Post Match Discussion - Round 12

[Pates 9,536]

44 minutes ago, Biffen said:

On Buckley,

I'm not sure he is a great manager of men.

I don't think he has ever had the confidence of his team .

It doesn't help that fast Eddy and guys like Gubby Allen make headlines .

No finals- No Buckley .

The irony is that Eddie, who probably has more love for Buckley than his own wife, has been the architect of destruction for Buckley's coaching career. Panicking that another club would snaffle up his golden boy he engineered what he thought would be the perfect change over, he failed to actually consider whether Buckley was ready for/good at coaching.

Untried coaches that don't go through the proper channels of learning the art and taking multiple roles at different clubs clearly don't seem to work.

I expect Buckley won't be there next year if they miss finals and I don't think it's all Nathan's fault.

[Cards13 9,117]

Was at the game, just watching replay for first time. I felt it in the day and replay confirms it, if we'd kicked into our fwd 50 with any kind of accuracy in the first qtr and a half we'd have been 5 goals in front. 

We were all over them, turn overs made them look good.

[jnrmac 18,914]

This is a pretty good love-in but there were two howlers that could have changed things dramatically. The first was our first goal and the pathetic handball from TMac to Viney. That could have been one of the biggest stuff ups of all time.

The second was the 50m penalty in the ast quarter when Bugg tapped the ball from Greenwood's hands. Luckily Greenwood missed the shot but that stupid act could have easily cost us the game. 

 

[rpfc 27,393]

Watching the replay of the fateful goal, who was the bloke that Watts ran past as he went for his 50m hard lead?

Taylor Adams.

I really hope that kid joins a successful club one day, he deserves it...

[Deestroy All 14,261]

3 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

This is a pretty good love-in but there were two howlers that could have changed things dramatically. The first was our first goal and the pathetic handball from TMac to Viney. That could have been one of the biggest stuff ups of all time.

The second was the 50m penalty in the ast quarter when Bugg tapped the ball from Greenwood's hands. Luckily Greenwood missed the shot but that stupid act could have easily cost us the game. 

 

Tyson's last kick was the biggest howler. Kicked it nowhere near the boundary line, almost into the corridor and to a nest of Magpies. It was ridiculous whether it was intended or basic skill error. 

If Hibberd didn't spoil DeGoey he was lining up to put them in front. 

 

Enter Harmes and Watts...

[jumbo returns 6,484]

I'm a tad peeved that there's quite a few Watts' bashers on this forum who are sitting back saying that they're 'happy for him' and this was the 'redemption' blah blah blah

Jack Watts is more to this footy team than that goal yesterday - he shows human leadership, determination, has an iron will and an ability to turn off from puerile, unrelentless vitriol

That goal was Jack Watts doing what he does best - the poise, the class, the finish

 

Edited June 14, 2017 by george_on_the_outer
baiting

[Engorged Onion 9,239]

17 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

This is a pretty good love-in but there were two howlers that could have changed things dramatically. The first was our first goal and the pathetic handball from TMac to Viney. That could have been one of the biggest stuff ups of all time.

The second was the 50m penalty in the ast quarter when Bugg tapped the ball from Greenwood's hands. Luckily Greenwood missed the shot but that stupid act could have easily cost us the game. 

 

Im sure that'll be covered in their review pal...

[DistrACTION Jackson 6,398]

2 hours ago, sisso said:

Loudest roar I've heard from the Demons fans when Watts kicked the sealer since 2000....the Southern at the punt road end end was shaking!

I was down there behind the goals as well. It was the loudest I've ever heard at a game.

[monoccular 16,017]

8 hours ago, jnrmac said:

Anyone else notice how awkward Watts looked when he bounced the ball? My heart was in my mouth....

No.  Looked in full command.  The most mature and composed I have seen him 

6 hours ago, DemonOX said:

Can't believe we r SIXTH on the ladder which is the first time since 2006. 

Hopefully we stay there for the rest of the season. 

Preferably higher

53 minutes ago, Pates said:

The irony is that Eddie, who probably has more love for Buckley than his own wife, has been the architect of destruction for Buckley's coaching career. Panicking that another club would snaffle up his golden boy he engineered what he thought would be the perfect change over, he failed to actually consider whether Buckley was ready for/good at coaching.

Untried coaches that don't go through the proper channels of learning the art and taking multiple roles at different clubs clearly don't seem to work.

I expect Buckley won't be there next year if they miss finals and I don't think it's all Nathan's fault.

Interesting that when the Pies have lost the criticism has been that the players are not playing for their coach, and when they win "we did it for Bucks"!

So yesterday were they not "playing for Bucks"?

Edited June 13, 2017 by monoccular

[buck_nekkid 5,460]

11 hours ago, Devil is in the Detail said:

Great follow up kick.

He did this so often with us.  Big spekkie followed up with an instant turnover.

It was like school kick to kick.  He knew it was coming to T-mac (our predictable exit strategy) so he just set himself for the easiest hanger of all time.

He seems to be doing OK at the pies.  His call to walk.  Great he is part of such a 'successful outfit' with them.

