Will Minson

[Dwight Schrute 16,722]

6 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

We don't need a backup ruckman, we have one, Mahoney said fwd/ruck if we can find one, Hannatth was delisted for a reason, MFC could have easily delisted Spencer but they didn't, that should tell you something

I believe strongly we need one more while King develops, if Max and Jake get injuries the quality of our ruck stocks is a real concern, one more on the cheap to replace young king who i suspect will be delisted i think would be a wise move, doesn't have to be Hanneth or Minson, could be someone else, but i really think the club should consider bringing in one more ruckman through the trade/draft period.

if we can get a forward ruck as well that'd be great but i suspect Pedo has been re-signed because they didn't feel there were any really good options open to them in this regard.

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

On 10/6/2016 at 10:58 AM, hemingway said:

As there does not seem to be much choice, I would not be averse to Minson. 

We do not want another "development" tall. 

Minson is an intelligent and experienced ruckman that knows his craft and his limitations. Not ideal but not a stupid choice. He has a bit of aggro and can take a mark around the ground. 

^ THIS., we are looking for a stop gap. Developing rucks takes ages. Max has taken 7 years. 

 

Surprised by the negativity by know it alls like Wiseblood and others who contribute nothing but smart ar$se comments. He's hardly be the worst addition if you'd get him for nothing. If Max gets injured and spencer has to ruck, we are f.....n stuffed. 

[ManDee 7,073]

1 hour ago, Ron Burgundy said:

 

Better still - perhaps we should get Colin Sylvia back to assist Gawn with the ruck duties.

 

He'd need one good pre-season I reckon. 

[hoopla 418]

10 hours ago, Satyriconhome said:

, MFC could have easily delisted Spencer but they didn't, that should tell you something

It tells me that we didn't see any options - and that we expected Frank to continue improving.

On the evidence of the VFL Grand Final - Minson is twice the ruckman Frank is - and he can mark.I think I think I'm right in saying that he played a fair chunk of his 190 games under Mc Cartney. If he wants to play - he'll be cheap.

He'd give Max a good workout at training !!

[Moonshadow 16,120]

Or we can start looking forward to Jeff White's son, Kalani, who must be about 10 now.

Edited October 7, 2016 by Moonshadow

[Ethan Tremblay 28,294]

5 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Or we can start looking forward to Jeff White's son, who must be about 16 now.

 I think his name is Khaleesi.

[dieter 3,325]

3 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

 I think his name is Khaleesi.

isn't that a virus?

[Moonshadow 16,120]

3 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

 I think his name is Khaleesi.

Did an edit after a Google search Eth.

[Ethan Tremblay 28,294]

5 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Did an edit after a Google search Eth.

Kalani. I was close. 

[P-man 13,154]

10 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Kalani. I was close. 

You've been watching too much Game of Thrones

I would feel confused if I ever met a male called Khaleesi.

[Adzman 2,085]

Spencer is under contract. If he wasn't I would consider minson. I don't see the value minson would bring with Spencer in the wings and pedo playing the role if 2nd ruck.

[Whispering_Jack 27,931]

40 minutes ago, Adzman said:

Spencer is under contract. If he wasn't I would consider minson. I don't see the value minson would bring with Spencer in the wings and pedo playing the role if 2nd ruck.

You can still trade out a player under contract, can't you? 

I think it's fairly clear that Spencer will only get his opportunities as an understudy to the AA ruckman. At this stage of his career, he might aspire to be more than that so if another club offered him the opportunity, he might agree to be traded out.

On the other hand, Minson is as close to the end as you can get and he might be happy to play second fiddle (given that he's the only AFL player who can also play the violin, it would be a great fit) for a year or so.

If this happens, then Melbourne wins in the trade because it would get a draft pick or player in exchange for Spencer and Minson would come for free as a FA.

Whatever the case, we would be looking to draft another younger ruckman to develop along with Mitch King for the future (I can't see us hanging on to Max King after three years as a rookie).

[Adzman 2,085]

1 hour ago, Whispering_Jack said:

You can still trade out a player under contract, can't you? 

I think it's fairly clear that Spencer will only get his opportunities as an understudy to the AA ruckman. At this stage of his career, he might aspire to be more than that so if another club offered him the opportunity, he might agree to be traded out.

On the other hand, Minson is as close to the end as you can get and he might be happy to play second fiddle (given that he's the only AFL player who can also play the violin, it would be a great fit) for a year or so.

If this happens, then Melbourne wins in the trade because it would get a draft pick or player in exchange for Spencer and Minson would come for free as a FA.

Whatever the case, we would be looking to draft another younger ruckman to develop along with Mitch King for the future (I can't see us hanging on to Max King after three years as a rookie).

Never said you couldn't trade out players. My opinion is purely based on signing Minson, not shifting other players on to justify him signing on.

[Satyriconhome 9,982]

I would support Minson if we signed him coz that means FD value him higher than I do, would still be tempted to eat scarf though

Edited October 8, 2016 by Satyriconhome

[Dwight Schrute 16,722]

2 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

I would support Minson if we signed him coz that means FD value him higher than I do, would still be tempted to eat scarf though

No Saty, i've already written to the MFC on twitter asking them to confirm they've enquired about Minson so that we can see you eat your scarf, no backing out now. 

[hoopla 418]

4 hours ago, Whispering_Jack said:

If this happens, then Melbourne wins in the trade because it would get a draft pick or player in exchange for Spencer and Minson would come for free as a FA

Like this WJ

On the evidence of the VFL Grand Final - we'd be better off with Minson in 2017 and probably 2018 as well.

After that you'd hope one of the Kings or a young 2016 draftee would better than either an ageing Minson or a mid age Spencer

Just hope another club sees something in Mr Spencer ( Some Mothers do 'ave em )! We might be able to do something with the very high pick we could get for him

[Satyriconhome 9,982]

1 hour ago, Abe said:

No Saty, i've already written to the MFC on twitter asking them to confirm they've enquired about Minson so that we can see you eat your scarf, no backing out now. 

Think I am safe, Jamar was dumped and he was in similar position to Minson, why would we then get Minson a year later, all this talk about another ruckman? Mahoney said fwd/ruck, though nothing would surprise me these days   Vickery to Hawthorm astounds me even given their past record on recycled players