WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - MICHAEL HIBBERD

[Uncle Fester 2,835]

Seems fair. Two quality players plus Weed, from a draft we didn't have a lot to offer. And hey, if one of the late picks or someone in the rookie draft turns out to be a gem , then we;ve not just won, but killed it dead.

[The Chazz 4,077]

3 minutes ago, billy2803 said:

No, we differ on list management ideas.

For a start, trade period hasn't finished, so I will reassess our draft strategy when I know what the final draft order will be.  I expect our draft order to change in some shape over the next 24 hours.

I also know that 12 months is a long time in football, and that upgrading Smith now, who is relatively a project player that has been in the system for 12 months, and Wagner, who has definitely shown "something" but let's see him do it again next year.

 

2 minutes ago, stuie said:

Smith>Pick 84

 

See bolded above Stuart...

Now go and annoy someone else.

[What 18,810]

Great addition.  Probably the best half back we have had in a decade. 

He and Hunt on each back flank are the perfect compliment to each other.

[stuie 7,374]

2 minutes ago, billy2803 said:

 

See bolded above Stuart...

Now go and annoy someone else.

 

20 minutes ago, stuie said:

Next move should be: Trade Dunn and 57 for Collingwood's pick 47. Use pick 47 in the draft and then upgrade Wagner and Smith.

 

Calm down mate. Maybe read some of my other posts, like the above.

 

[Bang Bang Bang 5,431]

Originally I thought Hibberd was worth an early 20s pick, so to get him for pick 29 and an upgrade of a later pick is a good result. 

I know Paul Roos had little to do with it, but Hibberd is a Roos-type player. Fans won't flock to get his number on their back but you can be sure he'll be a very useful role player for us for a number of years.

Also it's nice to see Petracca being so pro-Melbourne on his Twitter feed, even on his time off. Within minutes of the trade being completed he's on there welcoming Hibberd to the club. Dare I say it, 'bleeds red and blue' already.

[DeeSpencer 23,061]

I guess we folded which is a bit disappointing but we needed Hibberd in and to do the right thing by him, and we got a nice little steak knives upgrade.

Time to turn that upgrade plus Dunn plus next years 2nd rounder in to a top 30 pick this year. 

 

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Great result. The deal is fair and, while it leaves us without any early picks, it's good to see other posters realising that our first rounder from this draft is Weideman. Adding Lewis, Hibberd and the return of Melksham makes this a terrific trade period for us. 

Add in the fact we have signed up all our young players and the future looks bright. 

[Mazer Rackham 14,968]

Just now, DeeSpencer said:

I guess we folded which is a bit disappointing but we needed Hibberd in and to do the right thing by him, and we got a nice little steak knives upgrade.

Time to turn that upgrade plus Dunn plus next years 2nd rounder in to a top 30 pick this year. 

 

No necessarily. We might have decided to knock this deal over to leave time for doing others. Rather than still having horns locked with EFC at 11:45 tomorrow.

Spending pick 29 on Hibberd is hardly a disaster. "Money" well spent in fact.

[Devil is in the Detail 880]

1 minute ago, DeeSpencer said:

I guess we folded which is a bit disappointing but we needed Hibberd in and to do the right thing by him, and we got a nice little steak knives upgrade.

Time to turn that upgrade plus Dunn plus next years 2nd rounder in to a top 30 pick this year. 

 

We don't need to, we effectively picked up Lewis and Hibberd for our second rounder. Next years draft is stronger. Why would we burn next years 2nd rounder for a 2nd rounder in a weaker draft.

[Demon Jack 6,272]

Unless the recruiting team have their eyes on a certain player, I don't really see much need to trade back into the first/second round. Weideman is essentially our first pick this year and we have enough young guys at the club now as it is. 

[Maldonboy38 5,813]

33 minutes ago, stuie said:

Next move should be: Trade Dunn and 57 for Collingwood's pick 47. Use pick 47 in the draft and then upgrade Wagner and Smith.

 

Agree totally with this. Wagner showed enough and another preseason should add more. The more I see of Joel Smith the more he comes across as a real smokey who could be something unique. Add to this that Weideman is effectively our first round draft pick this year as well, and our inward changes are Lewis, Hibberd, Wagner, Weideman  Smith, and draft position 47. Very happy with this. 

Oops, forgot about Melksham who, although came to us via last year's trading, is in effective also an inward for this draft/trade period.

Edited October 18, 2016 by Maldonboy38
forgot Melksham

[Demonland 64,419]

Ok back to the Rockliff thread.

Too soon?

[DeeSpencer 23,061]

Just now, Devil is in the Detail said:

We don't need to, we effectively picked up Lewis and Hibberd for our second rounder. Next years draft is stronger. Why would we burn next years 2nd rounder for a 2nd rounder in a weaker draft.