[Cards13 9,117]

What's with Howes ginger pube beard?

Hibberd.. best trade we have ever made, he is a gun. Reads the play incredibly well, hard and committed and has brilliant skills. Underrated.

[buck_nekkid 5,460]

In the first half, I was quite frustrated that they seemed to be guarding grass and watching (with tackles not sticking) and us being completely smashed in the contested marks.

I knew we were up and about in the third quarter when the guys sprinted to cover a fat-side spread.  All three of the collingwood players had Dees right with them, making a series of contests rather than a simple transition.  When we play like that, we are a different side.  We make contests and often win or halve them.  It allows us to set up our defensive structures at a minimum.

[Cards13 9,117]

Buggy and ANB both do nice little bits and pieces throughout games.

Bugg needs to get in the end of a few and finally this week he did.

ANB need to set up the links and be part of the links and has done that well recently.

[binman 37,799]

50 minutes ago, Cards13 said:

Was at the game, just watching replay for first time. I felt it in the day and replay confirms it, if we'd kicked into our fwd 50 with any kind of accuracy in the first qtr and a half we'd have been 5 goals in front. 

We were all over them, turn overs made them look good.

I've said it before and ill say it again our biggest issue is our foot skills. Way too many kicks miss simple targets atm for us to go all the way. Perhaps it is handling the adrenaline of the starts of games rather than not being switched on. In this context it was interesting to read goody saying he was deliberately taking a low key approach to the the preparation for this game.

[Jaded No More 57,691]

3 hours ago, sisso said:

Loudest roar I've heard from the Demons fans when Watts kicked the sealer since 2000....the Southern at the punt road end end was shaking!

I've been sitting in the same stand for near on 12 years. First time ever every single supporter got out of their chair and was jumping around. It was seriously the most pure moment of joy I've felt from our supporters in my time. 

[Willmoy1947 3,762]

9 hours ago, jnrmac said:

Anyone else notice how awkward Watts looked when he bounced the ball? My heart was in my mouth....

Yes, i did, he bounced it with his left hand i think. A little unusual for a right hander.

[dees189227 10,710]

6 minutes ago, willmoy said:

Yes, i did, he bounced it with his left hand i think. A little unusual for a right hander.

Could you imagine the media today if he stuffed that up completely and missed that goal? Could you imagine the outrage on here. This is why I'm so happy for him and he was composed. 

[Deemented Are Go! 3,581]

1 hour ago, jnrmac said:

This is a pretty good love-in but there were two howlers that could have changed things dramatically. The first was our first goal and the pathetic handball from TMac to Viney. That could have been one of the biggest stuff ups of all time.

The second was the 50m penalty in the ast quarter when Bugg tapped the ball from Greenwood's hands. Luckily Greenwood missed the shot but that stupid act could have easily cost us the game. 

 

The first goal was Bugg, dude

[Red and Bluebeard 2,027]

18 minutes ago, willmoy said:

Yes, i did, he bounced it with his left hand i think. A little unusual for a right hander.

The Robbie Flower special ...

[Sir Why You Little 34,422]

12 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

Could you imagine the media today if he stuffed that up completely and missed that goal? Could you imagine the outrage on here. This is why I'm so happy for him and he was composed. 

But he never looked like he was going to miss.

Many on here forget that Jack was also a gun basketball player at school

[In Harmes Way 7,477]

3 hours ago, sisso said:

Loudest roar I've heard from the Demons fans when Watts kicked the sealer since 2000....the Southern at the punt road end end was shaking!

Yep, me and my boy included. I think it was the first time my boy (11 yo) was truly proud to be a dees supporter

[Phadraig 760]

The pies supporters are saying Collingwood should make a complaint about Watts goading their cheersquad, anyone see what he did?

[hardtack 10,126]

3 hours ago, Ted Fidge said:

Ron Burg's description was spot on. Time stood still. That's what it felt like at the ground. Watching on replay I was surprised by how many players were in our forward 50. At the time it felt like he was the only one on the ground.

A moment that will live for years.

(And for those not at the G ... yes it was loud. It was as cathartic for us Demons fans as it must have been for Jack!)

My son and I were seated a few rows back midway between the goal and point posts in that pocket. It was strange as Watts jogged into the 50 and towards goal, there was an eerie silence and even the Pies players seemed a bit mesmerised and weren't making moves to shut him down. Then when he took that kick and it sailed through, the whole place erupted! That goes down as one of the most memorable football moments in my 65 years; seriously!

Edited June 13, 2017 by hardtack

[Willmoy1947 3,762]

Perhaps while Eddy is looking for an apology from 360, he could do one on behalf of his own backyard  to Neale. Too much to ask for the walking Broady apology book.....

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,089]

42 minutes ago, Jaded said:

I've been sitting in the same stand for near on 12 years. First time ever every single supporter got out of their chair and was jumping around. It was seriously the most pure moment of joy I've felt from our supporters in my time. 

Biggest roar since 2006 elimination final win. That  Watts goal is something very special, stoked to have witnessed it! The TV coverage doesn't do justice to the noise at the ground