Changes v Adelaide

[Deecisive 1,709]

I think stretch is a definite out, he has tried but not delivered enough to keep Tyson out. Pederson, while he did a couple of good things he needs to make room for Jack Watts if he is available. I am sure that Watts would have done enough had he been fit to equal of better Pederson's effort today.

 

[monoccular 17,433]

39 minutes ago, dee-tox said:

I've gone from thinking Stretch was a sure-handed linkman with decent disposal to barely VFL.

I maintain the faith though as our top players get back he may well go back to Casey.  

[picket fence 17,181]

30 minutes ago, bing181 said:

But isn't that the problem? He's now being asked to play also as an insider, and then with the absence of insiders, there's less opportunity to stand back and be that linkman. Also, he does have decent/good disposal, but only when he has time.

It's an interesting one, not sure of the solution.

Needs to build a stronger body IMV! Retain but needs another 5 kg of Muscle and definition IMV

[Diamond_Jim 12,598]

Just now, picket fence said:

Nup Smith to stay, Stretch not up to it 

Outs Stretch , Kent ( limited output today)

In Tyson, Watts!

think you could be right .... there is obviously something Goody sees in Smith that we have yet to find.

Noticed him in a one on one marking comp where his job was to spoil and it wasn't pretty

[Mdemonski3 174]

23 minutes ago, Garbo said:

other than the obvious outs of smith, Kent and Stretch. I would also look at resting Hunt to me he looks to have been struggling with something since the West Coast game. 2 of those 4 go out for Watts and Tyson. Pederson also possibly out for balance reasons.

Not sure if serious. Drop Hunt?

Come on man.....you're better than that.

[At the break of Gawn 4,460]

Don't think Watts will play. I reckon his hammy will need another week. 

Kent will go out for Ben Ken I'd say.

[picket fence 17,181]

Just now, At the break of Gawn said:

Don't think Watts will play. I reckon his hammy will need another week. 

Kent will go out for Ben Ken I'd say.

Yep a good  call!

[Diamond_Jim 12,598]

1 minute ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Don't think Watts will play. I reckon his hammy will need another week. 

Kent will go out for Ben Ken I'd say.

Unfortunately you could be right also

Hammies don't do well with 3-4 hour flights so they may not risk him.

Pity because we need everyone we got to face down Adelaide

 

[olisik 4,060]

Surely Trengove for Kent

[Bring Back Barassi 552]

Kent added butchering the ball to his talent for slow decision making under pressure, must go

[hardtack 10,555]

Possibly Kent and Stretch to make way for Kennedy and JKH. 

[bandicoot 1,395]

1 hour ago, Jibroni said:

Not sure what to make of Hogans performance today. He really struggled for obvious reasons and maybe needs a week a Casey to regain some match fitness/form?

How will he gain more fitness at Casey than Melbourne? 

[dl4e 5,851]

Out would be stretch and in tyson. Yes another week for watts.

[The Swimming Dee 1,904]

Kent has to go out. Cannot or does not bend over to pick the ball up, cannot take a mark above his head and again shirked several contests today.

I don't think he adds anything to the team. Hardly ever wins a one on one. Always takes the easy option.

[rpfc 28,540]

As much as I disliked Kents game - he looked a beat slower - like Wagenr last week.

Wagner stepped up from a F-rated game to a solid C so I assume Kent can make a similar adjustment. Stretch disappointed again. Smith has something about him I like but he didn't do much. Melksham works hard but has a bit of Simon Godfrey about him.

Keep Petracca in the middle please! He makes Lewis much better when he falls over and REQUIRES a powerful magician to help him get the ball out of the congestion.

 

Watts back please for Pedersen. I think we are tall enough but understand if MC see Watts as a small.

Tyson back for Stretch.

Edited July 9, 2017 by rpfc

[Guest]

To be honest it feels like some time since I have seen so many poor players in an MFC win.  

Given that Hogan needs a few runs as does big Maxy, and that we had four or five really poor performances it is a fair effort to come away with the win.

You probably need to give Smith and Kent another run.  Stretch hasn't been in great form and he is a limited player and needs to make way I think.  Kent and possibly Melksham.....both had some under 12 moments today. Melkshams last quarter probably saves him and he can play a variety of roles.  Bernie I think is on borrowed time....his decision making and radar is off and I wonder how plugged in he is at times.  The Pedo show probably finishes when Watts get back, particularly now that Plugger is doing great things.

 

Edited July 9, 2017 by Guest

[praha 11,240]

I'm not massive on Kent but I feel he deserves another week. He can be a dumb footballer at times, but I feel that today he was genuinely trying to work himself into the game and apply the pressure we expect from a small forward. He kept the contest going a few times and while he was often beaten, he gets into position, which I think is very important. He has the smarts to be in an appealing position for a delivery. He seems very low on confidence atm and may very well have his foot out the door, but I do feel he's on a learning path. I can see him contributing next week.

[deeflog 679]

1 hour ago, dee-tox said:

I've gone from thinking Stretch was a sure-handed linkman with decent disposal to barely VFL.

As have i

he was awful today

[spirit of norm smith 16,478]

Outs J-Smith & Kent

ins. Tyson & Kennedy

Watts is another week yet. 

[At Least I Saw a Flag 5,251]

39 minutes ago, The Swimming Dee said:

Kent has to go out. Cannot or does not bend over to pick the ball up, cannot take a mark above his head and again shirked several contests today.

I don't think he adds anything to the team. Hardly ever wins a one on one. Always takes the easy option.

You forgot his habit of going to ground. 

[In Harmes Way 7,796]

A few factors influencing team selection this week IMO:

- Darwin will have a bit more humidity, shouldn't go too tall

- I believe we were flat against the Swans due to both 4 games in 18 days coupled with the trip home from Perth. I think we need to think selection over a two week block and bring some fresh legs in against Port in a fortnight. Perhaps give Watts another week if he's NQR.

- we won't get better if our fringe players don't get a fair crack at AFL level. Oscar is now showing the fruits of perseverance, despite the fact DL continuously dropped him and the FD showed faith. That said, I think Stretch has had a fair run.

only 1 change for me this week - Tyson in for Stretch. Watts and Salem fresh legs for Port next week (and Viney as well, knowing him).

[monoccular 17,433]

1 hour ago, picket fence said:

Needs to build a stronger body IMV! Retain but needs another 5 kg of Muscle and definition IMV

presumably this fragmented discussion refers to Hannon?

Great pick up and versatile tough strong player who can snag a goal from nothing. 

[Old Bear 388]

2 hours ago, DemonAndrew said:

You don't play key players in the vfl.

OUT: Pedersen, Stretch

IN: Watts, Tyson

Without Pederson throwing his body into every contest in the last quarter there is no way we would have won it

 

 

[The Swimming Dee 1,904]

5 minutes ago, bingers said:

You forgot his habit of going to ground. 

I did forget about that. In the 1st or 2nd quarter he lost a contest by slipping and going to ground.

Another habit of his is over committing to the contest when going for tackles. The player with the ball just pivots and he might get one hand on them. 

The shirking of contests though is unforgivable. He has done it on many occasions this year.

Kent has been around for some time now. I don't see him as a best 22 player or developing into one.

He looks so wooden and overweight.

[JV7 2,351]

Just realised we play Adelaide on a 6 day break they have 8.. On all of our recent three 6 day breaks the opposition has always had the maximum break possible.. [censored]

Edited July 9, 2017 by JV7