I don't believe that's true. That gets said every year. This year they are saying it's a deep draft for outside runners in an even top 30 or so picks and that's what we need. Without a first rounder this year I think it's important to have a 2nd rounder because you have a higher chance of a kid you rate very highly slipping to your pick.

I also think the momentum of adding another quality skilled youngster is important and we can give this kid a good run at Casey in ideal development conditions. Staying ahead of the draft is a handy advantage as well, it boosts our list quality. 

All up I think the positives outweigh the negatives.

[stuie 7,374]

2 minutes ago, Maldonboy38 said:

Agree totally with this. Wagner showed enough and another preseason should add more. The more I see of Joel Smith the more he comes across as a real smokey who could be something unique. Add to this that Weideman is effectively our first round draft pick this year as well, and our inward changes are Lewis, Hibberd, Wagner, Weideman  Smith, and draft position 47. Very happy with this. 

Then delist Dawes, hopefully get a speedy mid with pick 47 and rookie list a key back and a ruckman.

 

[PaulRB 5,897]

12 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

Great addition.  Probably the best half back we have had in a decade. 

He and Hunt on each back flank are the perfect compliment to each other.

Totally agree, Hibberd's boot and Hunt's speed combined will help with the switch and opening teams upon the rebound. 

[DV8 2,271]

3 hours ago, Abe said:

There was a bit of talk around that Essendon wanted this years picks so they could package a few up and have a crack at O'meara

perhaps now that's not a factor they'll be more receptive to our 2017 pick, we need a deal breaker, because they will just wait this out and force our hand as it sits, we'd have to be willing to lose Hibberd to take that chance 

That makes sense, & likely Mahoney was aware of this...  It probably helped us, as the Hawks would be desperate to rejig their midfield with young guns.  Hence the cheap pick arrangement for Jordan.

[McQueen 17,862]

On 17 October 2016 at 1:52 PM, Petraccattack said:

Barrett says Hibberd will be traded for next years 2nd rounder.

Barrett got this wrong just as he did the Lewis deal of picks.

The bloke really has NFI and just drivels shyte for a living.

[Ungarieboy 353]

Another thought, is that rookies only need  to be put on for a 1 year minimum.  So using late round picks this year on upgrades also gives us a chance to bring in players (from a supposed weak draft) as rookies this year without committing to them for two years.

Also are the upgrades just a one year extension or do they then get the normal 2 year minimum of someone selected in the draft? 

[Bring Back Barassi 532]

15 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

I guess we folded which is a bit disappointing but we needed Hibberd in and to do the right thing by him, and we got a nice little steak knives upgrade.

 

Looks more like we met them half way

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Just now, McQueen said:

The bloke really has NFI and just drivels shyte for a living.

Barrett clearly gets his information from player managers who don't always (and shouldn't) know the details of what is being traded.

[DV8 2,271]

2 hours ago, Mickey said:

He's contracted 

thats worth zilch. he can walk because of the drugs saga. And a safe working environment.

 

 

 

[In Harmes Way 7,477]

10 minutes ago, Demonland said:

Ok back to the Rockliff thread.

Too soon?

Or the riddle thread???

[The Chazz 4,077]

8 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

I don't believe that's true. That gets said every year. This year they are saying it's a deep draft for outside runners in an even top 30 or so picks and that's what we need. Without a first rounder this year I think it's important to have a 2nd rounder because you have a higher chance of a kid you rate very highly slipping to your pick.

I also think the momentum of adding another quality skilled youngster is important and we can give this kid a good run at Casey in ideal development conditions. Staying ahead of the draft is a handy advantage as well, it boosts our list quality. 

All up I think the positives outweigh the negatives.

I'm certain that many people were saying last year that the 2016 draft was going to be a super draft.

[Mickey 4,172]

1 minute ago, DV8 said:

thats worth zilch. he can walk because of the drugs saga. And a safe working environment.

 

 

 

He wouldn't have. Hal Hunter may have been the only one who would. 

Edited October 18, 2016 by Mickey

[Lucifers Hero 36,984]

13 minutes ago, stuie said:

Then delist Dawes, hopefully get a speedy mid with pick 47 and rookie list a key back and a ruckman.

Collingwood will not give up 47 +/- high picks for Dunn...they need all the draft points they can get for their father/sons

The following comments don't relate to your posts stuie its for the people who put up all sorts of hypothetical pick trades. 

NOTE: draft points are a sliding scale and read this: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-10-19/indicative-2016-afl-draft-order

ie #28 = 703 points

# 47 = 316 points

# 57 = 182 points

# 59 = 158 points

And, hopefully for the last time, a club (with some exceptions) cannot have more draft picks than vacant list spots!!

Edit: we can use picks 102 and 120 to upgrade Wagner/Smith.

Edited October 18, 2016 by Lucifer's Hero