. Lewis - Composed thoughout

3. Wagner - Good through out

2. Hibberd - Had to cover for others but worked hard

1. ANB - Had spark and touch was generally good

 

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,217]

6. Vince clearly beat his opponent

5. Hunt

4. Kennedy-Harris

3. Lewis

2. Petracca

1. Wagner

[warren dean 193]

6 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Sorry Vince was ineffective and undisciplined. Not even close to one of our best.  

 

Until the time he went off with 5 minutes to play in the third quarter Sloane had 8 disposals.  Vince did his job very well. 

[Demon Jack 6,921]

6. Hunt - Was in absolutely everything. Some of his kicks forward weren't too flash (he wasn't alone there) but his run and that legendary torpedo gets him the chocolates this week.

5. Lewis - Close to his best game of the season. Didn't miss many targets or fumbled the ball much on a very slippery night.

4. Hibberd - Wasteful going forward at times but his endeavour and rebound from defence isn't doing any harm for his case to be one of the best recruits of recent time. Very strong chance of taking out the B&F this year provided he can catch up to Clarry.

3. Melksham - Proving to be a surprise packet up forward with his three first half goals. Was very creative at times as well in setting up shots for his teammates. Building very nicely at the right time of the season.

2. ANB - 23 odd touches at nearly 85% efficiency. Putting together a very fine patch of form in the absence of our midfield warriors. 

1. JKH - Well done young man. Started fairly slowly and made some poor errors but improved as the game went on. Deserves another couple of weeks in the team based on tonight.

Honerable mention to Bernie who clearly beat Sloane but misses out on votes due to another immature brain fade. Jetta was also good on Betts during the first half but couldn't maintain it once Adelaide really put the foot down.

Edited July 15, 2017 by Demon Jack

[John Dee 445]

6. Hunt

5. Lewis

4. Melksham

3. Wagner

2. Hibberd

1. Kennedy-Harris

[jane02 3,748]

6. Hunt

5. Lewis

4. Vince

3. Hibberd

2. Melksham

1. Neal Bullen

[Pennant St Dee 13,241]

6. Lewis - stood up in trying conditions and was composed 

5. Hunt - worked hard all night and will be great when he gets more composed delivering inside 50

4. Oliver - started slowly but once he got his hands dirty was one of the main reasons we got back into it

3. Vince - 1 brain fade which will hurt us next week but given 1 job to do and did it convincingly 

2. Melksham - worked his arse off and rewarded for his efforts 

1. Nibbler & Trac - both were factors 1 for sheer effort and contested work and the other for showing smarts, standing up physically in the contest and not panicking under pressure. 

Edited July 15, 2017 by Pennant St Dee
Spelling

[whatwhat say what 22,783]

It's always harder to make this call after watching on tv

6 - Hunt
5 - Lewis
4 - Hibberd
3 - Melksham
2 - Vince
1 - JKH

[layzie 33,865]

6 - Lewis

5 - Hunt

4 - Hibberd

3 - Melksham

2 - Oliver

1 - Vince

[Dee-licious 1,953]

6 - Hunt - 27 touches, 10 contested, 8 rebound 50's 5 inside 50's. 733 meters gained. I was worried that he wasnt going to get back (this season) to pre knocked out form. All it took was to play Adelaide again to reset. W

5 - Hibberd - 779 meters gained, 11 intercept possessions. He and Laird (who will go AA) basically had the same game (eerily similar) and Laird's is another game to add to his AA crown. It is tough coming back from injury and getting into AA contention because certain players are already cemented. But will be interesting to see if he makes the squad of 40. 

4 - Oliver - was going to go Lewis, but I think Oliver's game has been underplayed. Leading clearance and contested player on the ground. He is a second year player and without him I dont think we would be in the 8. Just found a way to win the contest.

3 - Lewis - The Lewis insurance policy paid off again. Just looked like he was playing at a different tempo. Sees what is happening and helps our boys get to the right position. 

2. ANB - Toss up between him and JKH. 11 contested possies, 5 inside 50's, 24 pressure acts, 6 tackles, he is getting better and better and I think a few clubs (Adelaide included) will be asking him if he is happy playing half forward flank for the Dees. 

1 - JKH - did not see that happening. Started slowly and then bang in the second half! 20 pressure acts, 10 contested possies, 5 tackles. Really played with some freedom. Will be interesting next week with Tyson back (maybe Viney), then Jones, then Salem what happens with JKH, but done himself no harm. 

Special mention to Petracca (much better second half), Melksham (3 goals), Vince (tagging), Oscar (golden paw), and Jetta (keeping a good Eddie down). 

[dee-tox 4,835]

6. Lewis

5. Hibberd

4. Hunt

3. Clarry

2. Melksham

1. ANB

[TRIGON 4,783]

6 Lewis

5 Hunt

4 Hibberd

3 ANB

2 Oliver 

1 Petracca

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,842]

6.  Hunt.

5. Lewis

4. Oscar

3. Melkshem 

2. ANB

1. Vince

Honorable mentions to JKH, Hibbard, Jetta, Hogan, Frost, Smith and Kent for effort and endevor.  Although he didn't get a heap of the pill or use it very well when he did, I did thought Kent's running and tackling were pretty good, typified by his tackle that ended Slone's night (not because it ended his night, but the ferocity og the tackle).  It's a really pitty that Kent got injured, because he might just have been starting to find form.  I find the malign on this forum at present somewhat difficult to understand, he was injured in the off season and has struggled to find his top form, but at his best, Kent can be a pretty good player for us.  I think it's somewhat of a reality that not all players can be in form all the time, so I'm not about to pay out on them for one bad season.

Edited July 15, 2017 by Rodney (Balls) Grinter

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,842]

8 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

6 Hunt  

100% heart, great goal, ran all night 

5 Lewis

got the pill, battled in, needs support

4 Frost

beat everyone he was on, quietened Walker, ran hard

3 Melksham 

Kicked the goals, battled hard, setup 2 chances both fuc&@$ed up by Garlett 

2 Hibberd

Smart, ran hard, cleared the footy out of the 50 about 20 times 

1 petracca

always does the right option, battled in, classy goal

Apologies to no one 

Then others were down... 16 strugglers & passengers.  Very very disappointing.  

 

Frost had one of his worst games for the year.  Tried hard and dared to take the game on as always, but a bit like Tom McDonald last night, almost every time they tried to get around an opponent, they got caught and turned it over, he also fumbled and couldn't control the slipery ball very well.

To say that we had passengers is laughable.  Their system and ball movement was clearly better than ours and they hurt us far more when they had the ball at times, but that doesn't make the other guys that pulled on the boots for us passengers.  Despite what the players and coachest will say, I really do think we are missing our A team on ball side badley.  Take Dangerfeild, Selwood and Duncan out of Geelong and they would have been beaten as badly or worse against the Crows last night.  That we were almost in the game for patches last night is a credit to ALL the guys that run out on the park for us.

[CBDees 3,167]

6. Hunt

5. Oliver

4. Lewis 

3. Melksham

2. Petracca

1. ANB

 

[P-man 13,366]

6. Lewis

5. Hunt

4. Hibberd

3. ANB

2. Oliver

1. JKH

[Deeoldfart 8,035]

6.  Lewis  -  four quality quarters where his experience and leadership shone through.  Best game for our Club. 

5.  Hunt  -  ran himself into the ground, topped off by GOTY.

4.  Oliver  -  slowish start, but worked into the game and was a key influence in our mini-revival.

3.  Hibberd  -  more of what we've seen from Hibbo all year, but without some of the classy finishing.

2.  ANB  -  got a fair bit of the pill through sheer hard work and grunt, and ball use is getting much better.  Really starting to look like he 'belongs' at this level.

1.  Melksham  - Our best forward on the night.  Another who played his best game for the Club.

Also thought Wagner, JKH, Petracca and Vince were solid contriburors. Very pleased for JKH.